WEBVTT

NOTE
This file was generated by Descript <www.descript.com>

00:00:00.500 --> 00:00:00.820
Hey, everybody.

00:00:00.820 --> 00:00:04.079
Welcome to a bonus episode
of , you may be listening to The

00:00:04.080 --> 00:00:08.039
Virtual Couch, maybe Waking Up to
Narcissism, maybe even Love ADHD.

00:00:08.169 --> 00:00:11.030
However you arrived, first
and foremost, thank you.

00:00:11.450 --> 00:00:12.419
I am Tony Overbay.

00:00:12.419 --> 00:00:15.940
I'm a licensed marriage and family
therapist and host of the, the

00:00:15.940 --> 00:00:18.519
aforementioned podcast, and I'm
really glad that you are here today

00:00:18.519 --> 00:00:20.860
because I wanna share something
a little different with you.

00:00:21.590 --> 00:00:25.050
Some of you may remember, if you've been
around for a little while, that back

00:00:25.050 --> 00:00:28.980
in twenty-twenty two and twenty-twenty
three, my daughter Sydney and I started

00:00:28.980 --> 00:00:31.090
a podcast called Murder on the Couch.

00:00:31.799 --> 00:00:35.860
, The concept , was pretty simple: take
true crime cases and run them through

00:00:35.860 --> 00:00:41.150
a therapist lens, or maybe even more
specifically, I like true crime a lot.

00:00:41.210 --> 00:00:44.740
I listen to podcasts, I watch
documentaries and interrogation videos,

00:00:44.740 --> 00:00:49.960
and I find myself continually wondering
and wishing that I had that person or

00:00:49.960 --> 00:00:54.190
that couple on my couch, so I could
really try and understand not just

00:00:54.530 --> 00:00:56.760
what happened, , but really the why.

00:00:57.460 --> 00:00:59.420
W-what was going on psychologically?

00:00:59.440 --> 00:01:04.450
What was the runway or the ramp that led
up to why the person did what they did?

00:01:04.450 --> 00:01:07.450
Because I think there are so
many variables that go into why

00:01:07.450 --> 00:01:08.810
people do the things that they do.

00:01:09.390 --> 00:01:13.759
What does it say about shame, or their
attachment, or their family system?

00:01:14.359 --> 00:01:18.279
Did they have a, a hole in their
need-for-validation bucket, so that

00:01:18.279 --> 00:01:22.769
bucket was never gonna be filled, or did
they have such deep dad issues that it

00:01:22.769 --> 00:01:25.859
wasn't gonna matter who they interacted
with in their personal lives, , there

00:01:25.859 --> 00:01:27.099
was eventually gonna be a breaking point.

00:01:27.649 --> 00:01:31.739
And my daughter Sid is one of the funniest
and most clever and truly enjoyable humans

00:01:31.739 --> 00:01:36.693
that I have spent time with, so honestly,
, it was a fun experience to record those.

00:01:37.263 --> 00:01:40.923
And then what was wild was the
reception to those first five

00:01:40.923 --> 00:01:45.533
episodes was phenomenal, and I don't
think that Sid or I even realized

00:01:45.593 --> 00:01:48.863
where that podcast was potentially
heading from a growth standpoint.

00:01:49.513 --> 00:01:53.283
But then life happened, and other projects
got in the way, and Sid decided to take

00:01:53.283 --> 00:01:58.263
a step back, and the last episode went
out in October of twenty twenty-three.

00:01:58.303 --> 00:02:01.823
So it's been a minute, as I don't
think the kids are still saying.

00:02:02.323 --> 00:02:05.213
But I've realized that I never
stopped doing the thing that started

00:02:05.463 --> 00:02:07.883
or at least my involvement in
that project in the first place.

00:02:08.433 --> 00:02:11.303
, I'm still watching true crime
documentaries and interrogation

00:02:11.303 --> 00:02:14.813
videos and catching myself forty-five
minutes deep into a psychological case

00:02:14.813 --> 00:02:18.363
conceptualization and wondering what
the subject of that case , would think

00:02:18.363 --> 00:02:22.593
about, , emotional immaturity concepts or
my latest fixation, co-regulation, or the

00:02:22.593 --> 00:02:26.893
dance of two people's nervous systems, or
I'm noticing that person sure seemed to

00:02:26.893 --> 00:02:31.463
display an incredible presentation of an
anxiously attached, , attachment style.

00:02:31.713 --> 00:02:35.893
So no wonder their partner would withdraw
even more, causing their anxiety to ramp

00:02:35.893 --> 00:02:39.423
up more to the point of, uh, true crime.

00:02:40.667 --> 00:02:44.117
So I decided to bring Murder on the
Couch back , and I think I have some

00:02:44.117 --> 00:02:48.767
exciting news that I'll share inside the
episode about my search for, let's say,

00:02:48.767 --> 00:02:52.677
a temporary co-host , or maybe a few
co-hosts, , all while still keeping the

00:02:52.677 --> 00:02:56.687
seat warm for Syd because whenever and
if ever she's ready, that chair is hers.

00:02:57.187 --> 00:02:59.977
So before we jump in, I do wanna give
you a heads-up, especially if you are

00:02:59.977 --> 00:03:02.257
not a regular true crime listener.

00:03:02.257 --> 00:03:05.627
This is probably not one to just all of
a sudden say, "Well, you know, what's

00:03:05.627 --> 00:03:09.647
this true crime stuff all about?" , Not
one to cut your teeth on because this

00:03:09.647 --> 00:03:12.247
episode opens with a pretty intense case.

00:03:12.347 --> 00:03:12.537
, it

00:03:12.587 --> 00:03:17.177
involves a familicide, , a man who
killed his wife, his mother, and then

00:03:17.257 --> 00:03:21.297
their teenage children, and he claimed
that God was perfectly fine with his

00:03:21.297 --> 00:03:25.370
decision the details are pretty disturbing
and, and I don't sugarcoat them.

00:03:25.970 --> 00:03:28.280
If that's not something that you
are in a place to hear right now,

00:03:28.400 --> 00:03:30.240
honestly, I completely understand.

00:03:30.610 --> 00:03:32.050
, Take care of yourself first.

00:03:32.440 --> 00:03:35.370
, This episode will be here if
and whenever you're ready.

00:03:35.390 --> 00:03:39.590
But if you do stay, then here's , what I
want you to know about where this goes.

00:03:40.100 --> 00:03:41.950
I'm not just covering the crime.

00:03:42.060 --> 00:03:45.540
I, I decided to use this case to dig
into some concepts that I think are

00:03:45.540 --> 00:03:49.230
gonna feel pretty familiar to a lot
of my listeners, whether it's Virtual

00:03:49.240 --> 00:03:50.400
Couch or Waking Up to Narcissism.

00:03:50.450 --> 00:03:54.130
Things like, uh, compartmentalization
or, or what happens when we seal off the

00:03:54.130 --> 00:03:57.840
parts of ourselves that we don't want
anybody else to see, or the difference

00:03:57.840 --> 00:04:02.810
between shame and guilt and how shame gets
installed in childhood before we really

00:04:02.820 --> 00:04:05.290
have tools to understand what's happening.

00:04:05.710 --> 00:04:09.060
And I talk about something called, , the
altruistic defense, which is when somebody

00:04:09.060 --> 00:04:16.060
reframes a-an act of self-protection that
can be pretty, pretty intense as an act

00:04:16.060 --> 00:04:20.710
of love, and then why that dynamic or
how that dynamic shows up in my office

00:04:20.730 --> 00:04:22.780
regularly, minus the true crime part.

00:04:23.450 --> 00:04:25.890
, I talk about emotional immaturity
and rigidity and cognitive

00:04:25.900 --> 00:04:27.190
fusion and, , differentiation.

00:04:27.530 --> 00:04:30.640
And then a concept out of, uh, my beloved
acceptance and commitment therapy that

00:04:30.640 --> 00:04:34.140
I think is, , one of the most hopeful
things in psychology, which is this

00:04:34.140 --> 00:04:38.060
difference between the story that
you've been telling yourself and then

00:04:38.060 --> 00:04:41.960
the part of you that's been observing
or watching the story the whole time.

00:04:42.460 --> 00:04:45.040
And, , just to be clear, I'm not
saying that anybody listening is

00:04:45.040 --> 00:04:46.400
heading toward a life of crime.

00:04:46.830 --> 00:04:50.340
, But many of the concepts that, that we
explore today, the shame, the rigidity,

00:04:50.350 --> 00:04:54.010
the performing a version of yourself for
other people, the sealing off of things

00:04:54.020 --> 00:04:57.390
that you don't want anybody to know, I
think those exist in most all of us at…

00:04:57.430 --> 00:05:00.930
in some form, , a far,
far less intense form.

00:05:01.530 --> 00:05:05.330
And so I think that's what makes a case
like this worth sitting with, not because

00:05:05.340 --> 00:05:08.260
the behavior is anywhere near relatable.

00:05:08.360 --> 00:05:09.090
It's horrific.

00:05:09.580 --> 00:05:13.860
But I think the psychology underneath it
is a big part of the human experience.

00:05:13.890 --> 00:05:18.040
And then I, I often think that
understanding it at this extreme level

00:05:18.040 --> 00:05:21.780
or magnification can actually help
us see things in our own lives that

00:05:21.780 --> 00:05:23.680
are a lot harder to spot up close.

00:05:24.010 --> 00:05:27.200
'Cause one of the things I think
is the most helpful to do is

00:05:27.200 --> 00:05:31.130
to learn how to look inward,
, introspection, self-confrontation.

00:05:31.630 --> 00:05:32.590
So that's what you're getting today.

00:05:33.090 --> 00:05:36.920
Definitely heavier than a normal Virtual
Couch or Waking Up to Narcissism episode.

00:05:37.620 --> 00:05:40.340
, But I think it's worth it, and I genuinely
am excited to share this with you.

00:05:40.340 --> 00:05:43.360
And if you like it, please do me a huge
favor and go subscribe to Murder on the

00:05:43.360 --> 00:05:45.010
Couch wherever you listen to podcasts.

00:05:45.020 --> 00:05:45.670
That would mean a lot.

00:05:46.180 --> 00:05:49.750
, Not to spoil the surprise inside, but
maybe I'll be talking with you, the

00:05:49.750 --> 00:05:51.440
listener, about a case in the future.

00:05:52.100 --> 00:05:52.370
Okay.

00:05:52.420 --> 00:05:53.170
Let's get into it.

00:05:53.180 --> 00:05:57.250
Here is Murder on the Couch and the case
of John List, who was a Sunday school

00:05:57.250 --> 00:05:59.700
teacher, and the psychology of shame

00:06:04.520 --> 00:06:05.330
So picture this.

00:06:05.660 --> 00:06:07.720
It's December nineteen seventy-one.

00:06:08.410 --> 00:06:12.120
A postal worker in Westfield, New
Jersey, starts noticing something

00:06:12.120 --> 00:06:16.550
odd about the big Victorian mansion
at the end of Hillside Avenue.

00:06:17.060 --> 00:06:19.940
The lights are on, all of
them, every single night.

00:06:20.570 --> 00:06:24.670
The mail is piling up, and there's
this faint sound coming from inside.

00:06:25.300 --> 00:06:29.880
It's classical music, and it's playing
very softly, like the house itself is

00:06:29.880 --> 00:06:32.250
humming, but to nobody in particular.

00:06:33.200 --> 00:06:34.710
Neighbors mention it to each other.

00:06:35.280 --> 00:06:36.640
There's a lot of talk in the neighborhood.

00:06:37.480 --> 00:06:41.340
And then finally, somebody goes up and
knocks on the door, but nobody answers.

00:06:42.010 --> 00:06:46.267
This goes on for over a month,
a teacher calls the police.

00:06:46.997 --> 00:06:49.297
Two officers eventually show up.

00:06:49.927 --> 00:06:55.247
They step inside, and they find in a
house with the thermostat turned down to

00:06:55.247 --> 00:07:01.697
near freezing the bodies of five people:
a wife, a mother, three teenagers,

00:07:02.327 --> 00:07:03.757
each one of them shot in the head.

00:07:04.557 --> 00:07:07.587
Carefully laid out on sleeping bags
in the mansion's grand ballroom.

00:07:08.267 --> 00:07:10.047
The mother was in the
kitchen where she'd fallen.

00:07:10.487 --> 00:07:13.807
There was no sign of a break-in,
no struggle, no robbery.

00:07:14.707 --> 00:07:18.897
But what there was, sitting neatly on
the desk of the family patriarch, a

00:07:18.897 --> 00:07:23.827
five-page handwritten letter addressed to
his pastor, and in it, the man explained

00:07:23.827 --> 00:07:28.497
exactly what he had done and why God
would understand and why he was confident

00:07:28.497 --> 00:07:30.427
that his family was now safe in heaven.

00:07:31.297 --> 00:07:36.697
And then that man, John List, forty-six
years old, devout Lutheran, Sunday

00:07:36.697 --> 00:07:41.427
school teacher, former army officer,
apparently a devoted family man, walked

00:07:41.427 --> 00:07:45.927
out of that house, got in his car,
and disappeared so completely that it

00:07:45.927 --> 00:07:47.707
would take eighteen years to find him.

00:07:49.237 --> 00:07:54.887
This is one of the cases that stopped
me in my tracks because the question

00:07:54.887 --> 00:07:57.827
that I just can't seem to shake, the
one that I want to spend this episode

00:07:57.827 --> 00:08:00.147
sitting with is: how does it happen?

00:08:00.907 --> 00:08:03.337
Not the logistics, but let's
talk about the psychology.

00:08:03.917 --> 00:08:06.677
How does a man get to a place where
killing the five people that he

00:08:06.677 --> 00:08:10.627
supposedly loved the most in the
world becomes, in his mind, the

00:08:10.627 --> 00:08:12.727
most loving thing that he could do?

00:08:13.867 --> 00:08:16.707
And how does somebody's internal
world become so sealed off, so

00:08:16.707 --> 00:08:22.267
rigid, so fused with shame and
fear that this is the exit ramp?

00:08:23.037 --> 00:08:26.237
And that also that he is
convinced that God is gonna be

00:08:26.237 --> 00:08:27.827
perfectly fine with what he did.

00:08:28.667 --> 00:08:29.757
That's what we're talking about today.

00:08:30.517 --> 00:08:31.497
My name is Tony Overbay.

00:08:32.377 --> 00:08:34.897
I'm a licensed marriage and family
therapist, host of The Virtual

00:08:34.897 --> 00:08:36.857
Couch, Waking Up to Narcissism.

00:08:37.577 --> 00:08:40.387
But today, you're listening
to Murder on the Couch.

00:08:40.777 --> 00:08:41.347
Let's get into it.

00:08:46.772 --> 00:08:47.062
Hey, everybody.

00:08:47.062 --> 00:08:48.302
Welcome to Murder on the Couch.

00:08:48.302 --> 00:08:49.112
I'm your host, Tony Overbay.

00:08:49.112 --> 00:08:52.352
I'm a licensed marriage and family
therapist and somebody who cannot

00:08:52.352 --> 00:08:56.512
watch a true crime documentary
Or a, an interrogation video

00:08:56.512 --> 00:09:00.002
without narrating this running
psychological commentary in my head.

00:09:00.422 --> 00:09:01.982
Quite frankly, whether anybody
wants to hear it or not.

00:09:02.522 --> 00:09:06.172
If you are a longtime listener
and -- it needs to be pretty long

00:09:06.172 --> 00:09:07.722
ago, thanks for still being here.

00:09:07.752 --> 00:09:08.552
Thanks for showing up again.

00:09:08.582 --> 00:09:09.282
It's been a while.

00:09:09.802 --> 00:09:12.262
If you've been around from the beginning,
you know that this podcast, Murder on

00:09:12.262 --> 00:09:16.392
the Couch, was initially a collaboration
between my daughter Sydney and me, and

00:09:16.392 --> 00:09:20.342
those episodes with her are genuinely one
of my favorite things that I've ever done.

00:09:21.152 --> 00:09:24.422
Meanwhile, I've done over four hundred
and fifty episodes of a mental health

00:09:24.422 --> 00:09:25.732
podcast called The Virtual Couch.

00:09:26.122 --> 00:09:29.172
Throw in another one hundred and
fifty plus of Waking Up to Narcissism,

00:09:29.582 --> 00:09:33.982
but this one is the thing that
took off like a rocket ship and

00:09:33.982 --> 00:09:36.102
and then came to an abrupt halt.

00:09:36.752 --> 00:09:39.262
But she's taking a break right now,
and I hope, I hope that she'll rejoin

00:09:39.262 --> 00:09:40.632
me in the not-too-distant future.

00:09:41.072 --> 00:09:43.462
But in the meantime, I've been
doing what I do all the time.

00:09:43.632 --> 00:09:48.122
I watch a lot of true crime documentaries
listen to some true crime podcasts.

00:09:48.952 --> 00:09:53.292
I have a YouTube feed absolutely full
of interrogation videos, and I do the

00:09:53.292 --> 00:09:55.932
thing where I'm supposed to be just
consuming content like a normal human

00:09:55.932 --> 00:10:00.532
person, but instead I'm forty-five minutes
in with a full case conceptualization

00:10:00.882 --> 00:10:04.672
running in my head and wondering the
psychological makeup and who hurt this

00:10:04.672 --> 00:10:08.132
person as a child and why wouldn't
somebody just give this person validation?

00:10:08.162 --> 00:10:09.952
Could it have fixed this whole thing?

00:10:10.732 --> 00:10:13.792
And also, admittedly, there are times
where I'm saying out loud, "I would

00:10:13.792 --> 00:10:16.352
really like to work with that person,
just to get inside their head," because

00:10:16.352 --> 00:10:18.092
I love what I do as a therapist.

00:10:18.422 --> 00:10:21.522
But all of a sudden, I'll look around
and, hey, there's my wife maybe an

00:10:21.522 --> 00:10:24.802
adult child or two looking at me a
little strange, like I need a hobby

00:10:24.892 --> 00:10:26.682
that also isn't isn't my profession.

00:10:27.092 --> 00:10:30.402
So here we are because because true
crime when you look at it through

00:10:30.402 --> 00:10:35.252
the therapeutic lens is not just
disturbing or even just compelling.

00:10:35.722 --> 00:10:36.572
It's instructive.

00:10:37.412 --> 00:10:41.452
And I'm not talking about here's how you
do it, but it shows you sometimes the

00:10:41.452 --> 00:10:47.052
most extreme magnification what happens
inside human beings when things like

00:10:47.052 --> 00:10:51.362
shame go unexamined or when connection
gets replaced by performance or when

00:10:51.702 --> 00:10:56.032
the interior life, what it feels like
to be you on the inside, honest to

00:10:56.032 --> 00:10:58.772
goodness, never gets the attention that
it needs, and maybe doesn't even know

00:10:58.772 --> 00:11:02.712
what it needs so that attention-seeking
game was rigged to begin with.

00:11:03.502 --> 00:11:06.662
But before I get to the case, I want to
make an offer, because I've spent a lot

00:11:06.662 --> 00:11:09.892
of time thinking about how I want to move
this podcast forward, and I landed on

00:11:09.892 --> 00:11:13.712
something that felt more exciting to me
than just picking up where we left off.

00:11:14.392 --> 00:11:17.222
I would like for you to be
my co-host, and I mean that.

00:11:17.262 --> 00:11:18.102
And here's what I'm envisioning.

00:11:18.702 --> 00:11:22.072
If you are somebody who has ever
gone down a A true crime rabbit hole.

00:11:22.272 --> 00:11:25.572
And I mean really down the rabbit
hole, the kind where it's the middle

00:11:25.572 --> 00:11:28.892
of the night and you're reading the--
even chasing down the court documents

00:11:28.892 --> 00:11:32.672
and you're watching all kinds of
hot takes by attorneys and other

00:11:32.672 --> 00:11:35.612
podcasters, and you found yourself
thinking not just about what happened,

00:11:35.612 --> 00:11:39.492
but really the why about what was
going on psychologically about the…

00:11:40.052 --> 00:11:43.092
Does the case talk about shame or
attachment wounds or family systems

00:11:43.092 --> 00:11:46.482
or, or identify any of the things
that that we talk about on this show

00:11:46.852 --> 00:11:50.012
or on any of my other podcasts, then
I genuinely wanna hear from you.

00:11:50.552 --> 00:11:54.432
Reach out to me at contact@tonyoverbay.com
and tell me about the case that

00:11:54.432 --> 00:11:55.382
you're interested in covering.

00:11:55.882 --> 00:11:58.592
Tell me a little bit about yourself,
give me a sense of the angles

00:11:58.592 --> 00:11:59.592
that you would want to explore.

00:11:59.892 --> 00:12:03.882
What draws you to it, maybe even from
a therapeutic lens or psychologically?

00:12:04.262 --> 00:12:06.712
What questions do you think
that the case is really asking?

00:12:07.152 --> 00:12:08.662
Or what does it even bring up in you?

00:12:08.662 --> 00:12:11.092
Let's talk about a little
transference maybe some projection.

00:12:11.712 --> 00:12:13.382
And it does not need to be polished.

00:12:13.612 --> 00:12:15.012
\ Doesn't have to be a formal pitch.

00:12:15.312 --> 00:12:16.832
Just tell me what's
got you hooked and why.

00:12:16.832 --> 00:12:19.492
And if it feels like a fit, I'll
reach out, and we will figure out

00:12:19.492 --> 00:12:20.852
how to make an episode together.

00:12:21.132 --> 00:12:22.912
Maybe it's one, maybe it's a few.

00:12:22.912 --> 00:12:26.792
And honestly, if the right person's
out there and we click and no one

00:12:26.792 --> 00:12:29.842
else reaches out, maybe maybe it's
something more ongoing than that.

00:12:30.472 --> 00:12:32.372
But let's get into today's case.

00:12:32.572 --> 00:12:35.212
And I do really think this one
is going to stay with you, and I

00:12:35.212 --> 00:12:37.642
probably should have already given
you a little bit of a trigger warning

00:12:37.642 --> 00:12:39.222
because that was quite the opening.

00:12:40.062 --> 00:12:41.032
But let's start with the facts.

00:12:41.322 --> 00:12:45.072
John Emil List was born in
Bay City, Michigan in 1925.

00:12:45.722 --> 00:12:48.962
He was described as a quiet, serious
kid, deeply shaped by his mother,

00:12:48.962 --> 00:12:53.442
Alma, who was intensely religious
and intensely devoted to John.

00:12:53.842 --> 00:12:56.372
He served in World War II and Korea.

00:12:56.742 --> 00:12:59.422
He got a degree in business and then
a master's degree in accounting.

00:13:00.072 --> 00:13:03.652
So on paper, he was doing everything
just great, building the life

00:13:03.652 --> 00:13:07.282
that his faith and his upbringing
told him that a good, God-fearing

00:13:07.282 --> 00:13:08.482
Christian man was supposed to build.

00:13:08.782 --> 00:13:13.682
He married Helen in 1951, she was
already a widow with a daughter,

00:13:13.682 --> 00:13:16.512
Patricia, and they had two more
children together, John Jr.

00:13:16.542 --> 00:13:17.132
and Frederick.

00:13:17.712 --> 00:13:20.212
And then they settled into
a modest churchgoing life,

00:13:20.212 --> 00:13:21.842
and for a while it worked.

00:13:21.872 --> 00:13:22.272
It held.

00:13:22.412 --> 00:13:23.402
It held together nicely.

00:13:24.252 --> 00:13:28.702
Then in 1965, he got a VP of finance
job at a bank in New Jersey, and the

00:13:28.702 --> 00:13:34.032
family moved into this enormous Victorian
mansion in Westfield called Breeze Knoll.

00:13:34.802 --> 00:13:36.562
It had 19 rooms.

00:13:36.852 --> 00:13:40.882
It was built in 1896, and it was too
big, and it was too expensive for

00:13:40.882 --> 00:13:42.522
what John List could actually afford.

00:13:42.852 --> 00:13:47.292
But he moved his family in anyway, and
this is where the slow unraveling begins.

00:13:47.559 --> 00:13:51.659
, This bank job that he had fell through
within a year List then bounced between

00:13:51.659 --> 00:13:55.509
positions, and then he began doing
what people who can't tolerate the

00:13:55.509 --> 00:13:59.229
gap between who they believe they are
and who they actually are often do.

00:13:59.709 --> 00:14:05.219
He started lying, a lot, about
everything, impulsively, compulsively.

00:14:05.299 --> 00:14:08.289
He lied to his wife, his mom,
his neighbors, his pastor.

00:14:08.689 --> 00:14:10.309
He started liquidating accounts.

00:14:10.339 --> 00:14:12.299
He stole from his elderly
mother's bank account.

00:14:12.819 --> 00:14:15.999
She lived on the third floor of the
mansion, and he would intercept mail

00:14:16.409 --> 00:14:18.039
so that Helen wouldn't see the bills.

00:14:18.849 --> 00:14:20.769
So for years, he kept up this performance.

00:14:20.999 --> 00:14:21.439
Years.

00:14:21.439 --> 00:14:25.139
That took a lot of work, but he
looked and performed the role of

00:14:25.139 --> 00:14:29.929
this stable, successful, God-fearing
patriarch, even as everything

00:14:29.969 --> 00:14:31.849
underneath him started to collapse.

00:14:32.226 --> 00:14:36.656
His teenagers were teenagers, and
they did the things that teenagers do.

00:14:36.656 --> 00:14:40.526
His daughter, Patty, sixteen, was
interested in theater, and she had

00:14:40.526 --> 00:14:43.896
friends, and she had opinions, and
she was becoming her own person the

00:14:43.896 --> 00:14:45.606
way sixteen-year-olds are supposed to.

00:14:46.496 --> 00:14:47.416
He had a son, Johnny.

00:14:47.446 --> 00:14:48.706
At that point, he was fifteen.

00:14:48.706 --> 00:14:51.386
He had started pulling away
from the rigid church-going

00:14:51.386 --> 00:14:53.246
structure of his dad's household.

00:14:53.996 --> 00:14:58.346
So the family was starting to crack open
in honestly pretty completely normal,

00:14:58.346 --> 00:15:02.336
healthy ways that families do when
children start to differentiate, when they

00:15:02.336 --> 00:15:06.836
start to try to figure out who they are
and John List, a man who had spent his

00:15:06.836 --> 00:15:12.449
entire adult life managing appearances
of trying to appear as a version o-of

00:15:12.449 --> 00:15:16.599
himself that he thought he was supposed
to be, was also, as he's doing that,

00:15:16.909 --> 00:15:18.659
trying to seal off a lot of shame.

00:15:19.739 --> 00:15:21.359
But over time, he couldn't keep it up.

00:15:22.249 --> 00:15:24.209
So on November ninth, nineteen
seventy-one, he got up and

00:15:24.209 --> 00:15:26.549
did what he'd apparently been
planning for quite a while.

00:15:27.249 --> 00:15:28.919
He killed his wife, Helen, in the kitchen.

00:15:29.789 --> 00:15:31.759
Then he went upstairs, and
he killed his mother, Alma.

00:15:32.559 --> 00:15:35.619
He called his children's schools, and he
told them that the kids wouldn't be in.

00:15:36.089 --> 00:15:40.179
And then, one by one, as his children
came home, he killed them, too.

00:15:40.869 --> 00:15:44.799
Patty first, then Frederick, then Johnny
last because Johnny was coming home

00:15:44.799 --> 00:15:46.309
late because he had football practice.

00:15:47.179 --> 00:15:51.579
. He sat down and wrote his pastor that
letter, five pages, very, very neat

00:15:51.579 --> 00:15:56.469
handwriting, explaining that he had
done what a loving father had to do to

00:15:56.469 --> 00:16:00.009
protect his family from a world that
would shame them, from immoral corruption

00:16:00.009 --> 00:16:01.459
creeping into his children's lives.

00:16:01.919 --> 00:16:04.999
He was confident that they were all
in heaven, and he asked for prayers

00:16:04.999 --> 00:16:06.399
from the pastor and the community.

00:16:06.939 --> 00:16:10.289
And he noted almost administratively,
that he didn't really think he'd be

00:16:10.289 --> 00:16:11.899
able to attend his own mother's funeral.

00:16:12.869 --> 00:16:13.929
Then he turned on the lights.

00:16:14.029 --> 00:16:15.709
He turned on the classical music station.

00:16:15.769 --> 00:16:17.469
He turned down the thermostat.

00:16:17.469 --> 00:16:19.689
He got in his car, and he drove to Denver.

00:16:20.609 --> 00:16:25.209
Now most coverage pivots here to
the manhunt, the famous nineteen

00:16:25.209 --> 00:16:28.439
eighty-nine America's Most Wanted
episode with the forensic sculptor who

00:16:28.439 --> 00:16:30.319
age progressed a bust of John List.

00:16:30.709 --> 00:16:35.204
And then there was a neighbor in Richmond,
Virginia, who saw the broadcast- looked

00:16:35.314 --> 00:16:39.954
out her window at a quiet churchgoing
accountant who lived next door named

00:16:39.954 --> 00:16:42.524
Bob Clark, and she made the call.

00:16:43.314 --> 00:16:47.084
He was arrested at his office,
63 years old, remarried.

00:16:47.534 --> 00:16:49.164
His new wife had no idea.

00:16:49.964 --> 00:16:54.244
He was eventually convicted in
1990, and he died in prison in 2008.

00:16:55.034 --> 00:16:59.244
But I don't even necessarily care
to spend much time in the capture,

00:17:00.064 --> 00:17:04.774
but more so in the 18 years that he
lived just a completely normal life.

00:17:05.314 --> 00:17:09.284
Because I think that's what tells us
something that the manhunt never could.

00:17:10.064 --> 00:17:12.094
Because what John List
did wasn't just a crime.

00:17:12.124 --> 00:17:17.234
It was the end product of a very
specific psychological architecture

00:17:17.664 --> 00:17:22.954
that was built brick by brick by brick
out of shame, out of being rigid, out

00:17:22.954 --> 00:17:27.184
of a fused identity, and about a faith
tradition that he bent into something

00:17:27.184 --> 00:17:29.644
that could no longer hold any grace.

00:17:29.801 --> 00:17:31.591
So let's dive into that architecture.

00:17:31.661 --> 00:17:33.921
And before we do that, I want to start
with a question, and I would love for

00:17:33.921 --> 00:17:35.271
you to just sit with this for a second.

00:17:35.861 --> 00:17:39.601
Have you ever had something going on
in your life, something embarrassing

00:17:39.631 --> 00:17:44.031
or scary or very deeply shameful, and
you just didn't want to tell anybody?

00:17:44.661 --> 00:17:48.411
So you continue to show up, you go to
work, you smile at the right moments,

00:17:48.411 --> 00:17:51.271
you show up and perform at school.

00:17:51.521 --> 00:17:54.141
Maybe there's a school play, maybe
there's a church potluck and you

00:17:54.141 --> 00:17:59.051
perform being fine so convincingly
that you almost believe it yourself.

00:17:59.081 --> 00:17:59.881
Everything's okay.

00:18:00.061 --> 00:18:03.471
It's like you're just kicking the can
down the road further and further.

00:18:03.991 --> 00:18:06.761
And I'm guessing that the answer
is yes, because that is a human

00:18:06.761 --> 00:18:08.901
thing, not just a monster thing.

00:18:09.551 --> 00:18:12.701
And I'm not starting there to
make you feel like John List.

00:18:12.781 --> 00:18:15.841
I'm starting there more because
the most important thing that we

00:18:15.841 --> 00:18:20.761
can do on a podcast like this is
resist the idea that the people

00:18:20.761 --> 00:18:22.931
that we talk about are simply other.

00:18:23.521 --> 00:18:25.061
The, at least I'm not that person.

00:18:25.111 --> 00:18:27.731
Because the truth is, and I think
this is what makes cases like this

00:18:27.731 --> 00:18:33.521
genuinely unsettling, that John List was
operating from a deeply catastrophically

00:18:33.651 --> 00:18:37.611
amplified version of something that I
think a lot of people do, and that is

00:18:37.611 --> 00:18:39.331
something called compartmentalization.

00:18:40.131 --> 00:18:43.841
Because that's a defense mechanism,
and I mean that quite literally.

00:18:44.341 --> 00:18:49.141
The mind defending itself, saying, "This
information is incompatible with my

00:18:49.141 --> 00:18:54.291
ability to function, so I am going to seal
it off and then continue operating and

00:18:54.291 --> 00:18:58.701
conducting my life as if this thing that
I'm also doing or thinking doesn't exist."

00:18:59.131 --> 00:19:01.281
And in small doses, it's pretty adaptive.

00:19:01.751 --> 00:19:05.711
A surgeon sets aside any anxiety in
an operating room, or you're going

00:19:05.711 --> 00:19:08.481
through a divorce, but you have a
presentation to deliver at work.

00:19:08.931 --> 00:19:14.001
That's human flexibility, and it's
a form of compartmentalization.

00:19:14.531 --> 00:19:18.041
But compartmentalization becomes
dangerous when it stops being a

00:19:18.041 --> 00:19:22.831
temporary tool and it becomes part of
your permanent architecture of yourself.

00:19:23.481 --> 00:19:27.101
When this sealed-off room that you seal
off these things that you don't want

00:19:27.101 --> 00:19:31.311
to deal with or maybe don't want to
acknowledge or admit doesn't just hold,

00:19:31.641 --> 00:19:36.721
"Hey, I'm nervous about this surgery," but
it holds, "I am a complete failure, and if

00:19:36.721 --> 00:19:41.491
anybody ever found out who I actually am,
then my entire existence would collapse."

00:19:42.066 --> 00:19:43.806
Because at that point,
that's not a tool anymore.

00:19:44.056 --> 00:19:48.226
That's a load-bearing wall, and
then everything gets built on top

00:19:48.226 --> 00:19:52.766
of it, and everything is propping
it up to, to try to keep it intact.

00:19:53.696 --> 00:19:57.316
Let's dive into shame versus guilt,
one of the things that I think I could

00:19:57.316 --> 00:20:01.516
talk about on every podcast anytime
that I speak to really distinguish

00:20:01.516 --> 00:20:02.726
or differentiate between the two.

00:20:03.476 --> 00:20:07.956
Because shame is what fills a sealed
room like this, and I wanna be really

00:20:07.956 --> 00:20:12.616
intentional about this because shame
and guilt get conflated constantly,

00:20:12.756 --> 00:20:14.146
and they are not the same thing.

00:20:14.866 --> 00:20:20.046
Guilt says, "I did something bad."
Shame says, "I am bad." Guilt is

00:20:20.046 --> 00:20:23.716
more often about behavior, but
shame is more about identity.

00:20:24.306 --> 00:20:27.326
And guilt can, at times, motivate repair.

00:20:27.736 --> 00:20:30.506
"I did something wrong," or,
"I wanna make something right.

00:20:30.556 --> 00:20:34.006
I did something that I'm not really
proud of, and now that I've done it,

00:20:34.206 --> 00:20:37.406
I wanna take ownership of it." So
it comes from this feeling of guilt.

00:20:37.966 --> 00:20:40.956
Shame does not motivate repair,
no matter how much that we

00:20:40.956 --> 00:20:41.936
like to think that it does.

00:20:42.236 --> 00:20:46.506
Shame motivates hiding, because
if the problem isn't what I did,

00:20:46.656 --> 00:20:50.546
but it's who I am or who I think
I am, then there's nothing to fix.

00:20:50.546 --> 00:20:51.776
There's only something to conceal.

00:20:52.406 --> 00:20:55.076
And shame does not arrive in adulthood.

00:20:55.616 --> 00:21:00.816
Shame gets installed early, before
you have the cognitive architecture to

00:21:00.816 --> 00:21:02.616
even be aware of it or to process it.

00:21:03.096 --> 00:21:04.656
Because where did that shame come from?

00:21:05.116 --> 00:21:07.266
I don't think that it
always starts in a church.

00:21:07.296 --> 00:21:10.696
I think it starts in a kitchen
or in a living room or on a

00:21:10.696 --> 00:21:11.856
car ride home from school.

00:21:13.026 --> 00:21:17.346
I shared this on a podcast about sin
and guilt and shame recently, so I'm

00:21:17.346 --> 00:21:18.806
gonna take an excerpt from there.

00:21:19.496 --> 00:21:20.106
But think about it.

00:21:20.106 --> 00:21:22.546
You're four years old, and you're
doing what four-year-olds do.

00:21:22.546 --> 00:21:26.036
You're moving through the world
impulsively, curiously, probably clumsily.

00:21:26.606 --> 00:21:29.926
Let's say you knock something over, or
you say something that you were told not

00:21:29.926 --> 00:21:33.956
to say, or you do something that your
parent told you not to do, even though

00:21:34.096 --> 00:21:37.016
you honestly don't fully understand
why you were told not to do it in

00:21:37.016 --> 00:21:38.576
the first place, because you're four.

00:21:39.496 --> 00:21:42.246
And now your parent's upset, and
they need something from you.

00:21:42.866 --> 00:21:46.196
They need to see that you understand
that what you did was wrong.

00:21:46.636 --> 00:21:47.596
They need the apology.

00:21:48.066 --> 00:21:49.586
They need you to hang your head down.

00:21:49.586 --> 00:21:51.106
They need the, they need to see the face.

00:21:51.106 --> 00:21:55.426
They need you to look sad or sorry
or scared because, and I'm saying

00:21:55.426 --> 00:21:59.016
this with absolute compassion for the
parent as well, because they're running

00:21:59.016 --> 00:22:03.316
their own inherited programming of
what they think you need to do to be

00:22:03.316 --> 00:22:05.346
a good kid, to be a better parent.

00:22:05.846 --> 00:22:07.976
Because if you don't look like
you feel bad, then what does

00:22:07.976 --> 00:22:09.236
that say about them as a parent?

00:22:09.556 --> 00:22:11.706
If the kid isn't showing
remorse, are they, i- is the

00:22:11.706 --> 00:22:12.806
parent even doing their job?

00:22:13.526 --> 00:22:17.481
So the kid learns over time to perform
the kid learns to read the room.

00:22:17.621 --> 00:22:21.821
They figure out what expression makes
this scary moment stop, and maybe at this

00:22:21.821 --> 00:22:25.521
day and age gets me back to my tablet
or lets me go play with my friends.

00:22:26.171 --> 00:22:29.791
But here's where actually the
damage happens, and it's so subtle

00:22:29.931 --> 00:22:31.461
that people don't even notice it.

00:22:32.081 --> 00:22:35.891
A four-year-old does not have the
cognitive architecture to separate, "I

00:22:35.891 --> 00:22:40.801
did a bad thing," from, "I am bad." And at
that moment, those two concepts are fused.

00:22:41.021 --> 00:22:41.871
They're one thing.

00:22:42.431 --> 00:22:45.811
In that moment, shame
gets installed, not guilt.

00:22:46.131 --> 00:22:49.431
Guilt says, "I did something I
wanna repair," but shame says, "I am

00:22:49.431 --> 00:22:54.681
fundamentally broken." And that shame, in
that moment, becomes the operating system.

00:22:55.291 --> 00:22:56.151
And then what happens?

00:22:56.231 --> 00:22:59.441
That kid grows up, and maybe
now they do walk into a church

00:22:59.441 --> 00:23:00.681
with the best of intentions.

00:23:01.091 --> 00:23:04.081
And somebody says, "Hey, we're
all sinners. You're a sinner."

00:23:04.531 --> 00:23:06.481
And it doesn't actually feel new.

00:23:06.481 --> 00:23:09.701
It feels familiar because it
confirms what they believed about

00:23:09.701 --> 00:23:11.071
themselves since they were small.

00:23:11.351 --> 00:23:15.341
"Well, of course I am. I am a sinner, and
I gotta confess things. A-and of course,

00:23:15.341 --> 00:23:19.861
something's wrong with me." And then,
unfortunately, the whole system reinforces

00:23:19.861 --> 00:23:21.601
the wound instead of healing it.

00:23:23.241 --> 00:23:26.661
This Franciscan priest, Richard
Rohr, has some amazing content around

00:23:26.661 --> 00:23:29.011
that, and that's where he says that
we're getting to this place where

00:23:29.011 --> 00:23:32.721
this is where it's intergenerational
because it's not one person's sin.

00:23:33.201 --> 00:23:34.641
In this scenario, it's a pattern.

00:23:34.671 --> 00:23:35.301
It's inherited.

00:23:35.851 --> 00:23:39.041
The parent who needed you to perform
remorse, well, they learned it from

00:23:39.041 --> 00:23:41.001
their parent, who learned it from theirs.

00:23:41.371 --> 00:23:44.811
And somewhere along the way, we built
entire institutions around the idea

00:23:45.191 --> 00:23:48.791
that this cycle of shame and confession
and judgment was the path to healing.

00:23:49.511 --> 00:23:53.761
And you've got this Franciscan priest,
Richard Rohr, who's operating from inside

00:23:53.761 --> 00:23:57.431
one of those institutions, and I love
that he says "I don't think that's it.

00:23:58.111 --> 00:24:01.571
I think the path is recognizing
brokenness and then requesting healing.

00:24:02.011 --> 00:24:06.381
It's not about performing penance." And if
you think of this example I'm laying out,

00:24:06.381 --> 00:24:11.811
it's about performing the right behaviors
to hopefully get your parent to buy in

00:24:11.811 --> 00:24:14.191
that you get the fact that you're bad.

00:24:14.191 --> 00:24:15.091
You did the bad thing.

00:24:16.191 --> 00:24:18.511
So Rohr says it's not
about performing penance.

00:24:18.831 --> 00:24:21.111
It's not about trying to prove
that you're sorry enough.

00:24:21.911 --> 00:24:25.471
Healing, and I am a huge acceptance
and commitment therapy fan.

00:24:25.471 --> 00:24:29.301
That's my modality of choice as a
therapist, in the ACT lens, this

00:24:29.301 --> 00:24:32.551
is where it gets pretty clean
because what is shame clinically?

00:24:33.031 --> 00:24:34.811
Shame is this cognitive fusion.

00:24:34.921 --> 00:24:37.351
I am fusing to this story
at its most destructive.

00:24:37.351 --> 00:24:40.591
It's not, I'm having a thought
or I'm noticing that I messed up.

00:24:40.841 --> 00:24:42.461
It's I am messed up.

00:24:43.091 --> 00:24:46.361
And so at that moment, the thought
and the self become one thing.

00:24:47.041 --> 00:24:49.381
And what does the traditional
sin framework ask you to do?

00:24:49.951 --> 00:24:53.371
It asks you now to walk into a
room and declare you are a sinner.

00:24:53.841 --> 00:24:57.331
It asks you to fuse with the most
painful story that you can tell about

00:24:57.331 --> 00:25:01.891
yourself, and then it tells you that
doing this is the path to freedom.

00:25:02.651 --> 00:25:06.091
That what healing requires,
though, in my opinion, is defusion.

00:25:06.891 --> 00:25:12.091
It's enough space to notice the thought
and hold it out away from you, hold it

00:25:12.091 --> 00:25:14.181
with curiosity instead of becoming it.

00:25:14.711 --> 00:25:18.811
To be able to say, "I'm having the thought
that something is wrong with me. I can

00:25:18.811 --> 00:25:22.701
notice that this thought's been with me
a long time, and in that moment, I can

00:25:22.701 --> 00:25:26.891
choose with my adult brain instead of my
four-year-old one to respond differently."

00:25:27.471 --> 00:25:29.381
Because that is not
avoiding accountability.

00:25:29.681 --> 00:25:30.971
It's actually a deeper form of it.

00:25:31.521 --> 00:25:35.601
You're not just owning a behavior, you're
owning the whole pattern, and that's a

00:25:35.601 --> 00:25:39.381
way to heal this intergenerational trauma.

00:25:39.781 --> 00:25:44.821
Sure, it will be uncomfortable, but it's
better than sealing this thing off and

00:25:44.821 --> 00:25:46.741
then pretending that it doesn't exist.

00:25:47.431 --> 00:25:48.411
So back to John List.

00:25:49.121 --> 00:25:52.081
So he was one of, I think, in my
opinion, looking back over this case,

00:25:52.081 --> 00:25:55.631
one of the most shame-saturated people
that you'll probably ever encounter

00:25:55.631 --> 00:25:59.091
in a true crime case because his
entire sense of self was constructed

00:25:59.091 --> 00:26:00.471
on a really brittle foundation.

00:26:00.961 --> 00:26:01.711
"I'm the provider.

00:26:02.031 --> 00:26:02.761
I'm the patriarch.

00:26:02.941 --> 00:26:03.761
I'm the man of God.

00:26:03.961 --> 00:26:06.731
I am in control." That
was the load-bearing wall.

00:26:07.191 --> 00:26:11.251
And then he had a mother, Alma, who
handed him a self before he was even

00:26:11.251 --> 00:26:14.931
old enough to choose one, and that
self was built on performance, on

00:26:14.931 --> 00:26:19.361
duty, on being a certain thing for a
parent who needed him to be that thing.

00:26:20.261 --> 00:26:24.331
It was on being righteous, on being
God-fearing, on being perfect.

00:26:24.931 --> 00:26:28.551
And he carried that performed,
shame-organized, rigid self into

00:26:28.551 --> 00:26:33.531
his adulthood, into his marriage,
into fatherhood, into his work,

00:26:33.531 --> 00:26:35.781
into that 19-room Victorian house.

00:26:36.141 --> 00:26:40.691
And so by 1971, his reality was
dismantling it brick by brick.

00:26:41.371 --> 00:26:46.751
Job gone, money gone, house about to be
foreclosed, kids becoming actually real

00:26:46.751 --> 00:26:51.371
complicated individual human beings who
are not gonna just quietly perform the

00:26:51.371 --> 00:26:53.831
roles that his architecture required.

00:26:54.721 --> 00:26:57.061
And here's what shame
does in that situation.

00:26:57.781 --> 00:27:01.081
Shame doesn't say, "You know, things
have gone a little bit south here.

00:27:01.111 --> 00:27:04.981
I think I need some help." Shame says,
"If anybody sees this, I will cease to

00:27:04.981 --> 00:27:09.431
exist as the person I believe myself
to be." That's actually how , the

00:27:09.431 --> 00:27:13.561
shame-based psyche experiences any
kind of i-internal or vulnerable

00:27:13.561 --> 00:27:17.371
exposure, not as embarrassment,
but as complete annihilation.

00:27:17.931 --> 00:27:21.351
So the nervous system responds to
it the way it responds to a physical

00:27:21.351 --> 00:27:25.831
threat, to physical danger, because
a-at the level of the psyche, oh, it is.

00:27:26.191 --> 00:27:27.801
That is a tiger that is chasing you.

00:27:28.741 --> 00:27:32.641
And there's a particular danger in shame
that lives only in the dark, only in the

00:27:32.641 --> 00:27:37.411
shadows, because shame that gets examined
or brought into a room with another

00:27:37.411 --> 00:27:42.621
person and witnessed, like a therapist
not fixed, but just witnessed, it loses

00:27:42.621 --> 00:27:47.256
power When you bring it from the shadows
into the light, it isn't as scary.

00:27:47.576 --> 00:27:48.616
It becomes more workable.

00:27:49.186 --> 00:27:52.326
But shame that never
gets examined just grows.

00:27:52.796 --> 00:27:56.636
It fills every room, and it gets
bigger and heavier and more defended

00:27:56.636 --> 00:28:00.796
with every passing year until the gap
between performance and then what's

00:28:00.796 --> 00:28:03.136
happening in reality cannot hold.

00:28:03.136 --> 00:28:04.186
It cannot exist.

00:28:05.086 --> 00:28:08.686
So when John List's system could
not hold anymore or anything

00:28:08.686 --> 00:28:10.306
else, he did not reach out.

00:28:10.816 --> 00:28:11.916
He didn't let anybody in.

00:28:12.606 --> 00:28:15.136
He sealed that room one final time.

00:28:15.666 --> 00:28:18.946
And then so he wouldn't have
a complete collapse i-in his

00:28:18.946 --> 00:28:21.166
psyche, he called it love.

00:28:21.412 --> 00:28:23.392
I wanna start this next segment
with something that might feel a

00:28:23.392 --> 00:28:24.762
little bit uncomfortable as well.

00:28:24.762 --> 00:28:25.452
Stay with me here.

00:28:25.542 --> 00:28:26.862
The discomfort is the point.

00:28:26.982 --> 00:28:28.672
There's growth from discomfort.

00:28:29.092 --> 00:28:33.202
Think about a time in a relationship with
a parent or a partner when somebody did

00:28:33.202 --> 00:28:37.592
something that hurt you, and when you
tried to say, "Hey, that that, that hurt.

00:28:37.592 --> 00:28:42.192
That landed hard," and the response
was some version of, "You know,

00:28:42.252 --> 00:28:45.342
that was actually more difficult
for me," or, "I did that for you.

00:28:45.402 --> 00:28:46.112
I was trying to help.

00:28:46.112 --> 00:28:50.592
I did it actually because I love you." And
if you've ever had that experience, you're

00:28:50.592 --> 00:28:56.682
left standing there with this bizarre
double reality, the pain on one side

00:28:57.862 --> 00:29:01.816
and trying to express it, and then this
in-insistence that the person who caused

00:29:01.816 --> 00:29:04.146
it was actually the hero of the story.

00:29:04.906 --> 00:29:08.746
Now, I think most everybody has
experienced some version of that, and

00:29:08.796 --> 00:29:12.286
understanding the psychology underneath
it is a really important thing that

00:29:12.286 --> 00:29:16.076
I think I can offer today because
what John List did is not separate

00:29:16.076 --> 00:29:21.256
from that experience, although he did
it in the most catastrophic possible

00:29:21.256 --> 00:29:25.476
expression of that kind of experience
or that mechanism, and that mechanism

00:29:25.476 --> 00:29:27.296
is called an altruistic defense.

00:29:28.136 --> 00:29:30.076
Let me even back up a little
bit here, let's compare it

00:29:30.076 --> 00:29:31.306
with a narcissistic injury.

00:29:31.816 --> 00:29:34.206
So when most people hear
narcissism, they picture the, the

00:29:34.206 --> 00:29:36.106
loud, swaggering, grandiose type.

00:29:36.106 --> 00:29:39.906
But there's another presentation
I see far more often, and I think

00:29:40.226 --> 00:29:43.486
the one that describes John List
would fit into this category.

00:29:43.526 --> 00:29:47.626
It's quieter, it-- but it's more rigid,
and it often wraps itself in virtue

00:29:47.846 --> 00:29:49.976
and duty and faith and self-sacrifice.

00:29:50.506 --> 00:29:53.216
And this is sometimes called a
covert or a vulnerable narcissist.

00:29:53.916 --> 00:29:56.206
The core wound in both
versions is the same.

00:29:56.506 --> 00:29:58.566
It's a self that was
never allowed to be real.

00:29:59.196 --> 00:30:03.116
Somewhere in development, and in John
List's case, I'd point right to his

00:30:03.116 --> 00:30:05.686
mom, Alma, the message got delivered.

00:30:05.886 --> 00:30:08.576
And by the way, that doesn't
mean I'm blaming his mom because

00:30:08.956 --> 00:30:11.606
h-his lack of a strong father
figure played a role in this.

00:30:11.716 --> 00:30:15.596
The church that Alma grew up and
went to, which most likely gave

00:30:15.596 --> 00:30:19.286
her a sense of security or maybe
even peace, that these are just

00:30:19.286 --> 00:30:21.016
all components that play into this.

00:30:21.356 --> 00:30:25.806
But the message that got delivered was
that who you actually are is not enough.

00:30:25.946 --> 00:30:30.346
There's a version of you you need
to be, and what that- That speaks

00:30:30.346 --> 00:30:33.836
especially to a kid is that love is
conditional on how you perform, that

00:30:33.836 --> 00:30:37.496
your value is located entirely in
what you produce and how you appear.

00:30:38.276 --> 00:30:41.596
So when a child grows up with that
message, they don't develop a real self.

00:30:42.066 --> 00:30:46.426
They develop a performed self, and that
performed self is extraordinarily fragile

00:30:46.466 --> 00:30:49.096
because it has no interior foundation.

00:30:49.126 --> 00:30:50.726
It's all basically this facade.

00:30:50.826 --> 00:30:53.036
It's the masks that the
person needs to wear.

00:30:53.806 --> 00:30:57.496
Now, narcissistic injury is what happens
when that facade gets threatened.

00:30:58.026 --> 00:31:01.796
When reality intrudes in a way that
can't be managed or it can't be

00:31:01.796 --> 00:31:06.536
denied, then the internal experience
of that person isn't embarrassment.

00:31:06.926 --> 00:31:10.546
It goes back to this concept
where John List felt like all

00:31:10.546 --> 00:31:11.656
of these things were an attack.

00:31:12.656 --> 00:31:17.246
And the nervous system responds to that
like it is an attack to physical danger

00:31:17.246 --> 00:31:22.556
because the only self that this person has
ever had is under the threat of collapse.

00:31:22.646 --> 00:31:25.156
They're gonna get discovered,
and they're gonna be found out.

00:31:26.036 --> 00:31:28.796
So the altruistic defense is
exactly what it sounds like.

00:31:28.796 --> 00:31:32.336
A person reframes an act of
self-protection, even if it's aggressive,

00:31:32.746 --> 00:31:36.696
as an act of love, of altruism, of
they're being loving and caring.

00:31:37.266 --> 00:31:39.726
And this often is not conscious.

00:31:40.316 --> 00:31:45.206
It's the psyche that has to construct this
narrative that preserves the self-image.

00:31:45.636 --> 00:31:49.006
It allows that person to remain,
in their own story, the good guy.

00:31:49.606 --> 00:31:54.046
John List could not, absolutely could
not be the man who failed his family.

00:31:54.606 --> 00:31:56.026
That identity wasn't available to him.

00:31:56.536 --> 00:32:00.106
So instead, he became the man who
saved his family, the man who loved

00:32:00.106 --> 00:32:03.746
his children so much he spared them
the suffering of watching their father

00:32:03.746 --> 00:32:07.996
fall apart, the man so devoted to
God that he sent his family ahead to

00:32:07.996 --> 00:32:12.366
heaven instead of let them be corrupted
by what he was having to deal with.

00:32:13.366 --> 00:32:17.556
He took an act entirely about protecting
his own ego, and then he had to dress

00:32:17.556 --> 00:32:19.266
it in the language of selfless love.

00:32:19.856 --> 00:32:23.766
And then I'm guessing, he walked
out of that house and then

00:32:23.766 --> 00:32:25.426
genuinely inhabited that narrative.

00:32:25.846 --> 00:32:27.736
Now, I'm not saying that John
List was not responsible.

00:32:27.736 --> 00:32:29.556
He absolutely was, one hundred percent.

00:32:29.906 --> 00:32:32.966
Psychological understanding
is not a psychological excuse.

00:32:33.066 --> 00:32:34.016
Those aren't the same thing.

00:32:34.576 --> 00:32:38.686
But the altruistic defense in its
non-criminal expressions is probably

00:32:38.686 --> 00:32:42.416
one of the most common and damaging
dynamics that I see in my clinical work.

00:32:43.156 --> 00:32:45.306
Because think about the parent
who controls every aspect of their

00:32:45.306 --> 00:32:46.776
kid's life and calls it protection.

00:32:47.516 --> 00:32:52.066
I have worked with more than one parent
who puts off when their kid drives or goes

00:32:52.066 --> 00:32:57.556
to school or gets electronic devices as
long as they possibly can, and they say

00:32:57.556 --> 00:32:59.156
that it's because I'm protecting my kid.

00:32:59.516 --> 00:33:03.426
But really, a lot of times it's more
about the parent not recognizing that

00:33:03.716 --> 00:33:08.386
I don't know how to help them manage
what they're gonna experience because I

00:33:08.386 --> 00:33:09.786
don't even know if I can manage my own.

00:33:09.826 --> 00:33:13.231
So it becomes this form of projection
the, the partner who monitors your

00:33:13.231 --> 00:33:16.621
friendships and then frames it as
care, I see that in my clinical work.

00:33:16.961 --> 00:33:20.181
The person who makes a major decision
that's gonna affect you without your input

00:33:20.211 --> 00:33:24.711
and then explains with genuine sincerity
that they did it to spare your pain.

00:33:25.721 --> 00:33:30.281
In each one of these cases, an act that's
fundamentally about the actor's needs, the

00:33:30.281 --> 00:33:34.621
person's needs, their anxiety, their ego,
their need for control, they repackage

00:33:34.621 --> 00:33:38.871
it as love, and then the recipient is
left trying to hold their own reality

00:33:38.921 --> 00:33:42.411
against what is starting to feel like
a very airtight counter-narrative.

00:33:42.411 --> 00:33:46.401
So this is why on my Waking Up to
Narcissism podcast, I spend so much

00:33:46.401 --> 00:33:49.571
time talking about the confusion that
partners and family members experience.

00:33:49.931 --> 00:33:53.261
Because when the person causing harm is
also the person most loudly proclaiming

00:33:53.261 --> 00:33:57.631
their love and their sacrifice, it creates
a psychological type of vertigo because

00:33:57.631 --> 00:33:58.971
you start questioning your own perception.

00:33:59.371 --> 00:34:02.991
You start wondering, "Wait, a-am I
being ungrateful?" And your brain

00:34:02.991 --> 00:34:06.641
ties itself into knots trying to
reconcile the impact that you're

00:34:06.641 --> 00:34:10.241
feeling with the intention that they're
declaring, they don't fit together.

00:34:11.071 --> 00:34:14.111
It can be a real challenge to learn to
trust your own experience of impact,

00:34:14.141 --> 00:34:18.581
even when somebody else insists that is
not what's happening, and that's one of

00:34:18.581 --> 00:34:22.081
the most important pieces of work that
you can do in a therapist's office.

00:34:23.081 --> 00:34:24.771
And then there's one more layer here.

00:34:24.771 --> 00:34:27.571
John List's children were
beginning to, to differentiate,

00:34:27.571 --> 00:34:31.711
to individuate, and in healthy
families, that's just what happens.

00:34:32.021 --> 00:34:33.721
It's, it can actually be
a bit of a celebration.

00:34:34.221 --> 00:34:37.241
You watch your kid become a real
person with opinions different from

00:34:37.241 --> 00:34:39.771
yours, and you can even feel pride.

00:34:40.451 --> 00:34:43.821
But in a narcissistically organized
family, individuation or differentiation

00:34:43.821 --> 00:34:45.121
is experienced as betrayal.

00:34:45.441 --> 00:34:46.601
You are going against us.

00:34:46.601 --> 00:34:49.821
It's that all or nothing, black or
white mentality, 'cause if your child

00:34:49.821 --> 00:34:53.581
becomes fully themselves, they stop
being an extension of your performed

00:34:53.581 --> 00:34:56.751
identity, and they start being a
witness to it, a witness who can now

00:34:56.751 --> 00:35:00.041
see the gap between who you claim
to be and who you actually are.

00:35:00.821 --> 00:35:04.151
David Schnarch is a psychologist who
I go back to his work constantly.

00:35:04.501 --> 00:35:07.091
He talks about differentiation,
and it's this capacity to be a

00:35:07.091 --> 00:35:10.831
fully separate self in the presence
of another person, to tolerate

00:35:10.831 --> 00:35:13.791
somebody else's separateness without
feeling like it's gonna destroy you.

00:35:14.341 --> 00:35:17.741
John List had e-essentially zero
differentiation capabilities.

00:35:18.491 --> 00:35:23.161
He had enmeshment and he masqueraded that
as devotion, and when the people that he

00:35:23.161 --> 00:35:27.091
was enmeshed with started to become real
complex individuals, real humans, his

00:35:27.091 --> 00:35:31.651
system had no idea what to do with it,
so he ended them, and he called it love.

00:35:32.121 --> 00:35:34.911
So here's what I would love for you
to take from this segment alone.

00:35:35.261 --> 00:35:39.671
Love, real love, requires the
other person to actually exist

00:35:39.671 --> 00:35:41.001
as a completely separate human.

00:35:41.401 --> 00:35:44.841
It requires them to be separate
from you, to have their own interior

00:35:44.841 --> 00:35:47.881
world, their own trajectory,
and you don't get to control it.

00:35:48.471 --> 00:35:49.931
Real love tolerates that.

00:35:50.731 --> 00:35:54.051
So this altruistic defense
produces care as control.

00:35:54.341 --> 00:35:58.191
It, it produces devotion as
possession, and in its mildest

00:35:58.191 --> 00:36:02.816
forms it erodes relationships
really slowly One cut at a time, the

00:36:02.816 --> 00:36:04.346
death by a thousand cuts scenario.

00:36:04.946 --> 00:36:08.056
In its most extreme form, it destroys
them in a most literal sense.

00:36:08.576 --> 00:36:11.939
So the question that I challenge
people with o-often is the relationship

00:36:11.969 --> 00:36:15.409
in your life or are the, all the
relationships in your life, are you

00:36:15.409 --> 00:36:18.999
being loved for who you actually are,
or are you being loved for the role

00:36:18.999 --> 00:36:20.559
you play in somebody else's story?

00:36:21.339 --> 00:36:22.649
'Cause those are not the same thing.

00:36:23.129 --> 00:36:26.679
You can have love or control in an adult
relationship, not both, and knowing

00:36:26.679 --> 00:36:29.379
the difference might be one of the most
important things that you can figure out.

00:36:29.706 --> 00:36:33.066
, So for this next section, I want to
start with a word that sounds almost

00:36:33.066 --> 00:36:35.686
too mild for what we're talking about
today, but it's, I think it's one

00:36:35.686 --> 00:36:39.486
of the most clinically precise words
that we can use to describe John List.

00:36:39.776 --> 00:36:42.496
And I've said it a couple times in
this episode, but let's dig in on it.

00:36:42.596 --> 00:36:43.666
This word is rigid.

00:36:44.206 --> 00:36:46.446
Not evil, not monstrous, but rigid.

00:36:47.216 --> 00:36:50.646
But if we just land on monster
and we call it done, I think

00:36:50.646 --> 00:36:51.696
we miss the entire lesson.

00:36:52.166 --> 00:36:55.286
And there is a lesson here, something
in John List's psychology that if

00:36:55.286 --> 00:36:58.266
we're, I think, being honest, maybe
we can find traces of in our own

00:36:58.266 --> 00:37:01.236
lives, our own relationships or the
family systems that we grew up in.

00:37:01.866 --> 00:37:04.866
So let me talk a little bit about what
emotional immaturity actually looks like.

00:37:05.196 --> 00:37:07.486
It's not just a grown-up
throwing a tantrum, although

00:37:07.486 --> 00:37:08.636
that certainly is a thing.

00:37:09.276 --> 00:37:14.426
It can also look almost like stone-faced
stoicism, this ironclad self-control.

00:37:14.976 --> 00:37:17.596
You know, a man who never raises
his voice, who follows every

00:37:17.596 --> 00:37:20.106
rule, who shows up to church every
Sunday and sits in the same pew

00:37:20.366 --> 00:37:23.266
And never, not once, gives
anybody visible reason to worry.

00:37:23.706 --> 00:37:26.306
Because emotional immaturity isn't
fundamentally about behavior,

00:37:26.356 --> 00:37:28.226
it's about internal capacity.

00:37:28.806 --> 00:37:31.486
So whether a person can actually
experience their emotional life,

00:37:31.606 --> 00:37:33.106
again, emotional immaturity.

00:37:33.196 --> 00:37:35.886
Do they even know what
emotions are there for?

00:37:36.756 --> 00:37:39.156
Can they tolerate what's
happening in their emotional life?

00:37:39.156 --> 00:37:43.816
Can they feel it, tolerate it, process
it, versus whether they learned early and

00:37:43.816 --> 00:37:46.006
out of necessity to simply shut it down.

00:37:46.766 --> 00:37:51.666
John List shut his emotions down
so completely, so early, that by

00:37:51.666 --> 00:37:55.456
adulthood, there really wasn't much
emotional interior left to access.

00:37:56.156 --> 00:38:00.166
What was there, , had been bricked over
by performance and rigidity and a set of

00:38:00.166 --> 00:38:05.346
rules that told him exactly who to be at
all times and left no room for the messy

00:38:05.346 --> 00:38:06.916
business of being a real human being.

00:38:08.056 --> 00:38:12.036
Back to acceptance and commitment therapy,
in ACT, psychological flexibility is

00:38:12.036 --> 00:38:15.716
considered one of the cornerstones of
the modality, and I think it's one of the

00:38:15.716 --> 00:38:17.286
cornerstones of mental health in general.

00:38:17.556 --> 00:38:19.016
Psychological flexibility.

00:38:19.446 --> 00:38:22.946
It's the ability to be in contact
with the present moment, including

00:38:22.946 --> 00:38:27.026
difficult emotions, difficult realities,
without being overwhelmed by them

00:38:27.026 --> 00:38:30.786
or, or rigidly defending against
them The opposite psychological

00:38:30.816 --> 00:38:34.196
inflexibility shows up in a few ways
that I think are easy to recognize.

00:38:34.696 --> 00:38:38.326
One of them is called experiential
avoidance, meaning I am, I'm avoiding,

00:38:38.426 --> 00:38:40.776
I am avoiding whatever has happened
and doing whatever it takes to

00:38:40.776 --> 00:38:42.236
not feel the uncomfortable thing.

00:38:42.606 --> 00:38:45.706
Staying busy, staying controlled,
sealing off the room, not allowing

00:38:45.706 --> 00:38:49.716
yourself to even think about things
without having music or a podcast or

00:38:49.716 --> 00:38:51.076
something blasting in the background.

00:38:52.016 --> 00:38:53.546
So you've got that experiential avoidance.

00:38:53.546 --> 00:38:56.796
I'm gonna do anything other than be
here in the - in the present moment

00:38:56.856 --> 00:38:59.929
because I don't even know how I feel,
and I don't know what to do with

00:38:59.929 --> 00:39:01.029
any of the emotions or feelings.

00:39:01.769 --> 00:39:05.449
And then there's another term
called cognitive fusion, merging

00:39:05.449 --> 00:39:08.449
with a story so completely that you
can't see it as a story anymore.

00:39:09.459 --> 00:39:11.889
And I've got a couple other concepts
and then we'll , make sense of these.

00:39:11.919 --> 00:39:15.109
Another one's rule-governed
rigidity, and this is the piece

00:39:15.109 --> 00:39:16.629
most specific to John List.

00:39:17.179 --> 00:39:20.529
Rule-governed rigidity is a way of
moving through the world organized

00:39:20.879 --> 00:39:25.129
almost entirely around rules, explicit
rules, implicit rules, religious

00:39:25.129 --> 00:39:26.629
rules, social rules, family rules.

00:39:27.199 --> 00:39:29.259
And what's interesting is
the psychological function of

00:39:29.259 --> 00:39:31.809
those rules is it makes sense.

00:39:31.809 --> 00:39:35.269
It's there, the rules are there
to eliminate uncertainty, to make

00:39:35.269 --> 00:39:38.019
the world so predictable that
nothing unexpected can get in.

00:39:38.079 --> 00:39:41.069
And the theory is that that
will make me feel better, and

00:39:41.069 --> 00:39:42.079
then I can go through life.

00:39:43.059 --> 00:39:45.709
But there's a, a fundamental difference
between somebody who holds their

00:39:45.709 --> 00:39:49.119
rules lightly, who can adjust when
the situation calls for it, and then

00:39:49.119 --> 00:39:51.839
somebody who holds them as though
their very survival depends on them.

00:39:52.399 --> 00:39:55.049
John List held his rules as though
his survival depended on them

00:39:55.079 --> 00:39:58.649
because a- as we've identified, at
the level of his psyche, it did.

00:39:59.299 --> 00:40:01.729
His rules told him who he was,
the good provider, the faithful

00:40:01.729 --> 00:40:02.999
husband, the church elder.

00:40:03.579 --> 00:40:04.689
Th-those aren't values.

00:40:04.719 --> 00:40:07.809
They were the architecture of
his self, the only thing standing

00:40:07.809 --> 00:40:11.479
between him and the terrifying void
of not knowing who he was at all.

00:40:12.339 --> 00:40:15.379
And what's fascinating about this
is you are going through life for

00:40:15.379 --> 00:40:18.029
the very first time as you, and you
are the only version of you that's

00:40:18.029 --> 00:40:19.509
ever existed on the planet Earth.

00:40:19.869 --> 00:40:22.109
And you are this unique combination
of your nature and nurture and

00:40:22.109 --> 00:40:24.679
birth order and abandonment and
DNA and hopes and dreams and fears.

00:40:25.009 --> 00:40:28.039
So you're actually reacting to
things the way you are because

00:40:28.039 --> 00:40:29.169
that's how you're reacting to them.

00:40:30.219 --> 00:40:34.279
And if you don't feel comfortable in
your own skin or as you are, then it

00:40:34.279 --> 00:40:37.399
would make sense that you're turning
to someone else to say, "Hey, how

00:40:37.399 --> 00:40:38.359
should I feel about this thing?

00:40:38.689 --> 00:40:39.729
How should I think about this thing?

00:40:39.939 --> 00:40:44.039
What should I do?" And you rely so,
so inherently on, on the validation

00:40:44.039 --> 00:40:47.969
of others, on external validation,
that at some point, just what it feels

00:40:47.969 --> 00:40:52.229
like to be you is I need to be told
what to do in every situation because

00:40:52.229 --> 00:40:56.399
then I don't have to take ownership
or accountability of if my life didn't

00:40:56.399 --> 00:40:57.349
go the way that I thought it would.

00:40:57.499 --> 00:41:01.639
I can say, "Well, the pastor said," or,
"My parents said," or, "God said," instead

00:41:01.639 --> 00:41:05.549
of just being and doing and existing
and figuring things out on your own.

00:41:06.529 --> 00:41:09.709
And then what rigidity does to a
family, so if a parent organizes

00:41:09.709 --> 00:41:13.139
their interior world around these
rigid rules, then the family stops

00:41:13.139 --> 00:41:16.529
being a living, dynamic system, and
it starts being all about performance.

00:41:16.859 --> 00:41:19.259
Kids learn early that their
job is not to be themselves.

00:41:19.529 --> 00:41:22.999
Their job is to maintain this
performance , don't rock the boat.

00:41:23.259 --> 00:41:25.979
Don't bring anything into the room
that might destabilize this very

00:41:25.979 --> 00:41:30.799
fragile architecture that the most
immature person in the room, often

00:41:30.829 --> 00:41:34.099
the most emotionally immature
narcissistic parent, has constructed.

00:41:34.429 --> 00:41:37.939
And the cruel irony is that
the most inflexible person in

00:41:37.939 --> 00:41:40.259
the room is the most fragile.

00:41:40.569 --> 00:41:42.029
The rigidity is not a strength.

00:41:42.059 --> 00:41:44.969
It's a symptom of how much internal
terror is being held at bay.

00:41:45.289 --> 00:41:49.419
So John List's iron control was the
behavior of a person one crack away

00:41:49.419 --> 00:41:52.939
from internal collapse at almost any
given moment until that crack appeared.

00:41:53.349 --> 00:41:55.789
So I would imagine, I was gonna
say guarantee, but I can't go

00:41:55.789 --> 00:41:59.329
back in time, that his kids,
his wife, his mom felt that.

00:41:59.379 --> 00:42:01.889
It was the, "Oh man, which version
of John do we have walking in

00:42:01.889 --> 00:42:04.439
today? Just something seems off.
He seems a little bit tense." Let's

00:42:04.439 --> 00:42:06.289
talk about the 18-year period.

00:42:06.359 --> 00:42:09.959
After November 9th, 1971, then
John List drove to Denver.

00:42:10.249 --> 00:42:11.189
He became Bob Clark.

00:42:11.409 --> 00:42:12.239
He got a job.

00:42:12.349 --> 00:42:13.289
He joined another church.

00:42:13.359 --> 00:42:14.289
He became a church elder.

00:42:14.319 --> 00:42:18.419
He married a woman, Dolores, who
described him as gentle and kind,

00:42:18.419 --> 00:42:21.779
and I cannot even imagine what that
would be like for Dolores whenever

00:42:21.779 --> 00:42:23.869
she discovered what had happened.

00:42:24.999 --> 00:42:28.499
But he lived this completely
normal life for 18 years.

00:42:28.689 --> 00:42:29.069
How?

00:42:29.859 --> 00:42:32.729
Because John List had been living
exactly like this his entire life,

00:42:33.229 --> 00:42:37.289
the capacity to seal off an interior
reality and just continue to perform.

00:42:37.819 --> 00:42:39.689
He had been doing that since childhood.

00:42:40.299 --> 00:42:43.639
November 9th wasn't a rupture in
his psychological functioning.

00:42:43.669 --> 00:42:47.299
It was, in a deeply disturbing
way, pretty consistent with it.

00:42:48.099 --> 00:42:50.379
He didn't flee and rebuild
because he was resilient.

00:42:50.409 --> 00:42:52.419
He fled and rebuilt because
he had never actually built

00:42:52.419 --> 00:42:53.409
anything in the first place.

00:42:53.699 --> 00:42:54.719
He'd only performed.

00:42:55.039 --> 00:42:56.799
And performing, that's portable.

00:42:57.269 --> 00:43:00.389
You can do it as John List in
New Jersey and as Bob Clark in

00:43:00.389 --> 00:43:04.269
Virginia, and the machinery works
pretty much the same because it was

00:43:04.269 --> 00:43:05.689
never connected to anything real.

00:43:05.979 --> 00:43:10.639
I see this when people divorce a, a true
narcissistic person, and then that person

00:43:10.639 --> 00:43:14.029
moves into a different relationship, and
all of a sudden they're doing everything

00:43:14.029 --> 00:43:17.439
that they said they would never do
in the relationship with the person

00:43:17.439 --> 00:43:21.609
that I'm now working with post-divorce
because they just pick up the sense of

00:43:21.609 --> 00:43:25.146
self of whatever they need to be in that
moment., Never connected to anything real.

00:43:25.356 --> 00:43:27.426
Emotional immaturity is not a nothing.

00:43:27.736 --> 00:43:31.736
It's an active, ongoing, energy-consuming
process of keeping reality at bay,

00:43:32.046 --> 00:43:35.986
and that process has costs, not always
for the person doing it, because for

00:43:35.986 --> 00:43:37.656
them that, that's just what they do.

00:43:38.216 --> 00:43:42.656
But it has a cost for the people around
them because you cannot be in a genuine

00:43:42.656 --> 00:43:44.506
relationship with a performance.

00:43:44.846 --> 00:43:47.006
You can't actually be loved by
somebody who has never developed

00:43:47.006 --> 00:43:50.516
the capacity to see you as a real,
separate, complex human being

00:43:50.516 --> 00:43:51.706
because they don't know who they are.

00:43:52.476 --> 00:43:56.316
I work with a lot of people who grew
up w-with someone like this, not a

00:43:56.316 --> 00:43:59.376
murderer obviously, but somebody with
the same emotional architecture, the

00:43:59.376 --> 00:44:03.386
rigidity, the rules, the complete
unavailability of a genuine interior life.

00:44:04.096 --> 00:44:06.996
And the thing that I hear over and
over is, "I always felt like I was

00:44:06.996 --> 00:44:08.296
supposed to be something for him.

00:44:08.736 --> 00:44:11.221
I, you know, I never felt like I
could just be me." And so I have the

00:44:11.221 --> 00:44:14.491
people in my office now trying to even
figure out at thirty, forty, fifty

00:44:14.551 --> 00:44:17.401
somebody in their seventies trying
to say, "I don't even know who I

00:44:17.401 --> 00:44:19.901
am," but now is the time to find out.

00:44:20.191 --> 00:44:22.561
I sometimes call this the
legacy of emotional immaturity.

00:44:22.851 --> 00:44:26.811
Not always dramatic, not always even
visible from the outside, but deeply

00:44:26.811 --> 00:44:30.111
and quietly kind of persistently
shaping what children believe love

00:44:30.111 --> 00:44:33.131
is supposed to feel like, what they
believe they are allowed to be.

00:44:33.831 --> 00:44:36.761
The work of undoing that, that's probably
some of the most important therapeutic

00:44:36.761 --> 00:44:41.301
work there is, but it does start with
naming what happened, understanding that

00:44:41.301 --> 00:44:43.261
the unavailability wasn't your fault.

00:44:43.521 --> 00:44:46.831
It's not a reflection of your
worth as a kid, not something you

00:44:46.831 --> 00:44:50.571
could have fixed by being smaller
or quieter or performing better.

00:44:51.201 --> 00:44:54.371
You couldn't have fixed it because
as much as it feels like it was

00:44:54.371 --> 00:44:56.061
about us, it never was about you.

00:44:56.281 --> 00:44:58.471
It was always entirely about them.

00:44:58.628 --> 00:45:01.788
A client asked me a question a few
years ago that I think about often.

00:45:01.998 --> 00:45:04.798
We were deep in a session, somebody
who had spent the better part of their

00:45:04.798 --> 00:45:08.188
adult life performing a version of
themselves built by other people, going

00:45:08.188 --> 00:45:11.398
through a nice faith deconstruction,
a faith crisis, and at one point

00:45:11.398 --> 00:45:14.228
they looked over at me and said,
"What if there's nothing underneath?

00:45:14.768 --> 00:45:18.378
What if I've been performing so long
that there's actually nobody in here?

00:45:18.621 --> 00:45:19.641
, This is just who I am.

00:45:19.691 --> 00:45:22.361
What if I am the chameleon?" Sit
there with that one for a second

00:45:22.471 --> 00:45:26.351
before you connect it to John List,
because I hear this one often, and I

00:45:26.351 --> 00:45:28.921
think it's one of the most important
questions that you can ask yourself.

00:45:29.841 --> 00:45:33.451
The answer is the beginning of
something genuinely hopeful, but John

00:45:33.451 --> 00:45:36.181
List is, in a terrible way, a case
study in what happens when somebody

00:45:36.181 --> 00:45:39.751
asks a version of that question and
they get the worst possible answer.

00:45:40.511 --> 00:45:42.941
In ACT there's a distinction
between the conceptualized

00:45:42.941 --> 00:45:44.831
self and the observing self.

00:45:45.231 --> 00:45:47.371
The conceptualized self is the story.

00:45:47.521 --> 00:45:49.941
It's the collection of roles
and labels and narratives.

00:45:49.941 --> 00:45:50.711
"I am provider.

00:45:50.761 --> 00:45:51.491
I am a good father.

00:45:51.491 --> 00:45:52.101
I am devout.

00:45:52.451 --> 00:45:55.451
I am in control." It's the
content of your identity.

00:45:55.951 --> 00:45:57.411
It's the what of who you are.

00:45:57.821 --> 00:45:59.361
Now, the observing self is different.

00:46:00.031 --> 00:46:03.991
It's the part that notices the
story, that can step back and watch

00:46:03.991 --> 00:46:06.461
your own thoughts and patterns
without being consumed by them.

00:46:07.001 --> 00:46:10.191
It's the awareness itself
instead of what's being observed.

00:46:10.991 --> 00:46:16.358
It's, , a beautiful concept called self
as context instead of yourself as content.

00:46:16.838 --> 00:46:20.978
John List had the conceptualized self
that was extraordinarily elaborate

00:46:21.078 --> 00:46:25.788
and extraordinarily brittle, and he
had, I'd argue, no observing self

00:46:25.788 --> 00:46:28.834
or the abi-ability to step back
and see himself in these moments.

00:46:29.404 --> 00:46:33.404
No capacity to step back and say, "Oh,
this, this story is in trouble, and

00:46:33.404 --> 00:46:37.634
I need to take a look at that." When
reality dismantled the story, all of a

00:46:37.634 --> 00:46:40.684
sudden he's losing his job, his home,
he can't go, "Well, check that out.

00:46:41.084 --> 00:46:43.854
This version of me that I thought
that this is how things would

00:46:43.854 --> 00:46:45.214
play out, that's not happening."

00:46:45.684 --> 00:46:47.754
And so now I can look and say,
"What's the story my brain , tells me?

00:46:47.804 --> 00:46:48.804
That I needed to be perfect.

00:46:48.834 --> 00:46:50.484
Oh, it's the old I need
to be perfect story.

00:46:50.844 --> 00:46:51.544
I'm noticing that.

00:46:51.574 --> 00:46:55.591
I can step away from it." When reality
dismantled the story, there was nothing

00:46:55.591 --> 00:46:58.781
underneath to catch him, no grounded
awareness that could say, "Oh, this

00:46:58.781 --> 00:47:00.621
story's falling apart, but I'm still here.

00:47:00.801 --> 00:47:01.781
The world's still spinning.

00:47:01.781 --> 00:47:06.394
I can survive this." Just the story,
and with the story falling apart and him

00:47:06.424 --> 00:47:10.664
making The most catastrophic possible
attempt to hold it together because

00:47:10.784 --> 00:47:12.614
he , didn't change, he relocated.

00:47:13.324 --> 00:47:18.264
, It's kinda haunting that after everything,
John List built a new conceptualized self,

00:47:18.634 --> 00:47:22.544
new story, new roles, gentle husband,
reliable employee, devoted church elder,

00:47:22.804 --> 00:47:27.194
and by all accounts, he then inhabited it
with exactly the same completeness, the

00:47:27.194 --> 00:47:30.844
same apparent conviction, the same absence
of internal conflict as the old one.

00:47:31.714 --> 00:47:32.864
He didn't rebuild himself.

00:47:32.864 --> 00:47:35.934
He just picked up a new story and put
it on, kinda like changing clothes.

00:47:36.574 --> 00:47:38.744
Genuine change doesn't happen
at the level of the story.

00:47:38.884 --> 00:47:41.924
You can't swap out one narrative for
another and then call it transformation.

00:47:42.434 --> 00:47:46.014
The self you're running from comes with
you until you turn around and face it.

00:47:46.644 --> 00:47:50.754
You get into a relationship with your
own interior experience, your own

00:47:50.754 --> 00:47:52.764
history, your own capacity for harm.

00:47:53.524 --> 00:47:56.274
The new story in his scenario
is just a new facade over the

00:47:56.274 --> 00:47:57.764
same unexamined foundation.

00:47:58.084 --> 00:47:59.834
I see people do versions of this often.

00:48:00.194 --> 00:48:02.314
They leave a marriage and immediately
enter a new relationship and

00:48:02.314 --> 00:48:04.284
wonder, "Why did, why on earth
did the same pattern show up?

00:48:04.314 --> 00:48:07.554
I left the bad relationship, and this
one seems so good." Or they move to a new

00:48:07.554 --> 00:48:10.214
city, and they reinvent their wardrobe
and change their friend group and slowly

00:48:10.214 --> 00:48:14.374
find themselves feeling exactly the
same, stuck, unseen, performing, and

00:48:14.374 --> 00:48:17.854
afraid because they changed the story,
but they didn't do the work of examining

00:48:17.854 --> 00:48:20.864
the storyteller, and the storyteller
comes with you every single time.

00:48:21.374 --> 00:48:24.634
Now, there are examples of this where
you do go to a new place, and you have

00:48:24.634 --> 00:48:28.934
this opportunity to reinvent yourself,
to become the new version of you, but

00:48:29.024 --> 00:48:32.854
that is successful when you've done the
work internally to figure out why it is

00:48:32.854 --> 00:48:34.124
that you show up the way that you do.

00:48:34.874 --> 00:48:35.824
So that's the real work.

00:48:35.824 --> 00:48:37.484
What does that excavation look like?

00:48:37.924 --> 00:48:41.204
And I, I wanna resist making it
sound easier and tidier than it

00:48:41.204 --> 00:48:44.224
is 'cause it's not just a weekend
workshop or a journaling exercise

00:48:44.224 --> 00:48:45.884
or just taking a few deep breaths.

00:48:46.574 --> 00:48:52.614
It's the slow, nonlinear, frequently
uncomfortable process of learning to be

00:48:52.614 --> 00:48:57.254
in genuine contact with your own internal
experience, developing the capacity to

00:48:57.254 --> 00:49:01.264
feel what you actually feel instead of
what you think you're supposed to feel.

00:49:01.894 --> 00:49:05.254
It's building enough psychological
safety inside yourself first that

00:49:05.254 --> 00:49:08.864
you can look at the most painful,
most shameful, most sealed-off parts

00:49:08.864 --> 00:49:11.344
of your history and be with them.

00:49:11.954 --> 00:49:14.554
It's gonna sound like
nothing but woo-woo at first.

00:49:15.074 --> 00:49:20.154
It's the feel the feelings, and it
doesn't make a lot of sense until it

00:49:20.154 --> 00:49:24.674
does, I've had to go through it myself
as a therapist working with my own

00:49:24.674 --> 00:49:28.594
therapist, that at first we even have to
know where do we feel the things that we

00:49:28.594 --> 00:49:31.384
feel, and we need to allow them to be.

00:49:31.824 --> 00:49:35.194
It gets, so ethereal and
all the words I've heard,

00:49:35.364 --> 00:49:36.954
hippy-dippy, woo-woo, you name it.

00:49:37.614 --> 00:49:39.904
But you have to allow yourself to feel.

00:49:39.904 --> 00:49:42.494
You breathe into the feelings, you thank
the feelings for being there, you give

00:49:42.494 --> 00:49:46.104
them time, and sometimes you don't do
anything with them, and the world spins,

00:49:46.474 --> 00:49:48.134
and the feelings eventually dissipate.

00:49:48.674 --> 00:49:50.674
At some point then, you're gonna
listen to them, and they're gonna

00:49:50.674 --> 00:49:53.994
tell you stories, and most likely your
first reaction is gonna be to want to

00:49:53.994 --> 00:49:56.664
get rid of them, to intellectualize
them, to try to make sense of them.

00:49:57.014 --> 00:49:59.304
And often the way you're trying to
make sense of them is still gonna

00:49:59.304 --> 00:50:02.234
be of something, a blame yourself
thing, and that goes back to that,

00:50:02.744 --> 00:50:06.564
programming that got inherited as a
kid that, "Well, it must be my fault.

00:50:06.564 --> 00:50:10.194
It must be something I'm doing wrong,"
versus, "Oh, this feeling could be

00:50:10.194 --> 00:50:13.734
providing me a roadmap that this,
I this situation doesn't feel safe.

00:50:14.094 --> 00:50:18.694
This doesn't feel like the right thing
for me to do right now." So learning

00:50:18.694 --> 00:50:21.294
to look at these most painful, , most
shameful, most sealed off parts of

00:50:21.294 --> 00:50:24.574
your history and be with them and
not fix them, and sit with them and

00:50:24.574 --> 00:50:27.124
acknowledge them, not perform a new
story about them, just be with them.

00:50:27.494 --> 00:50:29.694
And eventually, they actually
do start telling you stories.

00:50:30.084 --> 00:50:31.114
It's your own intuition.

00:50:31.174 --> 00:50:31.814
It's your gut.

00:50:32.814 --> 00:50:33.944
, This is acceptance.

00:50:34.264 --> 00:50:35.034
It's not approval.

00:50:35.474 --> 00:50:37.514
It- it's more of a willingness
to make contact with your

00:50:37.514 --> 00:50:39.474
experience as it actually is.

00:50:40.254 --> 00:50:42.544
And here's what that
acceptance makes possible.

00:50:43.164 --> 00:50:46.654
When you can learn to actually be with
your own experience, you free up an

00:50:46.654 --> 00:50:50.544
enormous amount of interior resources,
your emotional calories being burnt on

00:50:50.794 --> 00:50:53.764
trying to ruminate and beat yourself
up and figure out what's going on.

00:50:54.694 --> 00:50:58.384
You'll recognize how much time you spend
on that, and those are resources that

00:50:58.384 --> 00:51:01.894
are now available to go toward genuine
connection, toward actually showing up

00:51:01.894 --> 00:51:05.734
as a full, present, complex human being
instead of this curated performance of

00:51:05.734 --> 00:51:06.944
who you think you're supposed to be.

00:51:07.594 --> 00:51:11.424
You become somebody who can be known,
and being known, genuinely known,

00:51:12.084 --> 00:51:17.094
in all your complexity and all your
messiness, is the only foundation that

00:51:17.094 --> 00:51:19.174
real, real intimacy can be built on.

00:51:19.764 --> 00:51:22.574
Takes a lot of courage , to be known,
and it takes a lot of courage to

00:51:22.574 --> 00:51:28.294
genuinely know somebody and realize
that we're two wonderfully flawed

00:51:28.548 --> 00:51:31.518
human beings going through life for
the first time experiencing things.

00:51:32.248 --> 00:51:36.968
John List was never known, not by
his first wife, not by his children,

00:51:37.208 --> 00:51:41.028
not by his mom, not by his second
wife, because the real self was

00:51:41.028 --> 00:51:44.738
locked in a room he refused to open
for anybody, including himself.

00:51:45.488 --> 00:51:49.688
His second wife, Dolores, said after
the arrest she had no idea that the man

00:51:49.688 --> 00:51:53.388
that she married was gentle and warm
and that she had felt genuine love.

00:51:53.658 --> 00:51:57.728
And I believe her, because within the
limits of his architecture, he probably

00:51:57.728 --> 00:52:01.678
was a reasonably attentive partner,
but it just wasn't enough, because the

00:52:01.678 --> 00:52:09.003
intimacy was constructed on a total
false foundation on concealment The man

00:52:09.003 --> 00:52:10.633
that she was married to did not exist.

00:52:11.203 --> 00:52:13.413
Real intimacy cannot be
built on concealment.

00:52:13.973 --> 00:52:16.953
Real love can't survive the
fundamental unavailability of the

00:52:16.953 --> 00:52:18.433
person that you believe you love.

00:52:19.163 --> 00:52:21.133
That question that my client
asked earlier, "What if there's

00:52:21.133 --> 00:52:23.503
nothing underneath?" Here's
what I've come to believe.

00:52:23.903 --> 00:52:25.643
There's always something underneath.

00:52:26.123 --> 00:52:26.623
Always.

00:52:27.323 --> 00:52:29.993
The observing self doesn't disappear
just because it's been buried

00:52:29.993 --> 00:52:31.293
under decades of performance.

00:52:31.923 --> 00:52:34.283
It doesn't go away because nobody
ever made it safe to come out.

00:52:34.313 --> 00:52:35.013
It's there.

00:52:35.103 --> 00:52:35.963
It's always been there.

00:52:36.833 --> 00:52:39.193
So the work isn't about
constructing a self.

00:52:39.843 --> 00:52:42.743
The work is about excavating a self.

00:52:43.353 --> 00:52:45.153
One that was already there.

00:52:45.883 --> 00:52:47.383
John List never did that work.

00:52:47.423 --> 00:52:48.903
He didn't even know that work existed.

00:52:49.513 --> 00:52:53.913
He died in prison at 82, having
been genuinely unknown even to

00:52:53.913 --> 00:52:55.493
himself for his entire life.

00:52:56.763 --> 00:52:57.783
So let's bring this thing home.

00:52:58.753 --> 00:53:01.373
Why does a story like this reach
inside of us and grab something?

00:53:02.143 --> 00:53:05.423
Why can't we just file it under disturbed
individual, next case, and move on?

00:53:06.213 --> 00:53:09.463
Because the cases that stay with us
are touching something, making contact

00:53:09.463 --> 00:53:12.863
with some part of our own interior
landscape that recognizes, even if

00:53:12.863 --> 00:53:16.663
it doesn't want to admit it, that
sometimes the distance between us and

00:53:16.663 --> 00:53:20.023
the person that we're reading about
isn't always as vast as we'd like.

00:53:20.023 --> 00:53:20.933
Now, not in behavior.

00:53:20.933 --> 00:53:22.783
The behavior is horrific, absolutely.

00:53:23.453 --> 00:53:27.133
But the psychology underneath, the
shame, the rigidity, the performance,

00:53:27.133 --> 00:53:30.633
the terror of being truly known,
that psychology isn't alien.

00:53:31.243 --> 00:53:36.483
That psychology is human, and that's
what true crime at its best does for us.

00:53:36.673 --> 00:53:40.893
Not just to titillate, not to
horrify, but it illuminates things.

00:53:41.179 --> 00:53:43.019
Here's what I think the John
List case is really about.

00:53:43.649 --> 00:53:47.019
What happens when a person spends an
entire lifetime refusing the fundamental

00:53:47.019 --> 00:53:48.759
vulnerability of being a real human being?

00:53:49.339 --> 00:53:51.969
Everything that we talked about today,
the shame, the compartmentalization,

00:53:51.969 --> 00:53:55.469
the narcissistic injury, the altruistic
defense, the emotional immaturity,

00:53:55.469 --> 00:54:01.119
the identity built on performance, all
of it is downstream of that, that one

00:54:01.119 --> 00:54:05.809
refusal, the refusal to be real, to be
known, to let the gap between who you're

00:54:05.809 --> 00:54:10.979
supposed to be and who you actually
are, and then becoming that person

00:54:11.679 --> 00:54:15.179
becoming something that you can sit with,
grieve, and then eventually integrate.

00:54:15.899 --> 00:54:17.779
But the refusal is not inevitable.

00:54:18.269 --> 00:54:19.349
Patterns can be interrupted.

00:54:19.879 --> 00:54:25.579
These architectures built on shame and
performance can be slowly, painfully, with

00:54:25.579 --> 00:54:29.609
the right tools and support, dismantled
and rebuilt on something honest.

00:54:30.109 --> 00:54:31.149
That's what therapy's for.

00:54:31.303 --> 00:54:33.833
I deal with a lot of people that are
navigating their faith journeys, their

00:54:33.833 --> 00:54:36.993
faith deconstructions, and I wanna touch
on that real quick here, the faith piece.

00:54:36.993 --> 00:54:40.393
John List's Lutheran faith was
not incidental to what he did.

00:54:40.503 --> 00:54:44.253
It was central, and I'm not saying
this from a blame standpoint.

00:54:44.833 --> 00:54:48.193
I just think that it provided the
language for the altruistic defense the

00:54:48.193 --> 00:54:51.263
framework for his rigidity, and then
the most painful irony at the heart of

00:54:51.263 --> 00:54:56.013
the story because the tradition that
he drew on, Christianity in its most

00:54:56.013 --> 00:55:00.081
generous expression is built around
the exact opposite message, - that you

00:55:00.081 --> 00:55:03.571
are known fully and loved anyway, that
the gap between who you are and who

00:55:03.571 --> 00:55:06.441
you're supposed to be isn't something
to conceal, but something to bring into

00:55:06.441 --> 00:55:08.051
the light, to let your light so shine.

00:55:08.981 --> 00:55:12.451
The message itself that grace
is offered in the mess, not

00:55:12.481 --> 00:55:13.531
earned through performance.

00:55:14.041 --> 00:55:16.271
John List had access to that
message his entire life.

00:55:16.841 --> 00:55:20.001
He sat in church every Sunday,
and it never sank in because

00:55:20.001 --> 00:55:21.201
the shame was too thick.

00:55:21.391 --> 00:55:22.601
The architecture was too rigid.

00:55:23.291 --> 00:55:26.331
If you grew up in a religious environment
where faith was a performance standard

00:55:26.381 --> 00:55:30.161
instead of a refuge, where God was a
scorekeeper instead of a presence, I

00:55:30.161 --> 00:55:31.651
want to say something directly to you.

00:55:32.351 --> 00:55:35.191
I think the version that you might have
been handed isn't the only version.

00:55:35.881 --> 00:55:40.241
You're allowed to renegotiate that
relationship with, with the Almighty.

00:55:40.241 --> 00:55:43.791
You're allowed to find a version that
has room for your actual self, your

00:55:43.791 --> 00:55:45.931
messy, complicated, entirely human self.

00:55:46.501 --> 00:55:50.311
You're allowed to be known, and you
are allowed to be loved in the knowing.

00:55:51.331 --> 00:55:56.791
If I'm speaking fluent Christianity to
someone of that faith, the concept of

00:55:56.791 --> 00:55:59.601
God's the same yesterday, today, and
tomorrow, and his love is unconditional

00:55:59.751 --> 00:56:01.631
means that he loves you because he does.

00:56:02.371 --> 00:56:05.401
And that means that he is
probably the most differentiated

00:56:05.621 --> 00:56:08.911
parental figure, literally or
figuratively, that there could be.

00:56:09.491 --> 00:56:13.761
So then when we mess up, and I am
air quoting that, and we say, "Man,

00:56:13.761 --> 00:56:18.221
God must be mad at me," that's a me
thing, because if I'm turning back

00:56:18.221 --> 00:56:21.331
to that God who's the same yesterday,
today, and tomorrow and who loves me

00:56:21.961 --> 00:56:26.161
then it's a me thing, and I would turn
back to that person whenever I could.

00:56:27.181 --> 00:56:30.691
And I deal often with people navigating
faith journey, faith deconstruction, where

00:56:30.691 --> 00:56:34.111
sometimes there's a really fascinating
concept of where the more you begin

00:56:34.111 --> 00:56:38.701
to love yourself, the more you realize
your relationship with God changes.

00:56:39.261 --> 00:56:42.361
That when you are a little kid and you
don't like yourself, or if you are going

00:56:42.361 --> 00:56:45.541
through and experiencing tremendous
amounts of shame and guilt and fear,

00:56:46.081 --> 00:56:47.851
you then project that out to God.

00:56:48.581 --> 00:56:50.521
But when you love yourself it's funny.

00:56:50.521 --> 00:56:54.051
It's almost ironic to see how your
relationship with God changes.

00:56:54.281 --> 00:56:57.201
So John List was handed a self before
he was old enough to choose one.

00:56:57.631 --> 00:56:59.471
He never developed the
capacity to tolerate shame.

00:56:59.991 --> 00:57:02.511
He never built the observing self that
could stand outside of his story and

00:57:02.511 --> 00:57:03.961
say, "Hey, this story is not working.

00:57:04.681 --> 00:57:05.671
Let me look at that honestly.

00:57:05.741 --> 00:57:06.441
Let me ask for help.

00:57:06.601 --> 00:57:08.771
Let me grieve what I'm losing
instead of destroy it before

00:57:08.771 --> 00:57:09.971
anybody else can see me lose it."

00:57:10.581 --> 00:57:13.801
He built this fortress instead,
then he defended it in the most

00:57:13.801 --> 00:57:15.201
devastating way imaginable.

00:57:15.671 --> 00:57:19.801
Walked away, built another fortress,
lived inside of it for 18 years until

00:57:19.801 --> 00:57:22.751
a TV show and a woman looking out her
window said, "I think I know who that

00:57:22.751 --> 00:57:26.831
is." He maintained it to the end that
what he had done was an act of love.

00:57:27.281 --> 00:57:30.971
That fortress held even at the very
end, because cracking it would have

00:57:30.971 --> 00:57:33.841
meant becoming real, and becoming
real was the one thing that he spent

00:57:33.841 --> 00:57:35.651
his entire life refusing to do.

00:57:35.761 --> 00:57:38.011
Now, before I let you go, I
meant what I said at the top.

00:57:38.221 --> 00:57:39.131
I'm looking for co-hosts.

00:57:39.511 --> 00:57:42.091
If you followed this episode, you found
yourself thinking about the psychological

00:57:42.091 --> 00:57:43.381
underpinnings of what you were hearing.

00:57:43.881 --> 00:57:46.501
If you have a case that's gotten
under your skin and you know why,

00:57:46.831 --> 00:57:50.516
maybe even you don't know why Email
me at contact at tonyoverbay.com.

00:57:50.946 --> 00:57:54.546
Tell me who you are, the case you want
to cover, and anything else that you

00:57:54.546 --> 00:57:56.896
think would be helpful, the therapeutic
angles you think are worth exploring.

00:57:57.556 --> 00:58:00.486
And I will share this on the virtual
couch and waking up to narcissism too.

00:58:00.606 --> 00:58:05.166
I look forward to hearing from hopefully
a lot of you that might find this to

00:58:05.166 --> 00:58:07.266
be a pretty interesting experience.

00:58:07.886 --> 00:58:12.526
As directly as I know how, shame grows in
concealment and it shrinks in connection.

00:58:13.186 --> 00:58:16.436
The thing that you're most afraid for
people to know about you, the failure, the

00:58:16.436 --> 00:58:19.486
debt, the marriage that's falling apart,
the identity that's starting to crack,

00:58:19.486 --> 00:58:22.866
whether you like or don't like your job,
if you feel very vulnerable as a parent,

00:58:23.226 --> 00:58:26.956
or if you don't know, if you're struggling
with your faith, having a good old faith

00:58:27.176 --> 00:58:32.096
deconstruction, that thing does not become
more manageable when you seal it off.

00:58:32.326 --> 00:58:34.126
It doesn't get better eventually.

00:58:34.696 --> 00:58:37.496
Be aware of magical thinking
that, oh, it'll be better later.

00:58:38.286 --> 00:58:41.026
It becomes more powerful,
actually, the more that you don't

00:58:41.026 --> 00:58:41.906
bring it out into the light.

00:58:42.076 --> 00:58:43.566
It becomes this load-bearing wall.

00:58:44.136 --> 00:58:47.516
But the antidote, and I know this sounds
almost insultingly simple for everything

00:58:47.516 --> 00:58:50.356
that we've been through today, but I
mean it with everything I have, the

00:58:50.356 --> 00:58:52.656
antidote is starting to tell the truth.

00:58:53.606 --> 00:58:55.346
And that can be to somebody safe.

00:58:55.526 --> 00:58:58.036
And sometimes it starts with
telling the truth to yourself.

00:58:58.159 --> 00:58:59.009
Not everybody's safe.

00:58:59.259 --> 00:59:01.329
You don't owe your
interior life to everybody.

00:59:01.919 --> 00:59:05.109
But somebody, a therapist, a trusted
friend, a partner who has earned the

00:59:05.109 --> 00:59:07.796
right to the real you, Somebody who
can receive who you actually are..

00:59:07.889 --> 00:59:11.323
Because here's what happens over
and over again in my office.

00:59:11.793 --> 00:59:15.233
People finally do that when they bring
the sealed-off thing into the room

00:59:15.513 --> 00:59:16.703
and let another person witness it.

00:59:17.403 --> 00:59:18.573
It does not destroy them.

00:59:19.163 --> 00:59:21.003
It doesn't confirm the worst
thing that they feared.

00:59:21.843 --> 00:59:24.793
What happens is they feel less
alone than they felt in years,

00:59:24.793 --> 00:59:26.333
sometimes decades, sometimes ever.

00:59:26.943 --> 00:59:30.253
The most threatening thing becomes, in
the light of genuine human connection,

00:59:30.633 --> 00:59:34.243
something that can actually be worked
with, grieved, understood, integrated.

00:59:34.953 --> 00:59:36.723
That's the exit ramp John List never took.

00:59:37.013 --> 00:59:37.823
It was always there.

00:59:37.943 --> 00:59:39.093
He drove past it every time.

00:59:39.223 --> 00:59:40.443
But you don't have to.

00:59:41.203 --> 00:59:42.283
Thanks for spending this time with me.

00:59:42.283 --> 00:59:44.763
If you're sitting with something after
listening, something personal, something

00:59:44.763 --> 00:59:46.463
uncomfortable, stay with it for a second.

00:59:46.503 --> 00:59:47.233
Don't seal it off.

00:59:47.653 --> 00:59:49.183
That discomfort is information.

00:59:49.723 --> 00:59:51.526
If this episode resonated, share it.

00:59:51.543 --> 00:59:53.993
Go leave a review wherever
you listen to podcasts.

00:59:53.993 --> 00:59:55.643
Subscribe, like, all
those wonderful things.

00:59:55.643 --> 00:59:57.873
And if you want more of the therapeutic
frameworks we talked about today,

00:59:58.683 --> 01:00:01.883
ACT, differentiation, narcissistic
injury, emotional immaturity, come

01:00:01.883 --> 01:00:04.453
find me at The Virtual Couch or
Waking Up to Narcissism or reach out

01:00:04.453 --> 01:00:06.033
to me at contact at tonyoverbay.com.

01:00:06.843 --> 01:00:08.353
Thank you so much for joining me.

01:00:08.393 --> 01:00:09.553
This has been Murder on the Couch.

01:00:10.093 --> 01:00:11.123
Have an amazing week.

01:00:11.189 --> 01:00:16.199
next time that you see another episode
come up, it will be with my first co-host.

01:00:16.739 --> 01:00:18.039
Take care and have an amazing week.

01:00:18.289 --> 01:00:19.769
We'll see you next time
on Murder on the Couch.

