WEBVTT

1
00:00:08.080 --> 00:00:11.039
- Hello, and welcome to the Physics World weekly

2
00:00:11.039 --> 00:00:11.539
- podcast.

3
00:00:11.839 --> 00:00:13.059
- I'm Hamish Johnston.

4
00:00:13.865 --> 00:00:17.484
- Credibility is a cornerstone of modern science,

5
00:00:17.864 --> 00:00:18.685
- and concepts

6
00:00:19.065 --> 00:00:20.204
- such as reproducibility

7
00:00:20.745 --> 00:00:23.005
- and peer review have evolved

8
00:00:23.385 --> 00:00:26.685
- to ensure that the knowledge produced by scientists

9
00:00:27.064 --> 00:00:28.445
- is of high quality.

10
00:00:29.710 --> 00:00:33.250
- However, for science to thrive and benefit everyone,

11
00:00:34.030 --> 00:00:34.530
- scientists

12
00:00:34.989 --> 00:00:36.770
- must be seen to be credible

13
00:00:37.229 --> 00:00:38.609
- by the general public.

14
00:00:39.469 --> 00:00:42.129
- Today, we're going to talk about a fascinating

15
00:00:42.429 --> 00:00:46.245
- new study that reveals that the motivation of

16
00:00:46.245 --> 00:00:46.984
- a scientist

17
00:00:47.445 --> 00:00:50.664
- plays an important role in how their credibility

18
00:00:50.965 --> 00:00:51.704
- is perceived

19
00:00:52.085 --> 00:00:52.905
- by the public.

20
00:00:53.844 --> 00:00:54.984
- The study involved

21
00:00:55.285 --> 00:00:56.664
- nearly 1,000

22
00:00:56.804 --> 00:00:58.505
- subjects in The US,

23
00:00:58.929 --> 00:01:01.429
- and a key result was the identification

24
00:01:02.210 --> 00:01:04.469
- of five audience classes

25
00:01:05.090 --> 00:01:07.750
- that differ in terms of their perceptions

26
00:01:08.290 --> 00:01:09.109
- of scientific

27
00:01:09.489 --> 00:01:09.989
- credibility.

28
00:01:11.170 --> 00:01:12.704
- My guests this week

29
00:01:13.025 --> 00:01:16.885
- are Shumila Batti and Dara Wold, who conducted

30
00:01:16.944 --> 00:01:17.605
- the study.

31
00:01:18.064 --> 00:01:20.005
- They're both social scientists

32
00:01:20.385 --> 00:01:21.125
- at Virginia

33
00:01:21.584 --> 00:01:22.965
- Tech in The US.

34
00:01:31.319 --> 00:01:34.459
- Hi, Shamila and Dara. Welcome to the podcast.

35
00:01:35.239 --> 00:01:37.019
- Morning. Welcome. Thank you.

36
00:01:37.400 --> 00:01:38.060
- Good morning.

37
00:01:39.159 --> 00:01:41.979
- So, Dara, my first question is for you.

38
00:01:42.745 --> 00:01:45.085
- In your study, how do you define

39
00:01:45.704 --> 00:01:46.844
- scientific credibility?

40
00:01:48.905 --> 00:01:50.204
- Yeah. That's a great question.

41
00:01:51.465 --> 00:01:53.945
- There are, in brief, lots of ways to

42
00:01:53.945 --> 00:01:54.629
- define it.

43
00:01:55.909 --> 00:01:57.349
- One of the sort of key goals of

44
00:01:57.349 --> 00:01:58.810
- this project is to understand

45
00:01:59.509 --> 00:02:01.369
- how credibility was defined

46
00:02:01.750 --> 00:02:04.149
- in a bunch of different contexts. And in

47
00:02:04.149 --> 00:02:06.789
- this study, specifically, we're looking at controversial and

48
00:02:06.789 --> 00:02:07.289
- noncontroversial

49
00:02:07.750 --> 00:02:08.205
- contexts,

50
00:02:09.245 --> 00:02:10.384
- and how it's defined

51
00:02:10.764 --> 00:02:12.064
- for different individuals.

52
00:02:13.085 --> 00:02:15.004
- I could actually spend a long time talking

53
00:02:15.004 --> 00:02:17.264
- about how credibility is defined,

54
00:02:18.284 --> 00:02:21.264
- but I think for me what's most important

55
00:02:21.564 --> 00:02:22.384
- is that

56
00:02:24.010 --> 00:02:24.750
- I want

57
00:02:25.129 --> 00:02:27.770
- people to understand that credibility is not just

58
00:02:27.770 --> 00:02:29.310
- the message that you send,

59
00:02:29.930 --> 00:02:30.909
- but it's also

60
00:02:31.610 --> 00:02:32.909
- you as the source,

61
00:02:33.370 --> 00:02:34.349
- and how you,

62
00:02:35.104 --> 00:02:36.004
- your characteristics

63
00:02:36.465 --> 00:02:37.205
- and your,

64
00:02:38.305 --> 00:02:38.805
- traits

65
00:02:39.104 --> 00:02:40.564
- and and your intentions

66
00:02:40.944 --> 00:02:41.844
- are interpreted.

67
00:02:43.104 --> 00:02:43.925
- And so

68
00:02:44.465 --> 00:02:47.459
- the audience itself, right, they're gonna they're gonna

69
00:02:47.459 --> 00:02:49.620
- think about your message from their own lens,

70
00:02:49.620 --> 00:02:51.639
- from their own perspective and worldview,

71
00:02:52.180 --> 00:02:54.259
- but they're also gonna see you through their

72
00:02:54.259 --> 00:02:55.000
- own worldview.

73
00:02:56.099 --> 00:02:57.860
- And so one of the things that I

74
00:02:57.860 --> 00:03:00.205
- was motivated by by was the the idea

75
00:03:00.205 --> 00:03:02.525
- that I think credibility means different things to

76
00:03:02.525 --> 00:03:04.844
- different people. And so as social scientists, we

77
00:03:04.844 --> 00:03:07.025
- often try to define things and give you

78
00:03:07.245 --> 00:03:10.844
- specific measures for different ideas or or constructs.

79
00:03:10.844 --> 00:03:12.705
- Right? Things in the world that we,

80
00:03:13.069 --> 00:03:14.289
- that are really complicated.

81
00:03:15.310 --> 00:03:17.069
- And and I think what I kept coming

82
00:03:17.069 --> 00:03:17.569
- across,

83
00:03:18.270 --> 00:03:19.729
- in my in my experiences

84
00:03:20.270 --> 00:03:23.569
- here was that source credibility was really complicated,

85
00:03:24.189 --> 00:03:26.689
- and it was a combination of multiple things.

86
00:03:27.014 --> 00:03:29.594
- And those things weren't always the same thing

87
00:03:29.894 --> 00:03:31.034
- for different people.

88
00:03:32.055 --> 00:03:32.875
- And so

89
00:03:33.574 --> 00:03:34.935
- what we tried to do in the article

90
00:03:34.935 --> 00:03:35.995
- is simplify that

91
00:03:36.375 --> 00:03:37.435
- and say, okay.

92
00:03:37.735 --> 00:03:39.834
- Credibility is this complex combination

93
00:03:40.614 --> 00:03:42.539
- of perceived character traits

94
00:03:43.180 --> 00:03:44.959
- and their perceived intentions.

95
00:03:46.379 --> 00:03:48.239
- And we started with

96
00:03:48.699 --> 00:03:50.239
- early definition of credibility,

97
00:03:50.939 --> 00:03:53.659
- by, you know, Aristotle, right, which defined it

98
00:03:53.659 --> 00:03:54.400
- as expertise,

99
00:03:55.194 --> 00:03:55.694
- integrity,

100
00:03:56.715 --> 00:03:57.694
- and goodwill.

101
00:03:58.954 --> 00:04:00.555
- And in our study, we listed a whole

102
00:04:00.555 --> 00:04:02.474
- bunch of other things that people have used

103
00:04:02.474 --> 00:04:05.435
- to measure it in in different articles so

104
00:04:05.435 --> 00:04:07.454
- that we could capture the breadth of it.

105
00:04:08.460 --> 00:04:10.719
- And so I think if you had to

106
00:04:10.780 --> 00:04:12.860
- go to to something really simple, you would

107
00:04:12.860 --> 00:04:13.360
- say

108
00:04:13.900 --> 00:04:15.840
- credibility includes a scientist's

109
00:04:16.220 --> 00:04:19.120
- capability, right, their talent, their skills, their knowledge.

110
00:04:19.819 --> 00:04:21.899
- It can include their results, right, what they've

111
00:04:21.899 --> 00:04:22.720
- done before.

112
00:04:23.475 --> 00:04:26.435
- It can include their signals of integrity. Right?

113
00:04:26.435 --> 00:04:28.595
- Are you saying and doing the same things?

114
00:04:28.595 --> 00:04:30.754
- Is there alignment between the things that you

115
00:04:30.754 --> 00:04:32.855
- are saying you'll do and your actions?

116
00:04:33.235 --> 00:04:34.774
- And finally, their intent,

117
00:04:35.395 --> 00:04:38.115
- and why they do something or who they

118
00:04:38.115 --> 00:04:38.910
- do it for.

119
00:04:40.830 --> 00:04:42.670
- And and, Dara, I just wanna make sure

120
00:04:42.670 --> 00:04:42.990
- that,

121
00:04:43.790 --> 00:04:45.949
- when you talk about an audience, you're you're

122
00:04:45.949 --> 00:04:46.769
- talking about

123
00:04:47.069 --> 00:04:50.370
- the general public, I assume. So it's not

124
00:04:50.430 --> 00:04:53.164
- how, let's say, how one astrophysicist,

125
00:04:54.904 --> 00:04:56.844
- perceives the credibility of another

126
00:04:57.384 --> 00:04:57.884
- astrophysicist.

127
00:04:58.264 --> 00:04:59.724
- This is the

128
00:05:00.264 --> 00:05:02.104
- perception of a of a person who's a

129
00:05:02.104 --> 00:05:02.925
- non expert

130
00:05:03.250 --> 00:05:05.649
- or or or maybe not? Is it both,

131
00:05:05.970 --> 00:05:09.110
- expert and non expert or just about anybody?

132
00:05:09.810 --> 00:05:11.250
- Yeah. I mean, it's a great question. Right?

133
00:05:11.250 --> 00:05:14.689
- Experts are also people. Right? So so we

134
00:05:14.689 --> 00:05:16.790
- we all interpret other people's credibility,

135
00:05:17.329 --> 00:05:19.754
- credibility at all times. Right? It's it's it's

136
00:05:19.754 --> 00:05:21.274
- how the the world works. It's how we

137
00:05:21.274 --> 00:05:22.894
- make decisions under uncertainty.

138
00:05:24.074 --> 00:05:26.475
- And so so yeah. And and and part

139
00:05:26.475 --> 00:05:28.634
- of what what motivated this research and part

140
00:05:28.634 --> 00:05:30.475
- of what I was fascinated by is that,

141
00:05:30.475 --> 00:05:32.154
- you know, as a scientist, someone who's trained

142
00:05:32.154 --> 00:05:34.020
- as a scientist, right, I am trained to

143
00:05:34.020 --> 00:05:36.500
- signal my credibility very much to other scientists.

144
00:05:36.500 --> 00:05:38.020
- Right? So if I go to a a

145
00:05:38.020 --> 00:05:39.779
- conference, whether it's a a it's a conference

146
00:05:39.779 --> 00:05:42.500
- for physicist or a conference for psychologists or

147
00:05:42.500 --> 00:05:44.819
- a conference for political scientists, right, I stand

148
00:05:44.819 --> 00:05:46.339
- up on the podium, I give my talk,

149
00:05:46.339 --> 00:05:47.774
- and what do I start to signal? I

150
00:05:47.774 --> 00:05:50.095
- start to signal my affiliations, right, the organizations

151
00:05:50.095 --> 00:05:51.475
- that I'm affiliated with,

152
00:05:53.055 --> 00:05:55.555
- the the PhD behind my name,

153
00:05:55.935 --> 00:05:58.035
- right, the the peer reviewed journals,

154
00:05:58.414 --> 00:06:00.175
- articles that I've got. Right? And I might

155
00:06:00.175 --> 00:06:01.889
- do it subtly. Right? I'm not gonna be

156
00:06:01.889 --> 00:06:03.490
- huge hugely bragging about it, but I might

157
00:06:03.490 --> 00:06:05.589
- subtly put it there on my slides. Right?

158
00:06:06.850 --> 00:06:08.850
- The grants I've received. Right? That's how we

159
00:06:08.850 --> 00:06:09.750
- signal credibility

160
00:06:10.689 --> 00:06:12.870
- among and to other scientists. Right?

161
00:06:13.410 --> 00:06:14.769
- But part of the thing I would find

162
00:06:14.769 --> 00:06:16.310
- in my work, especially with

163
00:06:17.965 --> 00:06:20.205
- members of the public or in, many of

164
00:06:20.205 --> 00:06:22.465
- the environmental contexts in which I work,

165
00:06:23.004 --> 00:06:24.305
- those signals of credibility,

166
00:06:24.845 --> 00:06:26.064
- they don't mean anything.

167
00:06:27.085 --> 00:06:28.605
- And so that's what I mean when I

168
00:06:28.605 --> 00:06:30.865
- say I think credibility means different things.

169
00:06:31.220 --> 00:06:33.139
- And so what are the goals behind this

170
00:06:33.139 --> 00:06:34.839
- this work? And, originally, my,

171
00:06:35.779 --> 00:06:37.540
- my original grant that I wrote for this

172
00:06:37.540 --> 00:06:38.519
- for this project

173
00:06:38.899 --> 00:06:40.500
- was to sort of say, okay. If if

174
00:06:40.500 --> 00:06:42.660
- credibility doesn't mean that, right, if it doesn't

175
00:06:42.660 --> 00:06:44.665
- mean PhD behind the name and grants and

176
00:06:44.665 --> 00:06:46.185
- and all this stuff that we do in

177
00:06:46.185 --> 00:06:47.324
- the scientific community,

178
00:06:47.705 --> 00:06:49.485
- what does it mean in these other places?

179
00:06:49.625 --> 00:06:51.384
- Right? And and how do we measure that?

180
00:06:51.384 --> 00:06:53.064
- How do we define that so that we

181
00:06:53.064 --> 00:06:55.064
- can then signal it? Right? Because if we're

182
00:06:55.064 --> 00:06:57.404
- not signaling credibility in those spaces,

183
00:06:57.709 --> 00:06:59.230
- then our ability to take the science from

184
00:06:59.230 --> 00:07:00.990
- the labs that we work in into the

185
00:07:00.990 --> 00:07:03.709
- real world is limited. Right? Because our credibility

186
00:07:03.709 --> 00:07:05.790
- is in question, and then our recommendations are

187
00:07:05.790 --> 00:07:07.470
- not going to be followed. And that means

188
00:07:07.470 --> 00:07:09.810
- people could get sick because they're not adopting,

189
00:07:10.990 --> 00:07:12.529
- the health protective behaviors

190
00:07:13.125 --> 00:07:14.644
- or, you know, they could not they could

191
00:07:14.644 --> 00:07:16.404
- not evacuate when they need to evacuate because

192
00:07:16.404 --> 00:07:18.805
- they don't believe Noah's warnings. Right? And so

193
00:07:18.805 --> 00:07:20.724
- these are the things that that prompted me

194
00:07:20.724 --> 00:07:23.044
- to say credibility might be different things in

195
00:07:23.044 --> 00:07:24.504
- these in these other alternative

196
00:07:25.284 --> 00:07:28.500
- contexts with people who aren't trained as scientists.

197
00:07:28.959 --> 00:07:30.639
- And and what does that what does that

198
00:07:30.639 --> 00:07:32.319
- mean? And how do we how do we

199
00:07:32.319 --> 00:07:33.919
- define it? Right? To get to your very,

200
00:07:33.919 --> 00:07:36.100
- very good question to start us off. Yeah.

201
00:07:37.600 --> 00:07:39.779
- And, Shumaila, can you describe

202
00:07:40.414 --> 00:07:42.814
- the survey that you did? How how did

203
00:07:42.814 --> 00:07:43.794
- you go about,

204
00:07:44.495 --> 00:07:44.995
- measuring

205
00:07:45.535 --> 00:07:47.235
- credibility in your study?

206
00:07:48.095 --> 00:07:48.595
- So,

207
00:07:49.134 --> 00:07:49.634
- well,

208
00:07:49.935 --> 00:07:51.235
- first, we can,

209
00:07:52.414 --> 00:07:53.220
- talk about

210
00:07:53.699 --> 00:07:54.199
- the

211
00:07:55.139 --> 00:07:56.680
- measures which were

212
00:07:57.139 --> 00:07:58.839
- taken from previous samples,

213
00:08:00.500 --> 00:08:03.560
- and studies such as Wesley's work on reassessing,

214
00:08:04.019 --> 00:08:05.720
- perceptions of scientific credibility

215
00:08:06.100 --> 00:08:07.720
- and Colonial Mead's work.

216
00:08:08.654 --> 00:08:11.074
- We also looked at some very,

217
00:08:12.654 --> 00:08:13.154
- key

218
00:08:14.735 --> 00:08:17.134
- studies that have looked at different dimensions of

219
00:08:17.134 --> 00:08:17.634
- credibility.

220
00:08:18.495 --> 00:08:19.774
- Doctor Walls' work,

221
00:08:20.254 --> 00:08:20.754
- with,

222
00:08:21.134 --> 00:08:21.634
- doctor

223
00:08:24.470 --> 00:08:26.870
- Kathleen Hunt was also a key factor in

224
00:08:26.870 --> 00:08:29.509
- this one to understand the researcher's motivation and

225
00:08:29.509 --> 00:08:30.009
- influence.

226
00:08:31.029 --> 00:08:33.589
- As doctor Wall previously has said as well,

227
00:08:34.470 --> 00:08:37.215
- what was important in this study was, like,

228
00:08:37.295 --> 00:08:40.975
- how people perceived or interpreted others' motivation and

229
00:08:40.975 --> 00:08:41.475
- intent.

230
00:08:42.095 --> 00:08:43.934
- By others, I mean, like, the scientist motivation

231
00:08:43.934 --> 00:08:44.815
- and death, not just,

232
00:08:45.615 --> 00:08:46.115
- the

233
00:08:47.535 --> 00:08:49.715
- the the work that the scientists were doing,

234
00:08:50.495 --> 00:08:52.894
- which was a big factor that played in

235
00:08:52.894 --> 00:08:56.199
- this. So we had, like, multiple items. There

236
00:08:56.199 --> 00:08:57.659
- were approximately 30

237
00:08:58.039 --> 00:09:00.459
- or so items across three dimensions

238
00:09:00.839 --> 00:09:01.980
- of, competence,

239
00:09:02.360 --> 00:09:03.500
- integrity, and openness,

240
00:09:03.959 --> 00:09:05.980
- and then, goodwill or benevolence.

241
00:09:06.955 --> 00:09:09.674
- Competence was basically whether they had expertise, they

242
00:09:09.674 --> 00:09:12.315
- were intelligent, they were skilled. Integrity and openness

243
00:09:12.315 --> 00:09:14.095
- was whether they were willing to share information,

244
00:09:14.235 --> 00:09:16.495
- whether they were willing to listen to public.

245
00:09:16.955 --> 00:09:19.355
- And goodwill was why they were doing the

246
00:09:19.355 --> 00:09:21.434
- things that they were doing, who they were

247
00:09:21.434 --> 00:09:22.289
- doing it for,

248
00:09:22.690 --> 00:09:25.009
- was was what was the motivation? Was it

249
00:09:25.009 --> 00:09:25.669
- an external

250
00:09:26.049 --> 00:09:28.929
- extrinsic motivation or external motivation for the sake

251
00:09:28.929 --> 00:09:30.309
- of their society good,

252
00:09:31.169 --> 00:09:31.669
- public,

253
00:09:32.129 --> 00:09:32.629
- good,

254
00:09:33.009 --> 00:09:35.509
- human flourishing, or was it for their own

255
00:09:36.610 --> 00:09:37.110
- intrinsic

256
00:09:38.254 --> 00:09:39.154
- self interest

257
00:09:39.535 --> 00:09:40.035
- values?

258
00:09:40.735 --> 00:09:42.434
- So with regards to sampling,

259
00:09:42.815 --> 00:09:45.855
- we sampled a nationally representative US,

260
00:09:46.335 --> 00:09:48.835
- serve through a US survey acquired through Qualtrics,

261
00:09:49.809 --> 00:09:52.309
- in the winter of one twenty three between,

262
00:09:52.610 --> 00:09:55.169
- and, like, early twenty twenty four. And there

263
00:09:55.169 --> 00:09:58.230
- there were a total of 3,100,

264
00:09:59.809 --> 00:10:00.949
- participants approximately.

265
00:10:02.129 --> 00:10:05.105
- They were all exposed to a short news

266
00:10:05.105 --> 00:10:08.384
- article that we had, drafted using AP News

267
00:10:08.384 --> 00:10:08.884
- sources,

268
00:10:09.345 --> 00:10:09.824
- and,

269
00:10:10.784 --> 00:10:12.804
- they were divided into two different,

270
00:10:13.504 --> 00:10:14.884
- types of news articles.

271
00:10:15.519 --> 00:10:17.600
- One was either on extreme heat. The other

272
00:10:17.600 --> 00:10:19.519
- one was on Samulana, and the reason for

273
00:10:19.519 --> 00:10:21.519
- dividing these two on these two topics was

274
00:10:21.519 --> 00:10:24.179
- because one is a little more politically controversial

275
00:10:24.320 --> 00:10:25.059
- and charged

276
00:10:25.440 --> 00:10:26.899
- than something like food poisoning.

277
00:10:27.839 --> 00:10:28.965
- Also, they were,

278
00:10:29.365 --> 00:10:31.285
- less likely there there's not a lot of,

279
00:10:31.925 --> 00:10:34.485
- what do you call it, vaccinations regarding food

280
00:10:34.485 --> 00:10:34.985
- poisoning

281
00:10:36.485 --> 00:10:38.425
- in The United States or anywhere,

282
00:10:38.884 --> 00:10:41.305
- as we had, consulted with other,

283
00:10:41.684 --> 00:10:44.240
- health professionals as well in the field.

284
00:10:45.179 --> 00:10:47.659
- The other, thing we wanted to do was

285
00:10:47.659 --> 00:10:50.700
- for this specific analysis, we subsampled from those

286
00:10:50.700 --> 00:10:51.919
- 3,000 population,

287
00:10:52.860 --> 00:10:55.580
- the representative sample of 927

288
00:10:55.580 --> 00:10:56.080
- people

289
00:10:57.695 --> 00:11:00.595
- who, focusing those who weren't shown certain experimental

290
00:11:00.735 --> 00:11:02.894
- cues, we had because the this was part

291
00:11:02.894 --> 00:11:04.674
- of a larger experimental study

292
00:11:05.054 --> 00:11:06.195
- that had exposed,

293
00:11:06.815 --> 00:11:10.470
- participants to certain other cues such as uncertainty,

294
00:11:11.089 --> 00:11:15.110
- which was a cue view via, textual hedging,

295
00:11:15.889 --> 00:11:18.129
- which may it meant, like, model words such

296
00:11:18.129 --> 00:11:20.529
- as they maybe maybe there was a heat

297
00:11:20.529 --> 00:11:21.029
- wave.

298
00:11:21.475 --> 00:11:23.735
- Maybe a certain number of people died. Stuff

299
00:11:23.955 --> 00:11:26.215
- like that. And then we also had,

300
00:11:26.995 --> 00:11:27.495
- the

301
00:11:28.434 --> 00:11:28.934
- goodwill,

302
00:11:29.955 --> 00:11:30.455
- messages

303
00:11:30.835 --> 00:11:34.195
- in another ex in another factor factorial experiment

304
00:11:34.195 --> 00:11:37.139
- as well, which was, disclosure of biases

305
00:11:37.519 --> 00:11:40.639
- and then also other oriented motivation, whether the,

306
00:11:40.959 --> 00:11:42.879
- scientists working in the heat table or the

307
00:11:42.879 --> 00:11:43.779
- similar conditions,

308
00:11:44.320 --> 00:11:45.379
- what was the motivation

309
00:11:45.839 --> 00:11:47.539
- regarding that to understand,

310
00:11:48.320 --> 00:11:49.059
- why exactly,

311
00:11:49.754 --> 00:11:51.674
- the scientists were doing the work that they

312
00:11:51.674 --> 00:11:53.674
- were doing in the news articles too so

313
00:11:53.674 --> 00:11:54.955
- that they can read it and and then

314
00:11:54.955 --> 00:11:58.014
- answer all those questions regarding their science beliefs,

315
00:11:58.315 --> 00:12:00.254
- their science perceptions of scientists,

316
00:12:01.035 --> 00:12:03.934
- also the perception of the institution of science

317
00:12:05.040 --> 00:12:05.519
- itself.

318
00:12:05.920 --> 00:12:08.500
- So, yeah, those were the big broad

319
00:12:09.279 --> 00:12:11.059
- chunks or parts of the methodology

320
00:12:11.440 --> 00:12:14.240
- of how we, conducted the experiment, and then

321
00:12:14.240 --> 00:12:15.700
- we used the

322
00:12:16.745 --> 00:12:20.424
- statistical tool to categorize and identify the hidden

323
00:12:20.424 --> 00:12:23.085
- classes based on their credibility perceptions.

324
00:12:25.465 --> 00:12:27.865
- You know, it's it's interesting that when you

325
00:12:27.865 --> 00:12:30.830
- described the, you know, the article about salmonella

326
00:12:31.049 --> 00:12:32.350
- and and food poisoning,

327
00:12:32.970 --> 00:12:34.889
- you you said that it was sort of

328
00:12:34.889 --> 00:12:36.110
- less controversial

329
00:12:36.970 --> 00:12:37.470
- than,

330
00:12:38.649 --> 00:12:40.029
- than climate change.

331
00:12:40.730 --> 00:12:43.210
- You know, sort of ten, fifteen, twenty years

332
00:12:43.210 --> 00:12:43.710
- ago,

333
00:12:44.644 --> 00:12:47.204
- I wouldn't have thought that food poisoning or

334
00:12:47.204 --> 00:12:47.704
- salmonella,

335
00:12:48.084 --> 00:12:49.225
- you know, would be

336
00:12:49.605 --> 00:12:50.345
- a controversial

337
00:12:50.725 --> 00:12:51.225
- topic.

338
00:12:52.164 --> 00:12:53.944
- You know, you would have thought that everybody

339
00:12:54.004 --> 00:12:54.824
- would be against

340
00:12:55.204 --> 00:12:58.184
- food poisoning. But it just seems today that

341
00:12:58.564 --> 00:12:59.704
- everything is

342
00:13:00.299 --> 00:13:00.799
- controversial

343
00:13:01.100 --> 00:13:03.419
- in some way or another. Did did you

344
00:13:03.419 --> 00:13:05.840
- really struggle to to find

345
00:13:06.299 --> 00:13:07.440
- something that

346
00:13:07.980 --> 00:13:09.200
- that you could consider

347
00:13:10.139 --> 00:13:11.120
- less controversial,

348
00:13:12.554 --> 00:13:13.934
- rather than more controversial?

349
00:13:15.115 --> 00:13:15.615
- Yeah.

350
00:13:16.634 --> 00:13:19.774
- My personal expertise is in water resources management.

351
00:13:20.235 --> 00:13:20.735
- So

352
00:13:21.274 --> 00:13:22.875
- a part of me really wants to connect

353
00:13:22.875 --> 00:13:25.774
- with water resources and environmental issues regarding

354
00:13:27.009 --> 00:13:27.750
- water issues.

355
00:13:28.769 --> 00:13:31.190
- But also being an environmental photojournalist,

356
00:13:31.570 --> 00:13:34.470
- I had experience in, like, having to document

357
00:13:34.610 --> 00:13:37.330
- and tell stories regarding these issues from that

358
00:13:37.330 --> 00:13:37.830
- perspective.

359
00:13:38.514 --> 00:13:39.014
- So

360
00:13:39.714 --> 00:13:41.875
- being on the on the ground and having

361
00:13:41.875 --> 00:13:43.495
- that experience of

362
00:13:45.315 --> 00:13:48.695
- communicating from that end of the journalist's perspective,

363
00:13:48.754 --> 00:13:51.174
- it it it was a difficult

364
00:13:52.559 --> 00:13:55.059
- decision to make, but we had consultations

365
00:13:55.440 --> 00:13:55.940
- across,

366
00:13:56.320 --> 00:13:58.720
- with doctor Wald and other postdocs as well

367
00:13:58.720 --> 00:13:59.459
- in the lab.

368
00:13:59.839 --> 00:14:00.339
- And,

369
00:14:02.000 --> 00:14:04.559
- coming to the decision of food poisoning in

370
00:14:04.559 --> 00:14:05.679
- 2023

371
00:14:05.679 --> 00:14:06.179
- was

372
00:14:06.639 --> 00:14:07.139
- awesome.

373
00:14:07.575 --> 00:14:08.795
- In 2026,

374
00:14:10.735 --> 00:14:11.235
- I

375
00:14:13.175 --> 00:14:14.715
- will It feels a little different.

376
00:14:15.095 --> 00:14:16.455
- Yeah. I'll leave it to doctor Wall to

377
00:14:16.455 --> 00:14:18.455
- answer that question. Yeah. No. I mean, it

378
00:14:18.455 --> 00:14:19.975
- feels a little different. I think it's a

379
00:14:19.975 --> 00:14:21.675
- great it's a great question.

380
00:14:22.295 --> 00:14:23.730
- Yeah. I think I I think one of

381
00:14:23.730 --> 00:14:25.970
- the things that's really so in in some

382
00:14:25.970 --> 00:14:27.350
- previous work I did,

383
00:14:27.889 --> 00:14:28.389
- public,

384
00:14:28.850 --> 00:14:31.649
- on public perceptions of both scientists, but scientists

385
00:14:31.649 --> 00:14:33.909
- who do research on genetically modified foods,

386
00:14:34.370 --> 00:14:35.970
- which is, as you may know, like, one

387
00:14:35.970 --> 00:14:37.625
- of the more polarized. Right? Like, when you

388
00:14:37.625 --> 00:14:39.544
- look at the perceptions of the public versus

389
00:14:39.544 --> 00:14:41.384
- perceptions of science on the safety of genetically

390
00:14:41.384 --> 00:14:43.465
- modified foods, it's highly different. I'm very, very

391
00:14:43.465 --> 00:14:43.965
- different.

392
00:14:44.345 --> 00:14:46.184
- A big gap there. And and and so

393
00:14:46.184 --> 00:14:48.424
- what that study found and sort of highlighted

394
00:14:48.424 --> 00:14:50.559
- for me is that when we asked about

395
00:14:50.559 --> 00:14:53.200
- beliefs about genetically modified foods, it was the

396
00:14:53.200 --> 00:14:56.580
- environmental component of beliefs that was highly polarized.

397
00:14:56.720 --> 00:14:57.460
- It wasn't

398
00:14:57.840 --> 00:15:01.120
- perceptions of whether or not, genetically modified foods

399
00:15:01.120 --> 00:15:04.504
- provides a benefit to society from, making food

400
00:15:04.504 --> 00:15:07.004
- more plentiful or or more economic affordable.

401
00:15:07.384 --> 00:15:08.125
- Excuse me.

402
00:15:08.985 --> 00:15:10.665
- It it was the environmental part of that,

403
00:15:10.665 --> 00:15:12.665
- right, saying that genetically modified foods might have

404
00:15:12.665 --> 00:15:13.404
- an environmental,

405
00:15:14.745 --> 00:15:17.459
- harm. And that part was what was politically

406
00:15:17.519 --> 00:15:20.639
- polarized in particular in that particular study. And

407
00:15:20.639 --> 00:15:22.559
- so it it it has always sort of

408
00:15:22.559 --> 00:15:25.279
- resonated for me, this, that study, because it

409
00:15:25.279 --> 00:15:26.639
- it really makes the point to me that

410
00:15:26.639 --> 00:15:28.799
- not all things are polarized, but environmental things

411
00:15:28.799 --> 00:15:29.860
- are highly polarized.

412
00:15:30.955 --> 00:15:32.634
- And particularly in The United States, I don't

413
00:15:32.634 --> 00:15:34.394
- think that's the case everywhere, but particularly in

414
00:15:34.394 --> 00:15:35.995
- The US. And so that's one of the

415
00:15:35.995 --> 00:15:38.394
- reasons why we specifically chose an alternative case

416
00:15:38.394 --> 00:15:39.294
- that was not

417
00:15:39.914 --> 00:15:41.534
- on it on its surface environmental.

418
00:15:41.914 --> 00:15:43.674
- Right? And that's why we went into the

419
00:15:43.674 --> 00:15:45.839
- sort of food safety type. Although, you know,

420
00:15:45.839 --> 00:15:48.339
- as we all probably know, food is connected

421
00:15:48.399 --> 00:15:50.799
- to our environment as well. But we chose

422
00:15:50.799 --> 00:15:52.659
- that case intentionally to try to,

423
00:15:53.679 --> 00:15:55.360
- find something that was less polarized. And in

424
00:15:55.360 --> 00:15:57.220
- 2023, it did feel that way.

425
00:15:57.759 --> 00:15:59.460
- I absolutely agree with that.

426
00:16:00.975 --> 00:16:03.075
- Also, there's there's this policy,

427
00:16:03.615 --> 00:16:04.835
- politics, and information

428
00:16:05.615 --> 00:16:06.115
- aspect

429
00:16:06.415 --> 00:16:08.575
- of this that doctor Wall highlighted that I

430
00:16:08.575 --> 00:16:11.134
- wanted to specifically, like, emphasize as well. I

431
00:16:11.134 --> 00:16:13.934
- feel like when media communicates about certain policy

432
00:16:13.934 --> 00:16:14.674
- and politics,

433
00:16:15.690 --> 00:16:16.589
- certain people

434
00:16:16.970 --> 00:16:19.549
- have or use certain information channels

435
00:16:20.009 --> 00:16:22.110
- that they deeply rely on and trust

436
00:16:22.490 --> 00:16:23.549
- and find credible.

437
00:16:24.250 --> 00:16:26.669
- Those those are also sources that people,

438
00:16:27.690 --> 00:16:30.634
- tend to, you know, fall back on. And

439
00:16:30.634 --> 00:16:33.115
- that also, in the end, like, leads to

440
00:16:33.115 --> 00:16:33.615
- certain,

441
00:16:34.315 --> 00:16:35.695
- I guess, political polarizations

442
00:16:36.794 --> 00:16:37.534
- on those

443
00:16:38.075 --> 00:16:40.634
- on those ideas or policy proposals or how

444
00:16:40.634 --> 00:16:42.254
- to manage certain issues,

445
00:16:44.075 --> 00:16:45.750
- regarding environment, health,

446
00:16:47.590 --> 00:16:48.950
- life in general. So

447
00:16:51.269 --> 00:16:53.929
- And, Shmila, your analysis identified

448
00:16:54.389 --> 00:16:56.730
- five different classes of people

449
00:16:57.190 --> 00:16:58.809
- with respect to their perception

450
00:16:59.350 --> 00:17:01.210
- of the credibility of scientists.

451
00:17:01.955 --> 00:17:02.455
- And,

452
00:17:02.835 --> 00:17:04.294
- these are the enthusiasts,

453
00:17:05.154 --> 00:17:05.974
- the optimists,

454
00:17:06.595 --> 00:17:07.414
- the moderates,

455
00:17:08.115 --> 00:17:08.934
- the skeptics,

456
00:17:09.634 --> 00:17:10.695
- and the estranged.

457
00:17:11.075 --> 00:17:12.835
- So you can I suppose there's a clear

458
00:17:12.835 --> 00:17:13.894
- spectrum there?

459
00:17:14.990 --> 00:17:16.930
- Can you can you give us a definition

460
00:17:17.390 --> 00:17:20.029
- of each of these classes? What what what

461
00:17:20.029 --> 00:17:20.529
- sort

462
00:17:20.910 --> 00:17:23.650
- of views and beliefs do these people have?

463
00:17:24.750 --> 00:17:28.055
- Yeah. This also falls in the line of

464
00:17:28.295 --> 00:17:30.535
- from the, like, the perspective of question that

465
00:17:30.535 --> 00:17:32.615
- you asked regarding, like, where do where where

466
00:17:32.615 --> 00:17:33.835
- would physicists fall?

467
00:17:34.134 --> 00:17:36.714
- I think physicists would fall in enthusiasts,

468
00:17:37.894 --> 00:17:39.914
- because they would be the most scientifically

469
00:17:40.375 --> 00:17:41.515
- engaged population.

470
00:17:42.940 --> 00:17:44.000
- According to our

471
00:17:44.700 --> 00:17:45.200
- survey,

472
00:17:45.980 --> 00:17:49.680
- they rated scientists as very highly competent,

473
00:17:50.220 --> 00:17:51.680
- very honest and caring

474
00:17:51.980 --> 00:17:53.680
- about the public, and they trusted,

475
00:17:54.059 --> 00:17:55.120
- scientific institutions.

476
00:17:56.265 --> 00:17:58.365
- They didn't feel like they were isolated

477
00:17:58.825 --> 00:17:59.884
- from those institutions.

478
00:18:00.664 --> 00:18:02.984
- They had great confidence in them, and they

479
00:18:02.984 --> 00:18:06.205
- also strongly backed science based actions and policies.

480
00:18:07.225 --> 00:18:08.549
- So I think most

481
00:18:09.670 --> 00:18:12.470
- science pro science people would fall into the

482
00:18:12.470 --> 00:18:13.610
- enthusiast category.

483
00:18:14.630 --> 00:18:17.130
- Then we have the optimists who are closely

484
00:18:17.269 --> 00:18:18.410
- behind enthusiasts.

485
00:18:19.029 --> 00:18:21.585
- They're generally very positive, but the support shifts

486
00:18:21.904 --> 00:18:23.125
- depending on the topic.

487
00:18:23.664 --> 00:18:26.164
- And they are generally favorable and,

488
00:18:27.024 --> 00:18:29.345
- but they're more sensitive to how the issue

489
00:18:29.345 --> 00:18:30.005
- is framed.

490
00:18:30.784 --> 00:18:31.284
- And

491
00:18:33.105 --> 00:18:34.804
- then we have the moderates,

492
00:18:36.309 --> 00:18:38.549
- which fall someone in the middle in both

493
00:18:38.549 --> 00:18:40.490
- salmonella and heat wave context.

494
00:18:41.670 --> 00:18:42.970
- They're more on the fence.

495
00:18:43.430 --> 00:18:47.049
- They draw both on personal experts and,

496
00:18:49.085 --> 00:18:51.805
- both on personal sources and expert sources, like

497
00:18:51.805 --> 00:18:55.005
- technical sources such as news, scientists, and political

498
00:18:55.005 --> 00:18:55.505
- sources.

499
00:18:56.525 --> 00:18:58.684
- But they also rely a lot more on

500
00:18:58.684 --> 00:19:00.445
- family and friends when when it comes to,

501
00:19:00.445 --> 00:19:03.670
- like, getting information regarding certain health issues or,

502
00:19:03.670 --> 00:19:06.410
- like, even making decisions regarding environmental,

503
00:19:08.309 --> 00:19:08.809
- policies.

504
00:19:09.750 --> 00:19:11.130
- And their views

505
00:19:11.430 --> 00:19:11.930
- swing

506
00:19:12.470 --> 00:19:14.730
- a little bit depending on the issue

507
00:19:15.029 --> 00:19:16.154
- and the topic.

508
00:19:17.515 --> 00:19:19.914
- Again, that may also align with whether they

509
00:19:19.914 --> 00:19:20.414
- are,

510
00:19:22.234 --> 00:19:23.855
- leaning towards a specific political

511
00:19:28.315 --> 00:19:30.335
- ideology or not. Skeptics,

512
00:19:31.200 --> 00:19:33.059
- vary. They give scientists,

513
00:19:33.679 --> 00:19:36.319
- generally lower marks across the board, and they

514
00:19:36.319 --> 00:19:39.359
- lean more on less on technical sources and

515
00:19:39.359 --> 00:19:40.980
- more on, personal sources,

516
00:19:42.000 --> 00:19:44.579
- and they are more doubtful of scientists' motives.

517
00:19:45.474 --> 00:19:48.115
- And the lastly is the estranged. They are

518
00:19:48.115 --> 00:19:50.214
- the most disconnected of all,

519
00:19:50.755 --> 00:19:52.755
- and they have the lowest trust in scientists

520
00:19:52.755 --> 00:19:53.575
- and institutions.

521
00:19:53.875 --> 00:19:56.034
- They feel there's a general lack of confidence

522
00:19:56.034 --> 00:19:56.934
- in the scientific,

523
00:19:57.474 --> 00:19:58.214
- in the science

524
00:19:58.515 --> 00:19:59.015
- institution,

525
00:19:59.619 --> 00:20:01.700
- and they are least likely to seek out

526
00:20:01.700 --> 00:20:02.919
- scientific information.

527
00:20:04.179 --> 00:20:05.559
- And this is

528
00:20:06.019 --> 00:20:08.039
- this lack of information is

529
00:20:08.819 --> 00:20:10.440
- it may be less about, like,

530
00:20:10.819 --> 00:20:12.200
- the access to information

531
00:20:12.899 --> 00:20:15.255
- that they want to have because they do

532
00:20:15.255 --> 00:20:16.154
- seek information,

533
00:20:18.215 --> 00:20:20.615
- but more about a deeper resistance to science

534
00:20:20.615 --> 00:20:21.115
- itself.

535
00:20:21.734 --> 00:20:24.315
- So one thing that I would also highlight

536
00:20:24.375 --> 00:20:25.035
- is that

537
00:20:25.974 --> 00:20:27.089
- all of these groups,

538
00:20:28.049 --> 00:20:29.589
- they all rated scientists'

539
00:20:30.450 --> 00:20:32.470
- competence highly. They don't

540
00:20:32.769 --> 00:20:34.069
- have a deep

541
00:20:35.490 --> 00:20:38.230
- questioning of whether scientists are skilled or intelligent

542
00:20:38.450 --> 00:20:39.509
- or they have expertise.

543
00:20:40.865 --> 00:20:43.825
- What really distinguished all of these people were

544
00:20:43.825 --> 00:20:47.504
- whether they believe whether scientists had integrity or

545
00:20:47.504 --> 00:20:48.004
- goodwill,

546
00:20:49.264 --> 00:20:50.804
- whether scientists were honest,

547
00:20:51.105 --> 00:20:52.244
- whether they were open,

548
00:20:52.704 --> 00:20:54.565
- whether they were willing to

549
00:20:55.089 --> 00:20:57.029
- have public's interest at heart.

550
00:20:57.409 --> 00:20:59.329
- Basically, why do we do the things that

551
00:20:59.329 --> 00:21:01.589
- we do is what really distinguished

552
00:21:02.129 --> 00:21:02.950
- all of these,

553
00:21:04.049 --> 00:21:05.190
- categories apart.

554
00:21:06.129 --> 00:21:07.829
- And that is where I think

555
00:21:08.369 --> 00:21:09.669
- our work really,

556
00:21:10.684 --> 00:21:11.505
- lies in

557
00:21:12.125 --> 00:21:12.625
- highlighting

558
00:21:13.484 --> 00:21:13.984
- is

559
00:21:14.365 --> 00:21:16.384
- where does the the trust breakdown,

560
00:21:17.005 --> 00:21:17.505
- essentially.

561
00:21:19.964 --> 00:21:21.664
- I see. So so a skeptic

562
00:21:22.204 --> 00:21:23.345
- wouldn't necessarily

563
00:21:23.804 --> 00:21:24.304
- be

564
00:21:24.839 --> 00:21:27.660
- skeptical of the scientific method,

565
00:21:28.519 --> 00:21:29.339
- but rather

566
00:21:29.960 --> 00:21:32.460
- they would be skeptical of the motivation

567
00:21:33.480 --> 00:21:34.619
- Mhmm. Of the scientist?

568
00:21:35.480 --> 00:21:38.839
- Yeah. Even even skeptics were, you know, confident

569
00:21:38.839 --> 00:21:40.059
- that scientists have

570
00:21:40.734 --> 00:21:42.355
- expertise, that they have knowledge,

571
00:21:43.054 --> 00:21:45.375
- right? And so really what she was saying

572
00:21:45.375 --> 00:21:47.615
- is that the the real difference there came

573
00:21:47.615 --> 00:21:49.714
- in came in the other measures, the non

574
00:21:49.774 --> 00:21:53.054
- competence measures, right, the measures of integrity and

575
00:21:53.054 --> 00:21:54.115
- the measures of goodwill.

576
00:21:55.180 --> 00:21:56.880
- So so the the the people

577
00:21:57.180 --> 00:22:00.160
- aspects of it, I suppose, is is

578
00:22:00.539 --> 00:22:02.380
- maybe a good way to think of it.

579
00:22:02.380 --> 00:22:02.880
- Yeah.

580
00:22:03.180 --> 00:22:05.180
- That that that is really interesting. Well, I'm

581
00:22:05.259 --> 00:22:06.940
- you know, I suppose it makes sense because

582
00:22:06.940 --> 00:22:07.755
- after all,

583
00:22:08.075 --> 00:22:09.755
- we're all people, aren't we?

584
00:22:10.634 --> 00:22:13.914
- And we're we're subject to to prejudices and,

585
00:22:17.674 --> 00:22:19.535
- I suppose, questioning people's motives.

586
00:22:20.869 --> 00:22:22.069
- I mean, is is there a

587
00:22:23.109 --> 00:22:24.390
- did did you get a perception,

588
00:22:26.149 --> 00:22:26.649
- that

589
00:22:27.829 --> 00:22:28.329
- people

590
00:22:29.109 --> 00:22:32.470
- so non scientists. Do they do they see

591
00:22:32.470 --> 00:22:33.690
- scientists as

592
00:22:34.105 --> 00:22:35.164
- sort of fundamentally

593
00:22:35.464 --> 00:22:35.964
- different

594
00:22:36.904 --> 00:22:37.644
- to themselves,

595
00:22:38.105 --> 00:22:38.605
- or

596
00:22:39.384 --> 00:22:41.244
- do they do they see

597
00:22:41.625 --> 00:22:42.605
- scientists as,

598
00:22:43.784 --> 00:22:46.265
- I suppose, normal people who just happen to

599
00:22:46.265 --> 00:22:46.765
- be

600
00:22:47.304 --> 00:22:47.804
- scientists?

601
00:22:50.220 --> 00:22:53.100
- Based on personal conversations or based on the

602
00:22:53.100 --> 00:22:53.600
- survey?

603
00:22:54.539 --> 00:22:56.539
- Well, I I mean, just in general, I

604
00:22:56.539 --> 00:22:58.539
- suppose. I I mean, maybe that's not something

605
00:22:58.539 --> 00:23:00.480
- that you investigated in the survey.

606
00:23:00.955 --> 00:23:02.955
- Yeah. This wasn't something that we investigated in

607
00:23:02.955 --> 00:23:05.195
- the survey whether they saw they saw a

608
00:23:05.195 --> 00:23:06.095
- scientist as

609
00:23:08.075 --> 00:23:08.894
- an outsider.

610
00:23:09.674 --> 00:23:12.075
- But there are there are national studies, right,

611
00:23:12.075 --> 00:23:12.735
- that suggest

612
00:23:14.820 --> 00:23:17.880
- that scientists don't interact very often with nonscientists.

613
00:23:18.580 --> 00:23:20.339
- Right? That there's a big there's a big

614
00:23:20.339 --> 00:23:22.900
- social divide. Right? And and Mhmm. As we

615
00:23:22.900 --> 00:23:25.320
- sort ourselves more and more into different communities,

616
00:23:26.259 --> 00:23:28.605
- that interaction is even less likely to happen.

617
00:23:29.644 --> 00:23:31.724
- So, I think there are some studies that

618
00:23:31.724 --> 00:23:33.644
- suggest that as yeah. We did not measure

619
00:23:33.644 --> 00:23:35.404
- that specific question, but it's a it's a

620
00:23:35.404 --> 00:23:36.304
- really good one.

621
00:23:36.605 --> 00:23:37.105
- Yeah.

622
00:23:38.444 --> 00:23:39.984
- And they do look at how,

623
00:23:40.605 --> 00:23:41.105
- different

624
00:23:41.484 --> 00:23:43.930
- those studies have looked at, like, how one

625
00:23:43.930 --> 00:23:46.009
- scientist have been communicated in the media and

626
00:23:46.009 --> 00:23:48.590
- how that plays a role in people's perception

627
00:23:48.650 --> 00:23:50.670
- or forming a people's perception of scientist.

628
00:23:51.289 --> 00:23:53.769
- But that's the thing. Like, science is to

629
00:23:53.930 --> 00:23:56.090
- science isn't just a natural phenomena. We as

630
00:23:56.090 --> 00:23:57.549
- human beings are also natural

631
00:23:58.090 --> 00:23:58.590
- beings,

632
00:23:59.595 --> 00:24:00.974
- part of the natural phenomena.

633
00:24:01.434 --> 00:24:03.134
- And when we separate the two,

634
00:24:03.434 --> 00:24:04.815
- like, social and natural

635
00:24:05.195 --> 00:24:06.095
- as being

636
00:24:06.875 --> 00:24:07.375
- different

637
00:24:07.835 --> 00:24:09.695
- and not part of the same

638
00:24:10.474 --> 00:24:10.974
- piece,

639
00:24:12.110 --> 00:24:14.450
- it can become harder for us to connect

640
00:24:14.590 --> 00:24:16.110
- with each other. And that is why there's

641
00:24:16.110 --> 00:24:18.289
- a greater push towards, like, public facing,

642
00:24:19.630 --> 00:24:22.370
- education and processes and projects

643
00:24:22.830 --> 00:24:24.974
- for scientists to engage in as well

644
00:24:25.454 --> 00:24:28.174
- to have a greater connection with the communities

645
00:24:28.174 --> 00:24:29.075
- that they're actually

646
00:24:29.615 --> 00:24:31.634
- looking forward to serving and working with.

647
00:24:32.575 --> 00:24:35.375
- So, Dara, we talked a bit about what

648
00:24:35.375 --> 00:24:36.434
- could be behind

649
00:24:36.815 --> 00:24:38.755
- this wide spectrum of views.

650
00:24:39.529 --> 00:24:41.150
- Is it related to education,

651
00:24:42.169 --> 00:24:44.669
- income, political outlook, or

652
00:24:45.929 --> 00:24:47.349
- something else? Yeah.

653
00:24:48.169 --> 00:24:49.769
- We don't have an easy answer to this

654
00:24:49.769 --> 00:24:50.829
- yet. Right? So,

655
00:24:51.849 --> 00:24:53.529
- I think that was one of the the

656
00:24:53.529 --> 00:24:53.924
- hopes,

657
00:24:54.565 --> 00:24:55.605
- one of the things we were hoping to

658
00:24:55.605 --> 00:24:57.205
- dig into a little bit more. I I

659
00:24:57.205 --> 00:24:59.705
- can say that there were no consistent differences

660
00:25:00.005 --> 00:25:01.705
- between these groups in education,

661
00:25:02.644 --> 00:25:04.664
- income, age, or gender.

662
00:25:05.605 --> 00:25:08.005
- We did find significant differences between the groups

663
00:25:08.005 --> 00:25:10.250
- in terms of their prior beliefs about science

664
00:25:10.250 --> 00:25:10.990
- and technology.

665
00:25:12.009 --> 00:25:14.349
- We found differences in their support for environmental

666
00:25:14.409 --> 00:25:15.789
- and health protective behaviors.

667
00:25:16.490 --> 00:25:17.210
- And as,

668
00:25:17.690 --> 00:25:20.329
- Shwaila alluded to, their reliance on technical sources

669
00:25:20.329 --> 00:25:22.029
- of information was a big difference,

670
00:25:22.730 --> 00:25:24.944
- their levels of social trust, generally,

671
00:25:26.065 --> 00:25:28.565
- their confidence in scientific and other institutions,

672
00:25:29.585 --> 00:25:32.085
- and finally, their political affiliation and ideology,

673
00:25:32.784 --> 00:25:34.224
- as well as the region of The United

674
00:25:34.224 --> 00:25:36.544
- States they were located in in. So in

675
00:25:36.544 --> 00:25:37.524
- terms of the sociodemographic

676
00:25:38.224 --> 00:25:38.724
- variables

677
00:25:39.259 --> 00:25:41.500
- that that might, shed light on why these

678
00:25:41.500 --> 00:25:44.720
- differences exist, I would say political affiliation, ideology,

679
00:25:44.779 --> 00:25:45.599
- and region,

680
00:25:46.059 --> 00:25:47.659
- were the two that that had the most

681
00:25:47.659 --> 00:25:48.159
- consistent,

682
00:25:48.779 --> 00:25:49.279
- patterns.

683
00:25:50.059 --> 00:25:51.500
- And I think that sort of aligns with

684
00:25:51.500 --> 00:25:54.045
- what other people have found is that, you

685
00:25:54.045 --> 00:25:55.565
- know, I think there's a tendency to say,

686
00:25:55.565 --> 00:25:57.244
- oh, well, you know, people just don't know,

687
00:25:57.244 --> 00:25:59.085
- right, or it's a lack of education. But

688
00:25:59.085 --> 00:26:00.924
- a lot of studies have found consistently time

689
00:26:00.924 --> 00:26:02.785
- and time again that it's not about education,

690
00:26:03.085 --> 00:26:05.484
- that people who are highly numerate, right, highly

691
00:26:05.484 --> 00:26:07.984
- educated can do a a really good,

692
00:26:08.480 --> 00:26:10.880
- solve, you know, solve logic puzzles, and all

693
00:26:10.880 --> 00:26:11.539
- this stuff,

694
00:26:13.519 --> 00:26:14.180
- are actually

695
00:26:14.720 --> 00:26:16.980
- better at finding information that,

696
00:26:17.840 --> 00:26:21.840
- reinforces their beliefs, right, positively or negatively about

697
00:26:21.840 --> 00:26:23.460
- science or about data.

698
00:26:24.535 --> 00:26:26.315
- And so education or numeracy,

699
00:26:27.335 --> 00:26:30.375
- isn't isn't isn't always associated directly in the

700
00:26:30.375 --> 00:26:31.674
- way that we might think.

701
00:26:32.215 --> 00:26:33.974
- And that seems to to align with what

702
00:26:33.974 --> 00:26:35.115
- we found as well.

703
00:26:36.529 --> 00:26:38.690
- So so based on your research, Dara, how

704
00:26:38.690 --> 00:26:39.669
- would you advise

705
00:26:39.970 --> 00:26:40.470
- scientists

706
00:26:41.009 --> 00:26:43.909
- on how to best communicate to the public

707
00:26:43.970 --> 00:26:47.109
- about their research? Should they tailor messages

708
00:26:47.809 --> 00:26:48.309
- for

709
00:26:48.609 --> 00:26:51.409
- specific groups when appropriate, or should they try

710
00:26:51.409 --> 00:26:53.794
- to come up with a a universal message

711
00:26:53.855 --> 00:26:55.234
- that will appeal to

712
00:26:55.615 --> 00:26:57.154
- everyone from an enthusiast

713
00:26:57.855 --> 00:26:59.774
- to an estranged person? What,

714
00:27:00.335 --> 00:27:01.474
- what would you recommend?

715
00:27:02.575 --> 00:27:05.099
- Oh, the great the the great unicorn message

716
00:27:05.179 --> 00:27:06.160
- question. Right? So

717
00:27:06.619 --> 00:27:07.900
- I I what years ago and I don't

718
00:27:07.900 --> 00:27:09.179
- remember his name off the top of my

719
00:27:09.179 --> 00:27:09.679
- head,

720
00:27:09.980 --> 00:27:11.980
- I heard a a really good scholar who

721
00:27:11.980 --> 00:27:12.619
- works on,

722
00:27:13.740 --> 00:27:16.460
- vaccine hesitancy and public perceptions vaccine say there

723
00:27:16.460 --> 00:27:18.000
- is no unicorn message.

724
00:27:18.404 --> 00:27:20.005
- Right? And and I that has really stuck

725
00:27:20.005 --> 00:27:21.684
- with me. So I I think one thing

726
00:27:21.684 --> 00:27:24.664
- to remember is that communication is really hard.

727
00:27:25.125 --> 00:27:26.965
- And I think it's really important to think

728
00:27:26.965 --> 00:27:29.605
- deeply about how we do it, and who

729
00:27:29.605 --> 00:27:32.424
- our our target audience is before we're communicating.

730
00:27:33.750 --> 00:27:36.070
- And and, yes, I I strongly believe that

731
00:27:36.070 --> 00:27:38.630
- language and framing are very important. They have

732
00:27:38.630 --> 00:27:40.890
- effects, not always in the way we expect,

733
00:27:41.509 --> 00:27:43.930
- but but that understanding that is really important.

734
00:27:44.869 --> 00:27:46.390
- There are a lot of good there's a

735
00:27:46.390 --> 00:27:48.170
- lot of good, work out there,

736
00:27:49.304 --> 00:27:51.544
- very accessible work out there from social scientists

737
00:27:51.544 --> 00:27:53.704
- and others about how to craft a really

738
00:27:53.704 --> 00:27:55.964
- short, compelling, public facing message,

739
00:27:56.585 --> 00:27:58.505
- on on a variety of topics. And while

740
00:27:58.505 --> 00:28:00.524
- I think this work is really, really important,

741
00:28:00.585 --> 00:28:02.424
- I think what our study is saying is

742
00:28:02.424 --> 00:28:03.325
- that in addition

743
00:28:04.099 --> 00:28:05.960
- to crafting a good message,

744
00:28:06.340 --> 00:28:08.180
- scientists also need to think about how to

745
00:28:08.180 --> 00:28:10.200
- reach audiences who might be skeptical

746
00:28:10.820 --> 00:28:14.259
- about them from the beginning. Right? And and

747
00:28:14.259 --> 00:28:15.720
- to do that, right,

748
00:28:16.019 --> 00:28:17.799
- I think we need to remember that skepticism

749
00:28:18.765 --> 00:28:21.025
- is shaped by concerns about

750
00:28:21.805 --> 00:28:22.705
- what scientists

751
00:28:23.404 --> 00:28:25.724
- intend to do, what benefit they're bringing. Right?

752
00:28:25.724 --> 00:28:27.744
- Not their ability, not their expertise.

753
00:28:28.205 --> 00:28:28.705
- Right?

754
00:28:29.164 --> 00:28:30.065
- But really,

755
00:28:30.605 --> 00:28:32.125
- why do you do the work that you

756
00:28:32.125 --> 00:28:35.240
- do? Right? Who who benefits from it?

757
00:28:35.859 --> 00:28:37.779
- And so I would encourage scientists, in addition

758
00:28:37.779 --> 00:28:39.559
- to thinking about the messaging itself,

759
00:28:39.940 --> 00:28:41.779
- to to think about the signals we might

760
00:28:41.779 --> 00:28:43.720
- be sending about our credibility

761
00:28:44.420 --> 00:28:44.920
- unintentionally.

762
00:28:45.859 --> 00:28:47.444
- Right? And those are things like our character

763
00:28:49.284 --> 00:28:51.044
- intent. And and to be honest, I think

764
00:28:51.044 --> 00:28:52.244
- those are things that many of us as

765
00:28:52.244 --> 00:28:52.744
- scientists

766
00:28:53.524 --> 00:28:55.125
- think, you know, oh, well, we shouldn't have

767
00:28:55.125 --> 00:28:56.964
- to talk about that. Right? Because of course

768
00:28:56.964 --> 00:28:58.804
- what we do matters. And of course of

769
00:28:58.804 --> 00:29:00.769
- course we're good people. Right? And and I

770
00:29:00.769 --> 00:29:02.049
- agree we are you know, there are so

771
00:29:02.049 --> 00:29:04.609
- many scientists out there who are working so

772
00:29:04.609 --> 00:29:05.990
- hard and and

773
00:29:06.529 --> 00:29:09.329
- doing such amazing work, and and just as

774
00:29:09.329 --> 00:29:11.730
- there are people in other places working hard

775
00:29:11.730 --> 00:29:14.115
- and doing amazing work. And I think

776
00:29:14.974 --> 00:29:16.595
- I think it's important to

777
00:29:17.214 --> 00:29:19.315
- remember that in situations where scientists

778
00:29:20.095 --> 00:29:21.794
- aren't sort of standing at a podium,

779
00:29:23.454 --> 00:29:25.615
- they're they're out there communicating with the public

780
00:29:25.615 --> 00:29:26.815
- in in sort of more of a two

781
00:29:26.815 --> 00:29:27.954
- way model of communication.

782
00:29:28.900 --> 00:29:30.740
- They're working with a farmer to implement a

783
00:29:30.740 --> 00:29:32.660
- new on farm practice, so they're working with

784
00:29:32.660 --> 00:29:34.339
- a community group that wants to manage an

785
00:29:34.339 --> 00:29:35.319
- invasive species.

786
00:29:35.779 --> 00:29:37.160
- In those contexts,

787
00:29:37.700 --> 00:29:39.059
- both in this work and in the other

788
00:29:39.059 --> 00:29:40.119
- work that I've done,

789
00:29:40.500 --> 00:29:43.195
- integrity means are you showing up when you

790
00:29:43.195 --> 00:29:44.955
- said you would show up? Right? Do you

791
00:29:44.955 --> 00:29:46.815
- keep coming back and sharing information

792
00:29:47.434 --> 00:29:48.414
- as it's emerging?

793
00:29:48.795 --> 00:29:50.875
- Are you honest about what your study can

794
00:29:50.875 --> 00:29:51.535
- or cannot

795
00:29:52.075 --> 00:29:53.615
- say? Right? Are you,

796
00:29:54.394 --> 00:29:57.819
- are you working to to continue doing this

797
00:29:57.819 --> 00:30:00.779
- work for in perpetuity for a really, really

798
00:30:00.779 --> 00:30:02.299
- long time, or does your project end a

799
00:30:02.299 --> 00:30:04.940
- year from now? And if it does, what's

800
00:30:04.940 --> 00:30:06.640
- left when you leave? Right?

801
00:30:07.099 --> 00:30:09.099
- Will this work or your research make things

802
00:30:09.099 --> 00:30:10.640
- better for your participants?

803
00:30:12.284 --> 00:30:13.265
- Is the outcome

804
00:30:13.964 --> 00:30:14.464
- information?

805
00:30:15.404 --> 00:30:16.464
- Is it beneficial?

806
00:30:16.924 --> 00:30:17.825
- Is it extractive?

807
00:30:18.284 --> 00:30:18.765
- Right?

808
00:30:19.164 --> 00:30:20.924
- So so I think that those are the

809
00:30:20.924 --> 00:30:22.544
- questions that I I think scientists,

810
00:30:24.125 --> 00:30:26.339
- really in those in those more place based

811
00:30:26.579 --> 00:30:28.579
- context when you're going out and you're having

812
00:30:28.579 --> 00:30:29.720
- a a two way,

813
00:30:30.579 --> 00:30:31.079
- interaction

814
00:30:31.539 --> 00:30:32.039
- with,

815
00:30:32.419 --> 00:30:35.000
- an audience, whether it's someone who has expertise

816
00:30:35.059 --> 00:30:36.119
- or or not,

817
00:30:36.659 --> 00:30:38.419
- about what you're talking about. That's where I

818
00:30:38.419 --> 00:30:39.400
- think we really

819
00:30:39.955 --> 00:30:42.434
- haven't yet figured out how to how to

820
00:30:42.434 --> 00:30:43.575
- signal our credibility.

821
00:30:44.195 --> 00:30:46.515
- The the the the, again, the normal the

822
00:30:46.515 --> 00:30:49.494
- the forms that we use at conferences scientific

823
00:30:49.555 --> 00:30:50.934
- conferences are not enough.

824
00:30:51.955 --> 00:30:52.695
- And so

825
00:30:53.000 --> 00:30:54.680
- I think we need to think about whether

826
00:30:54.680 --> 00:30:56.779
- and how we're aligning our our words,

827
00:30:58.039 --> 00:31:00.119
- with our actions when we share science in

828
00:31:00.119 --> 00:31:00.619
- public

829
00:31:01.000 --> 00:31:03.900
- and and how more broadly we are demonstrating,

830
00:31:04.200 --> 00:31:06.279
- whether you're a bench scientist or a scientist

831
00:31:06.279 --> 00:31:07.580
- who's out in the fields,

832
00:31:08.234 --> 00:31:09.994
- how are you demonstrating that our science is

833
00:31:09.994 --> 00:31:11.134
- benefiting society,

834
00:31:11.755 --> 00:31:13.835
- the public, or the places in which we

835
00:31:13.835 --> 00:31:15.595
- work? Right? And and and that's where I

836
00:31:15.595 --> 00:31:16.095
- think

837
00:31:16.714 --> 00:31:19.035
- we focus so much on these messages. Right?

838
00:31:19.035 --> 00:31:20.490
- But I also think it's about

839
00:31:21.049 --> 00:31:23.390
- these underlying deeper parts of communication

840
00:31:24.089 --> 00:31:24.829
- that sometimes

841
00:31:25.210 --> 00:31:26.990
- get forgotten or really that scientists,

842
00:31:27.289 --> 00:31:29.049
- to to their credit, like, we we study

843
00:31:29.210 --> 00:31:31.210
- when we are trained, we there's so much

844
00:31:31.210 --> 00:31:33.529
- to learn. Right? And and this is stuff

845
00:31:33.529 --> 00:31:34.509
- that we don't really

846
00:31:34.890 --> 00:31:37.545
- focus on for a variety of reasons. Right?

847
00:31:38.184 --> 00:31:38.924
- And so

848
00:31:39.625 --> 00:31:40.825
- I think that but I think that they're

849
00:31:40.825 --> 00:31:42.825
- really important, and I and that's one of

850
00:31:42.825 --> 00:31:44.744
- the reasons why this this project was really

851
00:31:44.744 --> 00:31:45.724
- exciting for me,

852
00:31:46.184 --> 00:31:47.865
- to engage with is because I I I've

853
00:31:47.865 --> 00:31:49.545
- wanted for a long time just to be

854
00:31:49.545 --> 00:31:51.659
- able to articulate some of the patterns that

855
00:31:51.659 --> 00:31:52.859
- I was seeing in the work that I

856
00:31:52.859 --> 00:31:54.720
- do, which is much more two way communication

857
00:31:54.859 --> 00:31:55.359
- focused.

858
00:31:56.460 --> 00:31:58.059
- And so and and bring that to other

859
00:31:58.059 --> 00:32:00.299
- scientists who might be be struggling with that.

860
00:32:00.299 --> 00:32:01.819
- Well, when the rubber meets the road and

861
00:32:01.819 --> 00:32:03.740
- I go to communicate my public my science,

862
00:32:03.740 --> 00:32:05.259
- it doesn't always work the way I want

863
00:32:05.259 --> 00:32:07.075
- it to, or I get skepticism, or I

864
00:32:07.075 --> 00:32:07.815
- feel frustrated

865
00:32:08.515 --> 00:32:11.394
- about, how my science is being interpreted. And

866
00:32:11.394 --> 00:32:11.894
- so,

867
00:32:12.434 --> 00:32:13.875
- yeah. So I think I think that that

868
00:32:13.875 --> 00:32:15.575
- deeper stuff is really important.

869
00:32:17.075 --> 00:32:19.174
- I mean, in terms of communicating

870
00:32:19.554 --> 00:32:20.054
- credibility,

871
00:32:21.250 --> 00:32:22.849
- I can see that, you know, the the

872
00:32:22.849 --> 00:32:24.289
- the there could be a bit of a

873
00:32:24.289 --> 00:32:25.349
- trap here because

874
00:32:26.130 --> 00:32:28.630
- if scientists spend a lot of time

875
00:32:29.009 --> 00:32:29.910
- talking about

876
00:32:30.289 --> 00:32:31.269
- their own credibility,

877
00:32:32.210 --> 00:32:34.230
- that sort of implies that maybe

878
00:32:34.529 --> 00:32:35.670
- not all scientists

879
00:32:36.565 --> 00:32:37.305
- are credible.

880
00:32:38.644 --> 00:32:40.184
- Is there I mean,

881
00:32:40.725 --> 00:32:41.545
- how would you,

882
00:32:42.805 --> 00:32:44.265
- Shumaila, how would you,

883
00:32:45.605 --> 00:32:48.664
- sort of coach a scientist on on bridging

884
00:32:48.725 --> 00:32:51.384
- the the the concept of of credibility

885
00:32:52.220 --> 00:32:52.720
- without,

886
00:32:53.259 --> 00:32:55.519
- you know, sort of casting doubt on

887
00:32:55.980 --> 00:32:56.880
- on the profession.

888
00:32:58.299 --> 00:33:00.000
- You know, it's a bit like a banker,

889
00:33:00.140 --> 00:33:01.920
- you know, somebody who who,

890
00:33:03.019 --> 00:33:04.859
- you know, I suppose works for a bank

891
00:33:04.859 --> 00:33:06.480
- saying, well, you know, we're

892
00:33:06.944 --> 00:33:07.924
- trustworthy. But,

893
00:33:08.865 --> 00:33:11.664
- implying that maybe other bankers aren't trustworthy, I

894
00:33:11.664 --> 00:33:13.664
- don't know. It's just it's just something that's

895
00:33:13.664 --> 00:33:15.424
- popped into my head when I was when

896
00:33:15.424 --> 00:33:16.884
- I was reading your paper.

897
00:33:17.505 --> 00:33:18.244
- That is,

898
00:33:18.784 --> 00:33:20.005
- that is a fair concern.

899
00:33:20.464 --> 00:33:20.964
- And

900
00:33:22.820 --> 00:33:24.980
- one of the reasons I think that concern

901
00:33:24.980 --> 00:33:28.039
- emerges is because of the misunderstanding of what

902
00:33:28.100 --> 00:33:30.740
- credibility is. And I think doctor Wald,

903
00:33:31.299 --> 00:33:31.799
- explained,

904
00:33:32.980 --> 00:33:33.480
- like,

905
00:33:34.180 --> 00:33:35.720
- a lot of that by

906
00:33:36.234 --> 00:33:39.434
- describing that credibility isn't, like, the property of

907
00:33:39.434 --> 00:33:39.934
- the

908
00:33:40.634 --> 00:33:43.054
- of the source. It's of the receiver's

909
00:33:43.674 --> 00:33:44.174
- interpretation

910
00:33:44.714 --> 00:33:45.534
- of the source.

911
00:33:46.474 --> 00:33:47.294
- For example,

912
00:33:48.710 --> 00:33:51.369
- it's credibility isn't like something that

913
00:33:51.829 --> 00:33:54.730
- the the the scientist owns. It's not like

914
00:33:54.789 --> 00:33:54.950
- our

915
00:33:55.670 --> 00:33:57.750
- it's not it's not a diploma on the

916
00:33:57.750 --> 00:33:58.730
- wall. It's not

917
00:33:59.190 --> 00:34:01.450
- it's not my poster presentation.

918
00:34:02.565 --> 00:34:04.265
- It's not my manuscript publications.

919
00:34:05.525 --> 00:34:08.184
- It's it's something that the public gives them

920
00:34:08.644 --> 00:34:10.824
- based on how they perceive their

921
00:34:11.364 --> 00:34:14.405
- different properties, and that includes their expertise, which

922
00:34:14.405 --> 00:34:15.304
- is their competence,

923
00:34:16.000 --> 00:34:18.880
- their character traits, which includes their integrity, their

924
00:34:18.880 --> 00:34:19.380
- openness,

925
00:34:19.920 --> 00:34:23.119
- and their goodwill, whether they have their best

926
00:34:23.119 --> 00:34:24.340
- interest at heart.

927
00:34:24.720 --> 00:34:25.220
- So

928
00:34:25.599 --> 00:34:26.420
- when scientists

929
00:34:26.800 --> 00:34:29.234
- are when we talk about, like, scientists working

930
00:34:29.234 --> 00:34:31.474
- to communicate the credibility, it doesn't mean that

931
00:34:31.474 --> 00:34:32.855
- they don't have it.

932
00:34:33.554 --> 00:34:34.034
- It just

933
00:34:35.394 --> 00:34:38.135
- or it also doesn't mean, like, you know,

934
00:34:38.994 --> 00:34:41.609
- that they're admitting that there's a lack of

935
00:34:41.670 --> 00:34:42.889
- that said credibility.

936
00:34:43.190 --> 00:34:45.449
- It just means what aspect of that

937
00:34:46.309 --> 00:34:47.929
- of that part of yourself

938
00:34:48.630 --> 00:34:50.710
- as a scientist or that personhood as a

939
00:34:50.710 --> 00:34:52.889
- scientist are you planning on communicating

940
00:34:53.190 --> 00:34:53.849
- to highlight?

941
00:34:54.324 --> 00:34:55.545
- Because there are certain

942
00:34:56.085 --> 00:34:57.545
- people who are not perceived

943
00:34:57.844 --> 00:34:58.585
- as scientists.

944
00:35:00.644 --> 00:35:00.804
- Yeah.

945
00:35:01.525 --> 00:35:03.525
- I mean, I suppose, you know, a scientist

946
00:35:03.525 --> 00:35:05.844
- would look at credibility in terms of, you

947
00:35:05.844 --> 00:35:06.824
- know, their publication

948
00:35:07.125 --> 00:35:09.250
- list. You know, in physics, it would be,

949
00:35:09.250 --> 00:35:10.849
- well, look, you know, I've got these papers

950
00:35:10.849 --> 00:35:11.349
- in

951
00:35:11.730 --> 00:35:15.170
- nature and science and physical review letters. And

952
00:35:15.170 --> 00:35:16.469
- so that makes me

953
00:35:16.769 --> 00:35:17.589
- more credible

954
00:35:18.369 --> 00:35:22.049
- than another physicist who maybe hasn't published in

955
00:35:22.049 --> 00:35:22.514
- such

956
00:35:22.914 --> 00:35:25.414
- prestigious journals. But, of course, yeah, that

957
00:35:26.355 --> 00:35:30.194
- Yeah. Those impact factors, those journals, they don't

958
00:35:30.194 --> 00:35:32.594
- mean anything to the public because to them,

959
00:35:32.594 --> 00:35:34.375
- it's like, what have you done for me?

960
00:35:35.154 --> 00:35:36.214
- What have you done

961
00:35:36.755 --> 00:35:39.170
- for the good of society

962
00:35:39.949 --> 00:35:42.269
- in general if that is one of the

963
00:35:42.269 --> 00:35:44.429
- biggest concern of the public right now? And

964
00:35:44.429 --> 00:35:46.510
- that is what the study found was that

965
00:35:46.510 --> 00:35:48.909
- even the skeptics and estranged who are not

966
00:35:48.909 --> 00:35:50.929
- that connected to science and scientists,

967
00:35:51.635 --> 00:35:53.875
- their main concern was, like, why are you

968
00:35:53.875 --> 00:35:54.614
- doing this

969
00:35:54.914 --> 00:35:56.934
- work that you're doing? So tell me

970
00:35:57.394 --> 00:35:59.554
- don't show me just your diplomas, which is,

971
00:35:59.554 --> 00:36:01.815
- like, this is great, awesome work, but, like,

972
00:36:01.875 --> 00:36:03.815
- why are you doing what you're doing?

973
00:36:04.594 --> 00:36:05.094
- And

974
00:36:06.275 --> 00:36:06.599
- it's

975
00:36:07.960 --> 00:36:10.280
- so communicating credibility is about, like, closing that

976
00:36:10.280 --> 00:36:12.599
- gap about, like, helping people see what science

977
00:36:12.599 --> 00:36:14.059
- actually is as a process.

978
00:36:15.400 --> 00:36:17.480
- In in terms of why, you know, why

979
00:36:17.480 --> 00:36:19.260
- does what why does a scientist

980
00:36:19.559 --> 00:36:20.300
- do something?

981
00:36:21.534 --> 00:36:23.534
- Would it be okay for a scientist to

982
00:36:23.534 --> 00:36:26.755
- say, well, you know, it it's my job.

983
00:36:27.534 --> 00:36:29.934
- I need a job. I like doing it.

984
00:36:30.255 --> 00:36:32.114
- I get paid a modest salary.

985
00:36:32.574 --> 00:36:34.469
- I like the people that I work with.

986
00:36:35.829 --> 00:36:36.730
- It's a job.

987
00:36:37.109 --> 00:36:38.869
- Yeah. I mean, is that enough? Or do

988
00:36:38.949 --> 00:36:40.949
- you know, do it it almost sounds like

989
00:36:40.949 --> 00:36:41.449
- scientists

990
00:36:42.309 --> 00:36:43.050
- have to do

991
00:36:43.750 --> 00:36:44.489
- much more

992
00:36:45.269 --> 00:36:46.809
- to justify their existence

993
00:36:47.414 --> 00:36:47.914
- than,

994
00:36:48.535 --> 00:36:50.295
- I don't know, the, you know, a person

995
00:36:50.295 --> 00:36:53.735
- who who looks after elderly people or,

996
00:36:54.375 --> 00:36:54.875
- fixes

997
00:36:55.255 --> 00:36:56.715
- potholes in the road.

998
00:36:57.735 --> 00:36:59.894
- Do, you know, is is do do they

999
00:36:59.894 --> 00:37:01.434
- have to go the extra mile?

1000
00:37:01.780 --> 00:37:02.840
- Or is just saying,

1001
00:37:03.700 --> 00:37:05.300
- I want to do a good job and

1002
00:37:05.460 --> 00:37:07.860
- I think in any any job interview, they

1003
00:37:07.860 --> 00:37:09.619
- are going to ask why do you want

1004
00:37:09.619 --> 00:37:11.700
- the job. And if somebody's like, I just

1005
00:37:11.700 --> 00:37:13.700
- want a job, I I don't think that

1006
00:37:13.700 --> 00:37:16.394
- job interview is gonna go that well. I

1007
00:37:16.394 --> 00:37:17.675
- I don't know, doctor Wall. What do you

1008
00:37:17.675 --> 00:37:19.675
- think? Yeah. I mean, it's a great question,

1009
00:37:19.675 --> 00:37:20.954
- and I I love it. I mean, I

1010
00:37:20.954 --> 00:37:22.635
- like to think that my pilot flies a

1011
00:37:22.635 --> 00:37:24.715
- plane because they, you know, they have it's

1012
00:37:24.715 --> 00:37:26.554
- a job. Right? Reality. But I'd like to

1013
00:37:26.554 --> 00:37:27.914
- think that that while they're up there, they

1014
00:37:27.914 --> 00:37:29.110
- wanna make sure that they do the best

1015
00:37:29.110 --> 00:37:30.989
- jobs that they can and that I feel

1016
00:37:30.989 --> 00:37:32.590
- safe and that I'm gonna get home to

1017
00:37:32.590 --> 00:37:33.250
- my family.

1018
00:37:33.789 --> 00:37:35.150
- And I'd like to think that as a

1019
00:37:35.150 --> 00:37:37.470
- scientist, you know and and maybe this is

1020
00:37:37.470 --> 00:37:38.989
- just me, but I got into doing this

1021
00:37:38.989 --> 00:37:41.390
- because I had real strong convictions about trying

1022
00:37:41.390 --> 00:37:42.670
- to make the world a better place in

1023
00:37:42.670 --> 00:37:43.809
- a variety of ways.

1024
00:37:44.364 --> 00:37:44.864
- And,

1025
00:37:45.885 --> 00:37:48.204
- and and my motivation is is my family,

1026
00:37:48.204 --> 00:37:49.265
- is is my

1027
00:37:49.565 --> 00:37:50.065
- community.

1028
00:37:51.164 --> 00:37:51.985
- And so

1029
00:37:52.285 --> 00:37:54.364
- and and I don't yeah. It's a job.

1030
00:37:54.364 --> 00:37:55.644
- Sure. And I'm glad I have a job.

1031
00:37:55.644 --> 00:37:56.844
- I'm really grateful I have a job. It's

1032
00:37:56.844 --> 00:37:58.704
- a job of privilege. There's no question.

1033
00:38:00.710 --> 00:38:02.150
- But I also wanna do the best job

1034
00:38:02.150 --> 00:38:03.750
- that I can, and I wanna make an

1035
00:38:03.750 --> 00:38:05.750
- impact. And I think that more and more,

1036
00:38:05.750 --> 00:38:07.670
- we're seeing that even among the students that

1037
00:38:07.670 --> 00:38:08.949
- I teach. Right? When they talk about what

1038
00:38:08.949 --> 00:38:10.469
- they wanna go do, they they talk about

1039
00:38:10.469 --> 00:38:11.954
- that impact. Like, what kind of impact are

1040
00:38:11.954 --> 00:38:12.775
- they gonna have?

1041
00:38:13.795 --> 00:38:15.635
- And and I think it it's rare for

1042
00:38:15.635 --> 00:38:18.035
- me to hear that from other scientists. And

1043
00:38:18.035 --> 00:38:20.035
- I think that's somewhat what this study is

1044
00:38:20.035 --> 00:38:21.255
- saying. Yeah. It's a job,

1045
00:38:21.555 --> 00:38:23.474
- but it's a job that's meaningful for many

1046
00:38:23.474 --> 00:38:25.639
- of us. Right? We we we work really

1047
00:38:25.639 --> 00:38:27.480
- hard to get to where we are. We

1048
00:38:27.480 --> 00:38:29.500
- we study for a very long time.

1049
00:38:30.039 --> 00:38:31.719
- Many of us who are fortunate enough to

1050
00:38:31.719 --> 00:38:33.799
- go on to have, you know, careers where

1051
00:38:33.799 --> 00:38:35.579
- we have to go through, you know, internships

1052
00:38:36.279 --> 00:38:37.339
- and and apprenticeships

1053
00:38:37.639 --> 00:38:38.085
- and

1054
00:38:38.804 --> 00:38:41.385
- and tenure review and all these things. Right?

1055
00:38:41.605 --> 00:38:43.545
- But we do that at the heart because

1056
00:38:43.684 --> 00:38:46.085
- because of something. Right? We chose that path

1057
00:38:46.085 --> 00:38:47.144
- for some reason.

1058
00:38:49.125 --> 00:38:49.625
- And

1059
00:38:50.340 --> 00:38:51.780
- I I could I I can say that

1060
00:38:51.780 --> 00:38:52.739
- a lot of us spend a lot of

1061
00:38:52.739 --> 00:38:54.200
- time defending science.

1062
00:38:54.739 --> 00:38:56.820
- Right? But but what you know, this study

1063
00:38:56.820 --> 00:38:58.900
- and there's another study by Jan et al,

1064
00:39:00.579 --> 00:39:02.420
- a couple years ago that that found that

1065
00:39:02.420 --> 00:39:04.820
- most scientists spend more time defending science than

1066
00:39:04.820 --> 00:39:06.494
- they do talking about why they do their

1067
00:39:06.494 --> 00:39:08.494
- science, right, their intentions, right, to make the

1068
00:39:08.494 --> 00:39:10.434
- world a better place or not. And

1069
00:39:11.135 --> 00:39:12.974
- I guess we're we're saying what would happen

1070
00:39:12.974 --> 00:39:15.054
- if we flip that switch? What would happen

1071
00:39:15.054 --> 00:39:17.074
- if we spent more time talking about

1072
00:39:17.660 --> 00:39:19.579
- why we do what we do? And I

1073
00:39:19.579 --> 00:39:21.340
- think people in in public health are are

1074
00:39:21.340 --> 00:39:22.860
- are very good at this. They're becoming even

1075
00:39:22.860 --> 00:39:23.760
- better at this.

1076
00:39:24.380 --> 00:39:26.300
- And I've seen some really great examples of

1077
00:39:26.300 --> 00:39:27.980
- this over the years. And so I I

1078
00:39:27.980 --> 00:39:29.260
- wonder what would happen if we flip that

1079
00:39:29.260 --> 00:39:30.806
- switch. And more of us started talking about

1080
00:39:30.806 --> 00:39:31.019
- why we do what we do and who

1081
00:39:31.019 --> 00:39:31.340
- benefits.

1082
00:39:34.875 --> 00:39:36.155
- Yeah. So I think it's enough to have

1083
00:39:36.155 --> 00:39:37.434
- a job, but I'd like to know you

1084
00:39:37.434 --> 00:39:38.735
- wanna do that job well.

1085
00:39:39.035 --> 00:39:41.934
- Yeah. Even if it's basically to understand

1086
00:39:42.315 --> 00:39:44.635
- the world, you know, that is, like, considered,

1087
00:39:44.635 --> 00:39:47.035
- like, meta empathy, which is part of, like,

1088
00:39:47.035 --> 00:39:49.670
- a big way of, like, expressing competence. It's

1089
00:39:49.670 --> 00:39:52.409
- like, if I am taking time to understand

1090
00:39:52.949 --> 00:39:55.529
- you, the world, and everything around me, that

1091
00:39:55.589 --> 00:39:56.869
- itself is part of being

1092
00:39:57.589 --> 00:39:59.529
- like, having a good intentioned,

1093
00:40:01.925 --> 00:40:02.425
- motivational

1094
00:40:02.724 --> 00:40:03.864
- interest in

1095
00:40:05.445 --> 00:40:08.485
- in the world that I am existing in

1096
00:40:08.485 --> 00:40:10.405
- and have a part and a role to

1097
00:40:10.405 --> 00:40:13.125
- play in. And scientists play a big role

1098
00:40:13.125 --> 00:40:14.425
- in creating new knowledge.

1099
00:40:15.510 --> 00:40:18.070
- And that to me is a really, really

1100
00:40:18.070 --> 00:40:18.809
- big job

1101
00:40:19.190 --> 00:40:21.369
- because that means that they get to

1102
00:40:22.390 --> 00:40:26.010
- shape somewhat how we understand the material realities

1103
00:40:26.469 --> 00:40:27.449
- of this world.

1104
00:40:28.390 --> 00:40:31.594
- And if we have such a big job

1105
00:40:31.594 --> 00:40:32.255
- in understanding

1106
00:40:32.554 --> 00:40:33.215
- how we

1107
00:40:33.675 --> 00:40:36.094
- how we make sense of that material reality,

1108
00:40:36.155 --> 00:40:37.855
- that is that is a big

1109
00:40:38.234 --> 00:40:39.054
- big duty

1110
00:40:39.434 --> 00:40:40.175
- and responsibility

1111
00:40:40.795 --> 00:40:42.255
- as a scientist, I think.

1112
00:40:42.635 --> 00:40:44.494
- And I think that should be expressed

1113
00:40:45.590 --> 00:40:47.590
- to the public as in how am I

1114
00:40:47.590 --> 00:40:50.230
- doing that, and what is my intention behind

1115
00:40:50.230 --> 00:40:51.910
- behind it, and what are the values that

1116
00:40:51.910 --> 00:40:52.890
- I bring to the table?

1117
00:40:54.150 --> 00:40:56.710
- So what's next then for for your research?

1118
00:40:56.710 --> 00:40:59.030
- Are are are you planning on looking at

1119
00:40:59.030 --> 00:41:01.485
- perhaps how scientists can better

1120
00:41:01.945 --> 00:41:02.445
- express,

1121
00:41:03.224 --> 00:41:04.764
- you know, what we've just been

1122
00:41:05.065 --> 00:41:07.085
- talking about, or are you looking at

1123
00:41:07.385 --> 00:41:08.445
- at different issues,

1124
00:41:08.744 --> 00:41:10.045
- with regards to credibility?

1125
00:41:11.065 --> 00:41:11.565
- Yeah.

1126
00:41:11.945 --> 00:41:13.304
- Yeah. We've got a lot of work to

1127
00:41:13.304 --> 00:41:16.319
- do. So Shailila alluded to it. We included,

1128
00:41:17.440 --> 00:41:17.839
- several,

1129
00:41:18.400 --> 00:41:18.900
- experimental

1130
00:41:19.199 --> 00:41:20.639
- components to this work as well, and we

1131
00:41:20.639 --> 00:41:22.319
- haven't published those yet. So we're working on

1132
00:41:22.319 --> 00:41:23.299
- getting those out.

1133
00:41:24.159 --> 00:41:26.000
- And, yeah, what we did do is we

1134
00:41:26.000 --> 00:41:28.695
- tested different signals. Right? What happens when scientists

1135
00:41:28.695 --> 00:41:30.454
- do signal these things, and is it effective

1136
00:41:30.454 --> 00:41:31.195
- or not?

1137
00:41:31.815 --> 00:41:33.655
- And then in addition to this, this work

1138
00:41:33.655 --> 00:41:34.615
- was part of my,

1139
00:41:35.095 --> 00:41:37.675
- career project funded by the National Science Foundation,

1140
00:41:37.815 --> 00:41:40.394
- and that included an educational component as well.

1141
00:41:40.454 --> 00:41:42.135
- And so for the last four years, I've

1142
00:41:42.135 --> 00:41:42.855
- been working with,

1143
00:41:43.469 --> 00:41:44.849
- a couple of different groups,

1144
00:41:45.710 --> 00:41:46.849
- at other universities

1145
00:41:47.150 --> 00:41:48.530
- to develop some extension,

1146
00:41:49.630 --> 00:41:51.090
- materials that would actually

1147
00:41:51.710 --> 00:41:54.109
- look at what happens when scientists in these

1148
00:41:54.109 --> 00:41:55.250
- more two way communication

1149
00:41:55.630 --> 00:41:58.434
- kinds of contacts actually signal their credibility. And

1150
00:41:58.434 --> 00:42:00.434
- so we've developed a curriculum, and we pilot

1151
00:42:00.434 --> 00:42:02.614
- it pilot tested that curriculum,

1152
00:42:03.394 --> 00:42:05.795
- and we, have some really interesting findings so

1153
00:42:05.795 --> 00:42:07.474
- far as well. And so we're working on

1154
00:42:07.474 --> 00:42:08.375
- continuing to,

1155
00:42:08.914 --> 00:42:10.594
- format that curriculum and get it out so

1156
00:42:10.594 --> 00:42:12.675
- that it'll be more accessible to extension agents

1157
00:42:12.675 --> 00:42:13.809
- across the country.

1158
00:42:14.349 --> 00:42:15.710
- And then the last part of the work

1159
00:42:15.710 --> 00:42:17.250
- is that, I've been really

1160
00:42:17.630 --> 00:42:19.650
- digging more into this political polarization,

1161
00:42:20.989 --> 00:42:22.909
- and the idea of credibility as something that

1162
00:42:22.909 --> 00:42:24.989
- is politically polarized and where that comes from

1163
00:42:24.989 --> 00:42:26.050
- and what that means,

1164
00:42:26.909 --> 00:42:29.174
- in a variety of different cases and contexts.

1165
00:42:29.554 --> 00:42:31.714
- And so, that work is is supported by

1166
00:42:31.714 --> 00:42:33.635
- the Carnegie Foundation. And so I'm hoping to

1167
00:42:33.635 --> 00:42:34.135
- continue,

1168
00:42:35.194 --> 00:42:36.994
- in in sort of pulling at these threads

1169
00:42:36.994 --> 00:42:38.054
- a little bit more,

1170
00:42:38.514 --> 00:42:39.815
- as we go. And and

1171
00:42:40.139 --> 00:42:42.059
- I just yeah. I think this topic has

1172
00:42:42.059 --> 00:42:43.039
- really captured

1173
00:42:43.339 --> 00:42:45.420
- our attention in the lab for a long

1174
00:42:45.420 --> 00:42:47.099
- time, and it's exciting to see some of

1175
00:42:47.099 --> 00:42:48.559
- this work starting to come out.

1176
00:42:49.099 --> 00:42:51.420
- And when you say curriculum and teaching, is

1177
00:42:51.420 --> 00:42:54.779
- that is that something that you've, you've developed

1178
00:42:54.779 --> 00:42:55.599
- for scientists?

1179
00:42:56.275 --> 00:42:58.295
- So a way for for scientists

1180
00:42:58.594 --> 00:42:59.735
- to better communicate.

1181
00:43:00.835 --> 00:43:01.894
- Is that the idea?

1182
00:43:02.434 --> 00:43:05.014
- Yeah. It's, I'm working with extension educators,

1183
00:43:05.795 --> 00:43:08.135
- at a couple different universities in the Midwest,

1184
00:43:08.994 --> 00:43:10.514
- which is where I started this work, right,

1185
00:43:10.514 --> 00:43:12.719
- in the place based context of of,

1186
00:43:13.119 --> 00:43:15.920
- land management, things like that. So, so, yeah,

1187
00:43:15.920 --> 00:43:17.539
- so the curriculum right now is designed,

1188
00:43:18.159 --> 00:43:20.960
- to work with, people who are land managers

1189
00:43:20.960 --> 00:43:22.340
- and natural resource managers,

1190
00:43:22.960 --> 00:43:24.099
- and help to

1191
00:43:25.335 --> 00:43:27.815
- train them to understand what is credibility. Right?

1192
00:43:27.815 --> 00:43:28.855
- A lot of the things that we've talked

1193
00:43:28.855 --> 00:43:30.375
- about this morning. Right? What is what is

1194
00:43:30.375 --> 00:43:32.215
- credibility? What does it look like? How do

1195
00:43:32.215 --> 00:43:33.894
- we signal it? Right? Scientists are used to

1196
00:43:33.894 --> 00:43:36.295
- picking as credibility as our objectivity, but what

1197
00:43:36.295 --> 00:43:37.889
- if it's these other things in this other

1198
00:43:38.049 --> 00:43:38.549
- context?

1199
00:43:39.329 --> 00:43:41.250
- And then what does it look like to

1200
00:43:41.250 --> 00:43:42.630
- to signal it? And then,

1201
00:43:43.010 --> 00:43:46.049
- in this curriculum also includes direct interactions with,

1202
00:43:46.369 --> 00:43:47.429
- the target audience.

1203
00:43:47.730 --> 00:43:49.969
- And so, scientists are trained to listen to

1204
00:43:49.969 --> 00:43:51.730
- that target audience and to hear the messages

1205
00:43:51.730 --> 00:43:53.454
- and the values that they're expressing,

1206
00:43:53.775 --> 00:43:55.375
- and then come back and practice. Right? What

1207
00:43:55.375 --> 00:43:56.815
- would it mean for me to signal that

1208
00:43:56.815 --> 00:43:58.494
- or for me to meet them where they're

1209
00:43:58.494 --> 00:44:00.414
- at in terms of their values and their

1210
00:44:00.414 --> 00:44:00.914
- concerns?

1211
00:44:01.375 --> 00:44:02.655
- And how do I make sure that this

1212
00:44:02.655 --> 00:44:03.454
- work is,

1213
00:44:03.855 --> 00:44:05.454
- this work or these practices or the things

1214
00:44:05.454 --> 00:44:07.230
- that we're talking about in terms of land

1215
00:44:07.289 --> 00:44:07.789
- management,

1216
00:44:08.250 --> 00:44:10.730
- also come along with messages about, you know,

1217
00:44:10.730 --> 00:44:12.969
- how this might benefit them. Right? And so,

1218
00:44:12.969 --> 00:44:14.090
- yeah, it would be a it'll be a

1219
00:44:14.090 --> 00:44:15.789
- curriculum that'll be available,

1220
00:44:16.410 --> 00:44:18.730
- at the start mostly to extension agents at

1221
00:44:18.730 --> 00:44:20.875
- the universities that I'm currently working with, but

1222
00:44:20.875 --> 00:44:23.195
- I'd like to make it, something even even

1223
00:44:23.195 --> 00:44:25.035
- beyond that. And and this all started when

1224
00:44:25.035 --> 00:44:27.114
- I did a review of the curriculum that

1225
00:44:27.114 --> 00:44:28.555
- existed and realized that there was a lot

1226
00:44:28.555 --> 00:44:31.594
- of educational material out there, for scientists about,

1227
00:44:31.594 --> 00:44:32.335
- you know,

1228
00:44:32.795 --> 00:44:35.675
- crafting the compelling, right, the compelling message, that

1229
00:44:35.675 --> 00:44:37.190
- we talked about at the beginning and, you

1230
00:44:37.190 --> 00:44:39.429
- know, language and framing, which very much is

1231
00:44:39.429 --> 00:44:39.929
- important.

1232
00:44:40.389 --> 00:44:42.150
- But there wasn't a lot about what it

1233
00:44:42.150 --> 00:44:44.069
- means to be a trustworthy source or a

1234
00:44:44.069 --> 00:44:45.049
- credible source.

1235
00:44:45.989 --> 00:44:47.989
- And, you know, there's also some curriculum out

1236
00:44:47.989 --> 00:44:49.349
- there about telling your story, which I think

1237
00:44:49.349 --> 00:44:50.730
- is really important too.

1238
00:44:51.234 --> 00:44:53.074
- But this this part of, like, what are

1239
00:44:53.074 --> 00:44:54.755
- your intentions? Why do you do the work

1240
00:44:54.755 --> 00:44:57.074
- that you do, and and who benefits from

1241
00:44:57.074 --> 00:44:57.574
- it?

1242
00:44:57.954 --> 00:45:00.195
- Is not something that's currently being taught as

1243
00:45:00.195 --> 00:45:00.775
- a curriculum,

1244
00:45:01.155 --> 00:45:02.454
- and I'd love to see it,

1245
00:45:02.994 --> 00:45:03.655
- see it.

1246
00:45:04.380 --> 00:45:05.819
- I'd love to start figuring out how do

1247
00:45:05.819 --> 00:45:07.519
- we do that. Right? And does it matter?

1248
00:45:09.500 --> 00:45:12.299
- Shwaila and Dara, thanks so much for coming

1249
00:45:12.299 --> 00:45:14.139
- on the podcast and talking about,

1250
00:45:14.460 --> 00:45:17.519
- what what is a fascinating study about credibility

1251
00:45:18.059 --> 00:45:18.880
- in science.

1252
00:45:20.065 --> 00:45:21.505
- Thank you so much for having us. It's

1253
00:45:21.505 --> 00:45:23.505
- been great. Thank you for having us. This

1254
00:45:23.505 --> 00:45:24.805
- was a great conversation.

1255
00:45:32.190 --> 00:45:35.869
- That was Dara Wold and Shumila Bhatti of

1256
00:45:35.869 --> 00:45:37.089
- Virginia Tech.

1257
00:45:37.630 --> 00:45:39.730
- Thanks to both of them for a fascinating

1258
00:45:39.949 --> 00:45:40.449
- discussion.

1259
00:45:41.389 --> 00:45:44.530
- Their work is described in a paper called

1260
00:45:44.815 --> 00:45:46.355
- There Is Not

1261
00:45:47.054 --> 00:45:47.554
- Divergent

1262
00:45:47.855 --> 00:45:48.355
- Perceptions

1263
00:45:48.815 --> 00:45:49.715
- of Scientists'

1264
00:45:50.175 --> 00:45:51.315
- Source Credibility

1265
00:45:51.934 --> 00:45:53.235
- in The United States,

1266
00:45:53.855 --> 00:45:55.715
- and that appears in the journal

1267
00:45:56.094 --> 00:45:56.594
- Humanities

1268
00:45:57.295 --> 00:45:58.755
- and Social Sciences

1269
00:45:59.215 --> 00:45:59.715
- Communications.

1270
00:46:00.769 --> 00:46:03.010
- I'll put a link to the paper in

1271
00:46:03.010 --> 00:46:04.630
- the notes for this podcast.

1272
00:46:05.409 --> 00:46:07.329
- I'm afraid that's all the time we have

1273
00:46:07.329 --> 00:46:08.550
- for this week's episode.

1274
00:46:08.929 --> 00:46:12.289
- I'm Hamish Johnston, and our producer is Fred

1275
00:46:12.289 --> 00:46:12.789
- Iles.

1276
00:46:13.425 --> 00:46:16.244
- The music that you hear in Physics World's

1277
00:46:16.305 --> 00:46:16.805
- podcasts

1278
00:46:17.265 --> 00:46:20.465
- is called one three seven, and it was

1279
00:46:20.465 --> 00:46:21.844
- composed and performed

1280
00:46:22.224 --> 00:46:23.125
- by the physicist

1281
00:46:23.744 --> 00:46:24.805
- Philip Moriarty.

1282
00:46:25.664 --> 00:46:27.605
- We'll be back again next week.