1
00:00:02,101 --> 00:00:04,425
You're listening to the Ina ran Institute live

2
00:00:04,480 --> 00:00:05,352
podcast series.

3
00:00:06,304 --> 00:00:08,223
She is the title of this talk. You

4
00:00:08,223 --> 00:00:09,574
tell me, I I have no idea how

5
00:00:09,654 --> 00:00:11,562
I got into this. This is the title

6
00:00:11,562 --> 00:00:12,834
of the talk. It's in your program.

7
00:00:13,391 --> 00:00:14,981
The battle for the future. Okay? That's pretty

8
00:00:14,981 --> 00:00:16,825
clear. Right? Can you Melee,

9
00:00:17,462 --> 00:00:17,780
Ukraine,

10
00:00:18,337 --> 00:00:19,530
Trump, Israel,

11
00:00:20,008 --> 00:00:20,485
America,

12
00:00:20,883 --> 00:00:21,281
Europe,

13
00:00:21,758 --> 00:00:22,474
and all that.

14
00:00:25,354 --> 00:00:27,107
I have no idea what anybody was thinking

15
00:00:27,107 --> 00:00:28,223
when they came over with that title. It

16
00:00:28,223 --> 00:00:30,534
wasn't my title. Believe me. I don't... I

17
00:00:30,534 --> 00:00:32,686
wouldn't do that to myself, but there you

18
00:00:32,686 --> 00:00:32,846
go.

19
00:00:34,296 --> 00:00:35,253
Hey good luck. Thank you.

20
00:00:37,884 --> 00:00:40,675
Simon actually get a start somewhere else. I'm

21
00:00:40,675 --> 00:00:43,238
gonna start you in Amsterdam. Rather than try

22
00:00:43,238 --> 00:00:44,590
to take on that list. We'll get to

23
00:00:44,590 --> 00:00:45,306
that list later.

24
00:00:47,055 --> 00:00:49,202
I mean, I I love the city, and

25
00:00:49,281 --> 00:00:51,445
I'm I'm happy that this an objective conference

26
00:00:51,445 --> 00:00:53,617
here, and I'll talk about Amps amsterdam specifically

27
00:00:53,754 --> 00:00:55,506
tomorrow. We've got a whole talk about it.

28
00:00:56,383 --> 00:00:57,736
But 1 of the things that Ams amsterdam

29
00:00:57,816 --> 00:00:58,475
I think

30
00:00:58,851 --> 00:01:01,023
represents and should represent in our mind and

31
00:01:01,023 --> 00:01:02,381
if you study history a little bit.

32
00:01:03,420 --> 00:01:05,199
Am amsterdam to a large extent

33
00:01:05,898 --> 00:01:08,455
can be viewed as the birthplace of the

34
00:01:08,455 --> 00:01:08,775
enlightenment.

35
00:01:10,302 --> 00:01:11,437
Amsterdam represents

36
00:01:11,890 --> 00:01:13,343
the turning from

37
00:01:13,717 --> 00:01:14,590
the Renaissance,

38
00:01:15,226 --> 00:01:17,291
to an enlightenment that really develops in france

39
00:01:17,291 --> 00:01:19,848
and in England and a Scotland but everything

40
00:01:19,848 --> 00:01:20,825
goes through

41
00:01:21,598 --> 00:01:23,108
right where we are now.

42
00:01:24,301 --> 00:01:26,527
Really, many of the first thinkers of the

43
00:01:26,527 --> 00:01:28,928
enlightenment, the beginning of the enlightenment that we

44
00:01:28,928 --> 00:01:31,237
are radicals of the enlightenment are here.

45
00:01:32,352 --> 00:01:35,240
Am amsterdam where almost all the publishing houses

46
00:01:35,616 --> 00:01:38,600
that ultimately publish the text of the enlightenment

47
00:01:38,817 --> 00:01:40,889
that are too radical to be published in

48
00:01:41,049 --> 00:01:42,403
Paris or in London.

49
00:01:43,120 --> 00:01:44,077
This is where they're published.

50
00:01:45,288 --> 00:01:47,863
So Ams amsterdam has a unique historical

51
00:01:49,358 --> 00:01:52,711
significance if we value liberty if we value

52
00:01:52,711 --> 00:01:54,874
freedom, again, I'll talk about it more tomorrow.

53
00:01:55,670 --> 00:01:59,032
But I think that's a good entry into

54
00:01:59,486 --> 00:02:01,474
what I think is really, really important if

55
00:02:01,474 --> 00:02:03,238
we wanna understand the world and we we

56
00:02:03,238 --> 00:02:03,795
live today.

57
00:02:05,227 --> 00:02:07,534
And that is an entry into the enlightenment.

58
00:02:09,523 --> 00:02:10,023
In

59
00:02:10,493 --> 00:02:11,152
in a

60
00:02:12,719 --> 00:02:14,968
in a sense, the enlightenment is

61
00:02:15,581 --> 00:02:17,433
what when we talk about Western

62
00:02:17,808 --> 00:02:17,967
civilization,

63
00:02:18,618 --> 00:02:19,436
is really

64
00:02:19,891 --> 00:02:21,243
intellectually what we're talking about.

65
00:02:22,118 --> 00:02:23,254
The alignment is

66
00:02:23,629 --> 00:02:25,354
intellectually the most crucial period

67
00:02:25,871 --> 00:02:27,006
in the West history

68
00:02:27,619 --> 00:02:30,638
other than Greece, which, of course, inspires, the

69
00:02:31,035 --> 00:02:32,147
Renaissance and then the enlightenment.

70
00:02:33,275 --> 00:02:35,424
But in terms of what's happening in Europe,

71
00:02:35,583 --> 00:02:37,732
the enlightenment is where the ideas,

72
00:02:38,129 --> 00:02:40,198
the good ideas that we have today in

73
00:02:40,198 --> 00:02:41,392
the west come from.

74
00:02:42,362 --> 00:02:44,909
And all the battles that long list of

75
00:02:44,909 --> 00:02:46,603
bad stuff that's happening in the world

76
00:02:47,377 --> 00:02:49,628
is really an anti enlightenment

77
00:02:50,099 --> 00:02:50,599
constant

78
00:02:51,060 --> 00:02:53,460
force. There is a battle going on in

79
00:02:53,460 --> 00:02:54,120
the west

80
00:02:55,300 --> 00:02:57,300
between the enlightenment and the anti enlightenment. And

81
00:02:57,300 --> 00:02:58,840
it's me going on, since

82
00:02:59,231 --> 00:02:59,787
Main enlightenment?

83
00:03:01,928 --> 00:03:04,015
So what is the enlightenment? What does it

84
00:03:04,070 --> 00:03:05,736
represent? What are the ideas that come out

85
00:03:05,736 --> 00:03:06,450
of the enlightenment?

86
00:03:07,417 --> 00:03:08,631
That are then challenged

87
00:03:09,083 --> 00:03:12,416
and a constantly under attack. And today you

88
00:03:12,416 --> 00:03:14,797
see that attack on a scale. Maybe we

89
00:03:14,797 --> 00:03:15,614
haven't seen

90
00:03:15,923 --> 00:03:17,035
maybe since World war 2.

91
00:03:19,021 --> 00:03:20,713
But what are the what is the enlightenment

92
00:03:20,848 --> 00:03:21,007
represent?

93
00:03:22,596 --> 00:03:24,240
It represents a

94
00:03:24,837 --> 00:03:26,293
decline and demise

95
00:03:26,908 --> 00:03:28,523
of religion, but more fundamentally,

96
00:03:28,899 --> 00:03:31,310
a decline of demise of faith

97
00:03:31,686 --> 00:03:32,801
as the source of knowledge.

98
00:03:34,012 --> 00:03:37,144
The idea of the enlightenment is that reason

99
00:03:37,681 --> 00:03:39,834
is where we get knowledge from. Maybe they

100
00:03:39,834 --> 00:03:41,669
didn't have a folk... We know they didn't

101
00:03:41,669 --> 00:03:43,997
have a full conception of reason. Full conception

102
00:03:43,997 --> 00:03:47,187
of what rationality meant, that Only Rand has.

103
00:03:47,347 --> 00:03:49,761
And in every 1 of these respects, Rand

104
00:03:49,819 --> 00:03:50,319
completes

105
00:03:50,697 --> 00:03:52,212
the project that is the enlightenment.

106
00:03:53,264 --> 00:03:55,278
But they clearly have a view

107
00:03:55,734 --> 00:03:57,429
that's understand the world

108
00:03:57,885 --> 00:03:58,624
we need

109
00:03:59,160 --> 00:04:00,377
reason. We need

110
00:04:00,928 --> 00:04:01,428
perception

111
00:04:01,885 --> 00:04:03,182
we need to view

112
00:04:03,638 --> 00:04:05,552
the world out there and we need cognition.

113
00:04:06,189 --> 00:04:08,581
We don't get truth from revelation.

114
00:04:09,713 --> 00:04:12,907
And they're rejecting faith, not completely, not in

115
00:04:12,907 --> 00:04:15,222
any in every realm of life, but in

116
00:04:15,222 --> 00:04:16,281
a significant

117
00:04:16,978 --> 00:04:17,478
portion

118
00:04:17,857 --> 00:04:18,336
of life.

119
00:04:19,624 --> 00:04:22,800
So it's the re rebirth of reason. It's

120
00:04:22,800 --> 00:04:25,023
not an accident that the enlightenment is often

121
00:04:25,023 --> 00:04:26,635
called the age of

122
00:04:27,584 --> 00:04:27,904
reason,

123
00:04:28,704 --> 00:04:30,384
the age of reason, and the age of

124
00:04:30,384 --> 00:04:32,944
science and science and reason, of course, go

125
00:04:32,944 --> 00:04:33,185
together.

126
00:04:34,959 --> 00:04:36,098
You know, 1 of the

127
00:04:36,557 --> 00:04:38,953
Amsterdam. Right? So so you... We have here

128
00:04:38,953 --> 00:04:41,510
the philosopher Spin who's part of that movement.

129
00:04:42,243 --> 00:04:43,142
Away from faith

130
00:04:43,838 --> 00:04:44,396
towards reason.

131
00:04:45,672 --> 00:04:46,411
So reason

132
00:04:46,788 --> 00:04:49,020
is definitely a concept and idea that efficacy

133
00:04:49,020 --> 00:04:51,109
of reason. The importance of reason, reason as

134
00:04:51,109 --> 00:04:53,128
our means as human beings I'm knowing reality

135
00:04:53,586 --> 00:04:54,646
comes from

136
00:04:55,185 --> 00:04:55,824
the enlightenment.

137
00:04:57,183 --> 00:04:59,760
And if there's an understanding that they're

138
00:05:00,714 --> 00:05:01,613
entity that reasons

139
00:05:03,351 --> 00:05:04,070
is the individual.

140
00:05:05,509 --> 00:05:08,146
And the value of the individual again comes

141
00:05:08,146 --> 00:05:09,345
out of the enlightenment.

142
00:05:10,315 --> 00:05:11,689
It's a period in which

143
00:05:12,301 --> 00:05:15,638
individuals liberated to stop making decisions for themselves.

144
00:05:17,323 --> 00:05:19,237
This is a period in which people are

145
00:05:19,237 --> 00:05:20,354
thinking for themselves,

146
00:05:21,311 --> 00:05:21,789
acting,

147
00:05:22,507 --> 00:05:25,559
pursuing their own values, their own

148
00:05:25,937 --> 00:05:26,176
interests.

149
00:05:27,707 --> 00:05:30,521
It's the shadowing of the idea

150
00:05:30,898 --> 00:05:33,292
that, you know, the the community can decide

151
00:05:33,292 --> 00:05:35,625
who you should marry what profession you should

152
00:05:35,625 --> 00:05:37,865
have what values you should pursue what you

153
00:05:37,865 --> 00:05:40,584
should believe and suddenly, the idea that individuals

154
00:05:40,584 --> 00:05:41,944
should be able to decide for themselves.

155
00:05:43,318 --> 00:05:45,246
Who to Marry, what career to pursue

156
00:05:45,935 --> 00:05:46,911
and ultimately

157
00:05:47,918 --> 00:05:49,132
who their political

158
00:05:49,505 --> 00:05:50,219
leaders should be.

159
00:05:51,741 --> 00:05:54,439
So coming out of the enlightenment is a

160
00:05:54,439 --> 00:05:55,471
concept, again,

161
00:05:56,423 --> 00:05:58,486
somewhat primitive, particularly when you come from the

162
00:05:58,486 --> 00:05:59,359
perspective of Vine man.

163
00:06:00,168 --> 00:06:02,471
Of individual, there's even an attempt to figure

164
00:06:02,471 --> 00:06:03,924
out how do we get morality

165
00:06:04,694 --> 00:06:06,044
if it's not from God. How do we

166
00:06:06,044 --> 00:06:07,315
get from morality from reason?

167
00:06:08,283 --> 00:06:09,633
That they don't do a good job at

168
00:06:09,633 --> 00:06:10,983
it, but they're trying.

169
00:06:11,618 --> 00:06:13,763
And it's not accident than in the declaration

170
00:06:13,763 --> 00:06:15,986
of independence in American declaration independence,

171
00:06:16,701 --> 00:06:17,201
there's

172
00:06:17,828 --> 00:06:20,612
an alien a right to pursue happiness, happiness

173
00:06:20,612 --> 00:06:21,647
as an individual,

174
00:06:23,237 --> 00:06:23,953
your happiness.

175
00:06:25,001 --> 00:06:27,776
That's individual ism. There's that's a beginning of

176
00:06:27,776 --> 00:06:30,416
self interest. That's a beginning or maybe the

177
00:06:30,471 --> 00:06:32,866
right? It there's real ego there. Even if

178
00:06:32,866 --> 00:06:35,409
they can't articulate it as a moral theory,

179
00:06:36,045 --> 00:06:37,952
the orientation is already towards that.

180
00:06:38,985 --> 00:06:41,051
That's coming out of the enlightenment, individual ism.

181
00:06:42,261 --> 00:06:44,913
And finally, of course, the consequence of individual

182
00:06:45,050 --> 00:06:45,688
is political.

183
00:06:46,963 --> 00:06:48,977
And a consequence of an individualistic

184
00:06:49,448 --> 00:06:51,680
perspective politically is political freedom.

185
00:06:53,114 --> 00:06:55,845
And the enlightenment is this period where they're

186
00:06:55,983 --> 00:06:56,222
advocating,

187
00:06:56,874 --> 00:06:59,977
this starting to challenge the prevailing view of

188
00:06:59,977 --> 00:07:00,454
politics,

189
00:07:01,011 --> 00:07:03,580
kings, and and our stock

190
00:07:04,289 --> 00:07:06,227
and that whole notion and you get

191
00:07:06,606 --> 00:07:08,843
both out of the Scottish light, but primarily

192
00:07:08,843 --> 00:07:11,880
out of the enlightenment, this real suspicion of

193
00:07:11,880 --> 00:07:13,732
ever stock with see this world suspicion of

194
00:07:13,732 --> 00:07:16,549
kings, and the demands, the beginning of demands

195
00:07:16,848 --> 00:07:17,907
for Republic

196
00:07:18,286 --> 00:07:18,786
for

197
00:07:19,656 --> 00:07:22,281
individuals being able to choose their political leaders.

198
00:07:23,077 --> 00:07:25,383
And of course, what you get is the

199
00:07:25,383 --> 00:07:25,883
key

200
00:07:26,435 --> 00:07:27,415
political concept,

201
00:07:27,795 --> 00:07:31,014
the key political concept that we all understand

202
00:07:31,314 --> 00:07:32,675
is that the heart politics,

203
00:07:33,314 --> 00:07:33,875
which is what.

204
00:07:34,529 --> 00:07:35,563
What's the beginning,

205
00:07:36,994 --> 00:07:39,061
the key concept for politics?

206
00:07:40,811 --> 00:07:40,970
Rights?

207
00:07:41,686 --> 00:07:43,992
Individual rights. Right? Individual rights. That's the bridge.

208
00:07:44,564 --> 00:07:45,680
Between individual,

209
00:07:46,318 --> 00:07:48,311
and the political is individual rates,

210
00:07:49,188 --> 00:07:52,218
and that's John Lock. Right? And even before

211
00:07:52,377 --> 00:07:55,024
John Lock, a little bit. There's a beginning

212
00:07:55,024 --> 00:07:56,620
of it here. An Am amsterdam with,

213
00:07:58,614 --> 00:07:59,332
how do you pronounce it?

214
00:08:00,623 --> 00:08:01,659
Oh, forget about it.

215
00:08:02,695 --> 00:08:04,448
I'm not gonna even try to do that,

216
00:08:04,608 --> 00:08:05,404
but that guy.

217
00:08:08,288 --> 00:08:09,962
And again, he doesn't have it full conception,

218
00:08:10,122 --> 00:08:11,795
but this is the beginning that that that

219
00:08:11,795 --> 00:08:13,709
working on this concept of rights and what

220
00:08:13,709 --> 00:08:15,781
it means and what implications it has for

221
00:08:15,781 --> 00:08:16,235
politics

222
00:08:16,594 --> 00:08:17,714
And of course, by the time you get

223
00:08:17,714 --> 00:08:19,474
to the funny father, there's 17 76.

224
00:08:20,435 --> 00:08:22,354
Now you've got a theory and you've got

225
00:08:22,354 --> 00:08:25,875
a political application. And America is the cro

226
00:08:25,875 --> 00:08:28,179
achievement of the enlightenment in terms of pull

227
00:08:28,179 --> 00:08:28,497
politics.

228
00:08:29,053 --> 00:08:30,563
It is the manifestation of it.

229
00:08:32,491 --> 00:08:34,886
And the declaration of independence, the greatest document,

230
00:08:35,125 --> 00:08:36,902
political document I think ever written

231
00:08:37,280 --> 00:08:39,436
is a manifestation of that enlightenment.

232
00:08:40,009 --> 00:08:42,081
So here you have a whole system built

233
00:08:42,081 --> 00:08:42,798
on reason,

234
00:08:43,914 --> 00:08:44,414
individual

235
00:08:44,790 --> 00:08:45,826
and political liberty,

236
00:08:46,304 --> 00:08:46,782
individual rights.

237
00:08:48,154 --> 00:08:51,514
That's what the lay is. And really that

238
00:08:51,514 --> 00:08:54,714
is what Western civilization is. That's the essence

239
00:08:54,714 --> 00:08:57,126
of civilization. That when we're talking about what

240
00:08:57,126 --> 00:08:59,039
we're fighting for. That's what we're fighting for.

241
00:08:59,198 --> 00:09:01,271
We're fighting for a deeper understanding of that

242
00:09:01,271 --> 00:09:03,524
because Ay rand has completed all of those

243
00:09:03,582 --> 00:09:06,095
and given us a much more solid

244
00:09:06,475 --> 00:09:08,554
foundation for all of those concepts. But it

245
00:09:08,554 --> 00:09:11,034
is those concepts that we're fighting for is

246
00:09:11,034 --> 00:09:12,154
those ideas,

247
00:09:12,808 --> 00:09:15,303
that are crucial to maintaining

248
00:09:15,681 --> 00:09:17,856
civilization. It is what civilization

249
00:09:18,233 --> 00:09:18,951
means today.

250
00:09:20,719 --> 00:09:23,108
And An got talked about how amazing the

251
00:09:23,108 --> 00:09:24,381
world around us isn't it is.

252
00:09:25,576 --> 00:09:27,645
I mean, it's again, easy in my list.

253
00:09:28,298 --> 00:09:29,811
Reinforces is easy to focus on all the

254
00:09:29,811 --> 00:09:30,129
negatives.

255
00:09:31,881 --> 00:09:34,429
But, you know who's holding up his phone

256
00:09:34,429 --> 00:09:36,261
up there and video taping me, you know,

257
00:09:38,514 --> 00:09:40,835
it is amazing. You know, yeah. I've got

258
00:09:40,835 --> 00:09:41,154
the iphone.

259
00:09:43,475 --> 00:09:44,595
How to pull it out at some point.

260
00:09:44,754 --> 00:09:47,325
Right? And this stuff is amazing. We live

261
00:09:47,325 --> 00:09:48,623
in a time that is

262
00:09:49,001 --> 00:09:51,076
truly spectacular in terms of,

263
00:09:51,475 --> 00:09:54,284
our ability to live ability to exercise, I

264
00:09:54,284 --> 00:09:56,442
will ability to add to pursue our values.

265
00:09:57,241 --> 00:09:58,999
Yes. There are lots of limitations and we

266
00:09:58,999 --> 00:10:00,997
can focus on all the bad and all

267
00:10:00,997 --> 00:10:02,456
the constraints and all

268
00:10:03,567 --> 00:10:05,709
But why? You know, we can also focus

269
00:10:05,709 --> 00:10:08,169
on other the positives from historical perspective. There's

270
00:10:08,169 --> 00:10:09,597
never been a better time to be alive.

271
00:10:11,602 --> 00:10:11,842
Intellectually.

272
00:10:12,799 --> 00:10:15,593
The enlightenment the nineteenth century and and Greece

273
00:10:15,593 --> 00:10:18,626
were greater, artistic, the nineteenth century was great

274
00:10:18,626 --> 00:10:18,866
of it.

275
00:10:19,678 --> 00:10:21,671
And and many centuries were greater, but, you

276
00:10:21,671 --> 00:10:23,344
know, I can enjoy all that all today.

277
00:10:24,380 --> 00:10:26,054
So they're no modern and artists that are

278
00:10:26,054 --> 00:10:28,222
equating anything like that. Okay. But I can

279
00:10:28,222 --> 00:10:29,579
still enjoy all that out today, and I

280
00:10:29,579 --> 00:10:31,335
can enjoy all that out today because I

281
00:10:31,335 --> 00:10:32,692
can get on an plane and go there.

282
00:10:33,092 --> 00:10:34,449
And I can enjoy all that out today

283
00:10:34,449 --> 00:10:35,726
because I can go on the internet and

284
00:10:35,726 --> 00:10:36,045
search it.

285
00:10:36,699 --> 00:10:38,215
And experience it, I can even go to

286
00:10:38,215 --> 00:10:39,891
a company and ask them to print me

287
00:10:39,891 --> 00:10:41,726
out a copy of my favorite painting.

288
00:10:42,604 --> 00:10:43,104
And

289
00:10:43,801 --> 00:10:46,600
you'll get a... Oil painting, a a replica

290
00:10:46,600 --> 00:10:48,189
of, your favorite painting put up on your

291
00:10:48,189 --> 00:10:49,540
wall doesn't cost that much money.

292
00:10:51,208 --> 00:10:52,718
These are truly amazing things.

293
00:10:54,563 --> 00:10:56,872
But that's all, and it's important to understand

294
00:10:56,872 --> 00:10:59,681
that all of that. The science, the technology,

295
00:11:00,296 --> 00:11:00,796
the

296
00:11:01,331 --> 00:11:01,705
entrepreneurship

297
00:11:02,461 --> 00:11:02,961
And

298
00:11:03,338 --> 00:11:06,047
the acceptance in our society at least to

299
00:11:06,047 --> 00:11:08,038
some extent of the fact that each 1

300
00:11:08,038 --> 00:11:09,950
of us is pursuing happiness to the acceptance

301
00:11:09,950 --> 00:11:10,349
of that.

302
00:11:12,037 --> 00:11:12,992
That's the enlightenment.

303
00:11:13,630 --> 00:11:15,780
That's the remnants of the enlightenment in our

304
00:11:15,780 --> 00:11:16,099
culture.

305
00:11:16,975 --> 00:11:19,205
That's still alive and well every time Entrepreneur

306
00:11:19,205 --> 00:11:20,002
a start a company.

307
00:11:20,894 --> 00:11:21,794
Taking risks

308
00:11:22,334 --> 00:11:24,975
based on his own ideas, without asking for

309
00:11:24,975 --> 00:11:26,334
permission from the Prince of the King or

310
00:11:26,334 --> 00:11:26,735
whatever,

311
00:11:28,667 --> 00:11:30,338
that's the lang now that...

312
00:11:30,975 --> 00:11:32,328
Again, it's not perfect,

313
00:11:33,442 --> 00:11:33,942
but

314
00:11:34,318 --> 00:11:36,308
we should appreciate what we have, and we

315
00:11:36,308 --> 00:11:37,581
should appreciate where it comes from.

316
00:11:40,615 --> 00:11:41,568
So that's the positive.

317
00:11:42,283 --> 00:11:43,736
And the positive is

318
00:11:44,666 --> 00:11:46,889
all grounded in those ideas.

319
00:11:48,820 --> 00:11:50,019
Now from the beginning,

320
00:11:50,660 --> 00:11:51,860
the enlightenment is challenged.

321
00:11:52,500 --> 00:11:55,080
From the beginning, the anti enlightenment

322
00:11:55,460 --> 00:11:56,580
forces ways up.

323
00:11:58,187 --> 00:11:59,641
Initially, it's a philosophical

324
00:12:00,094 --> 00:12:00,253
objection.

325
00:12:01,922 --> 00:12:04,782
Initially, it's an attack both from philosophy and

326
00:12:04,782 --> 00:12:05,417
from religion.

327
00:12:06,627 --> 00:12:09,258
The attack of religion is not particularly powerful.

328
00:12:10,135 --> 00:12:12,310
But what is powerful is the attack from

329
00:12:12,368 --> 00:12:14,122
philosophy. And you can talk to the philosophers

330
00:12:14,122 --> 00:12:16,362
about why their tax from philosophy was so

331
00:12:16,362 --> 00:12:18,028
successful, what the holes were in the lay.

332
00:12:18,266 --> 00:12:20,328
We're not gonna get into that. But for

333
00:12:20,328 --> 00:12:22,886
emmanuel, or can't he to shopping out to

334
00:12:22,886 --> 00:12:26,395
marx the whole string of mostly German philosophers.

335
00:12:28,229 --> 00:12:31,834
They attack and demolished these ideas of reason,

336
00:12:32,394 --> 00:12:34,894
we on commented mentioned it earlier, Right? But

337
00:12:34,954 --> 00:12:37,914
undermining reason. Right? Can't turning reason upside down.

338
00:12:39,446 --> 00:12:41,520
Yeah. You can do it. It just doesn't

339
00:12:41,520 --> 00:12:43,035
reflect anything about the real world. It doesn't

340
00:12:43,035 --> 00:12:44,152
reflect anything about reality.

341
00:12:45,349 --> 00:12:46,146
The attack reason,

342
00:12:46,944 --> 00:12:48,140
the attack individual,

343
00:12:49,269 --> 00:12:51,415
We're all 1. He says, Right? I mean,

344
00:12:51,495 --> 00:12:52,949
there's no individual

345
00:12:54,038 --> 00:12:54,356
marx,

346
00:12:54,913 --> 00:12:57,377
and they attack, of course, political freedom, political

347
00:12:57,377 --> 00:12:59,938
liberty. And the consequence, once you get rid

348
00:12:59,938 --> 00:13:00,836
of individual

349
00:13:02,007 --> 00:13:03,440
is gonna be authoritarianism.

350
00:13:06,635 --> 00:13:09,201
Now it takes ideas time to manifest

351
00:13:09,733 --> 00:13:10,233
themselves

352
00:13:10,846 --> 00:13:13,388
in human action and in political action.

353
00:13:14,519 --> 00:13:16,676
So the really, really bad ideas that compost

354
00:13:16,676 --> 00:13:18,594
composed enlightenment that attacking the enlightenment.

355
00:13:19,153 --> 00:13:21,310
Don't really have an impact in the nineteenth

356
00:13:21,310 --> 00:13:21,630
century.

357
00:13:22,284 --> 00:13:24,384
Or don't have as much of an impact

358
00:13:24,684 --> 00:13:27,024
in the nineteenth century. Nineteenth century, there's the

359
00:13:27,164 --> 00:13:30,056
energy, the spirit of the enlightenment. It's the

360
00:13:30,056 --> 00:13:33,418
industrial revolution. It's taking those enlightenment ideas and

361
00:13:34,031 --> 00:13:34,531
manifesting

362
00:13:34,985 --> 00:13:37,768
themselves in people's lives and building and creating

363
00:13:37,768 --> 00:13:38,825
people too excited

364
00:13:39,294 --> 00:13:40,333
what are they excited about?

365
00:13:41,052 --> 00:13:41,612
They're free.

366
00:13:42,411 --> 00:13:43,849
Maybe for the first time in human history,

367
00:13:44,089 --> 00:13:46,166
people are free. They go out there. They

368
00:13:46,166 --> 00:13:48,259
can invent they could produce. They can... Build,

369
00:13:48,420 --> 00:13:49,139
they can create.

370
00:13:51,059 --> 00:13:52,580
This has never happened before.

371
00:13:53,379 --> 00:13:56,019
They don't need to ask for permission.

372
00:13:57,393 --> 00:13:57,893
It's

373
00:13:58,666 --> 00:14:01,211
for brief period, there's a permission society.

374
00:14:03,279 --> 00:14:05,290
So the enlightenment is manifest.

375
00:14:05,999 --> 00:14:07,197
In this nineteenth century,

376
00:14:07,996 --> 00:14:11,372
not fully not consistently with all the caveats

377
00:14:11,511 --> 00:14:12,810
associated with it, but

378
00:14:13,202 --> 00:14:15,664
to a greater extent than in ever in

379
00:14:15,664 --> 00:14:18,229
human history really. In terms of the freedom

380
00:14:18,285 --> 00:14:19,341
individuals can express

381
00:14:19,714 --> 00:14:21,144
and go out there and build and create

382
00:14:21,144 --> 00:14:21,621
and make.

383
00:14:23,788 --> 00:14:26,685
But in the background, the intellectual are striving

384
00:14:26,744 --> 00:14:26,984
against.

385
00:14:27,863 --> 00:14:28,842
And the real

386
00:14:29,460 --> 00:14:32,496
the real effect of the anti enlightenment is

387
00:14:32,496 --> 00:14:34,346
really not felt until

388
00:14:36,703 --> 00:14:37,497
the twentieth century.

389
00:14:38,469 --> 00:14:38,708
Right?

390
00:14:39,667 --> 00:14:41,106
And in the twentieth century you, you get

391
00:14:41,106 --> 00:14:43,104
the full impact of what that means.

392
00:14:44,303 --> 00:14:47,120
And that's world 1, and that's world 2

393
00:14:47,433 --> 00:14:48,729
That's the ways of communism,

394
00:14:49,184 --> 00:14:50,241
ways of fascism,

395
00:14:51,809 --> 00:14:53,719
and ultimately the ways of the mixed economy.

396
00:14:54,688 --> 00:14:56,542
But really fascism and

397
00:14:56,997 --> 00:14:57,497
communism,

398
00:14:57,952 --> 00:14:59,805
a direct attacks

399
00:15:00,579 --> 00:15:02,250
on the enlightenment in politics.

400
00:15:02,663 --> 00:15:06,323
Their direct attacks on Western civilization. They arise

401
00:15:06,323 --> 00:15:08,790
from the west, but they're anti western.

402
00:15:10,078 --> 00:15:11,991
The anti civilization forces.

403
00:15:13,506 --> 00:15:16,137
They want in that sense the reactionary forces.

404
00:15:16,296 --> 00:15:17,811
They're trying to take us back to an

405
00:15:17,811 --> 00:15:21,175
era from before the enlightenment. From before the

406
00:15:21,175 --> 00:15:23,966
discovery of the efficacy reason, communism denies it,

407
00:15:24,206 --> 00:15:25,880
really if you understand what they talk about

408
00:15:25,880 --> 00:15:27,316
when they even say the word reason.

409
00:15:27,968 --> 00:15:31,071
Fascism denies reason, suddenly they both deny individual

410
00:15:31,071 --> 00:15:32,923
ism and suddenly both deny

411
00:15:33,855 --> 00:15:34,412
political freedom.

412
00:15:36,096 --> 00:15:36,834
So fascism,

413
00:15:37,606 --> 00:15:40,625
and and communism, a direct attacks at the

414
00:15:40,625 --> 00:15:43,248
enlightenment and direct attacks at Western civilization.

415
00:15:44,694 --> 00:15:45,490
And they're defeated.

416
00:15:46,603 --> 00:15:47,001
Thoroughly,

417
00:15:47,797 --> 00:15:50,365
systematically. They're defeated. They're crushed

418
00:15:52,982 --> 00:15:54,493
And it by the time they're crushed.

419
00:15:55,925 --> 00:15:57,618
Our understanding in the west

420
00:15:58,168 --> 00:16:00,662
of the ideas that made the west possible

421
00:16:01,359 --> 00:16:02,715
is dramatically diminished.

422
00:16:04,150 --> 00:16:05,985
So we know we kinda won, but we

423
00:16:05,985 --> 00:16:06,884
don't know why

424
00:16:08,393 --> 00:16:10,647
We know we kinda won, but we don't

425
00:16:10,705 --> 00:16:12,539
understand where that comes from.

426
00:16:13,656 --> 00:16:15,889
In the West we cling maybe to the

427
00:16:15,889 --> 00:16:18,294
idea of political freedom but we don't really

428
00:16:18,294 --> 00:16:21,239
understand its value because we've lost individual and

429
00:16:21,239 --> 00:16:22,194
we've lost reason.

430
00:16:22,831 --> 00:16:25,616
I intellectual is no longer advocate for individual

431
00:16:25,616 --> 00:16:26,173
and reason.

432
00:16:26,984 --> 00:16:29,929
So all we have is kind of AAA

433
00:16:29,929 --> 00:16:32,953
mushy conception of what political freedom actually means,

434
00:16:33,351 --> 00:16:34,864
and it's turned into much more of a

435
00:16:34,864 --> 00:16:37,347
democracy than it was originally. Thought of as

436
00:16:37,347 --> 00:16:40,296
an individual rates based Republic. The concept of

437
00:16:40,296 --> 00:16:41,434
individual rates is lost

438
00:16:42,209 --> 00:16:44,202
to a large extent. I mean, remnants survive

439
00:16:44,202 --> 00:16:47,237
in America because America has a constitution. So

440
00:16:47,237 --> 00:16:49,459
they can, you know, why they're textual lists,

441
00:16:49,856 --> 00:16:51,761
why are their original lists and the Supreme

442
00:16:51,840 --> 00:16:55,200
Court of America, the conservatives became. Original textual?

443
00:16:55,679 --> 00:16:57,059
Because they don't understand

444
00:16:57,759 --> 00:16:58,500
the concepts.

445
00:16:59,919 --> 00:17:01,759
So they go by the woods. Oh, what

446
00:17:01,759 --> 00:17:03,774
did this mean in the 17 18 oh,

447
00:17:03,854 --> 00:17:05,931
okay. That's what it means. Right? They can't...

448
00:17:06,091 --> 00:17:08,248
They don't have a conceptual understanding of individual

449
00:17:08,248 --> 00:17:09,286
rights and how to apply it.

450
00:17:10,245 --> 00:17:12,976
State follow the exact wording of the thing.

451
00:17:13,216 --> 00:17:13,376
Oh,

452
00:17:14,654 --> 00:17:16,491
abortion... It doesn't say here there's a right

453
00:17:16,491 --> 00:17:17,530
abortion in the bill of rights.

454
00:17:18,263 --> 00:17:18,582
And

455
00:17:19,219 --> 00:17:20,970
they had to attitude in the bush and

456
00:17:20,970 --> 00:17:22,562
in the at eighteenth century therefore oh, Bush

457
00:17:22,562 --> 00:17:23,779
and must not be protected

458
00:17:24,154 --> 00:17:25,747
because they can't understand.

459
00:17:26,398 --> 00:17:28,148
The idea of individual ways and therefore a

460
00:17:28,148 --> 00:17:30,398
highway apply to all these circumstances

461
00:17:31,092 --> 00:17:31,887
unless it's written down.

462
00:17:33,492 --> 00:17:34,231
That's how

463
00:17:34,923 --> 00:17:35,979
non conceptual

464
00:17:36,591 --> 00:17:37,091
our

465
00:17:37,783 --> 00:17:40,564
most, you know, as smartest judges in the

466
00:17:40,643 --> 00:17:41,438
United States are.

467
00:17:42,488 --> 00:17:43,206
Not very smart.

468
00:17:44,562 --> 00:17:46,577
In terms of their conceptual understanding

469
00:17:47,194 --> 00:17:48,949
of the document that's supposed to be protecting.

470
00:17:49,347 --> 00:17:49,586
Right?

471
00:17:52,554 --> 00:17:54,494
So here we have a situation where

472
00:17:55,835 --> 00:17:56,335
collect

473
00:17:56,714 --> 00:17:57,595
in its most

474
00:17:59,434 --> 00:18:02,882
consistent forms, if you will. Communism fascism are

475
00:18:02,882 --> 00:18:03,280
demolished.

476
00:18:04,077 --> 00:18:05,692
But the west doesn't really know

477
00:18:06,148 --> 00:18:07,501
why they were demolished.

478
00:18:08,059 --> 00:18:09,891
It doesn't really know what it is,

479
00:18:10,384 --> 00:18:13,657
what it stands for, what values it represents.

480
00:18:14,296 --> 00:18:16,211
It doesn't see the stomach a link with

481
00:18:16,211 --> 00:18:18,686
the enlightenment and what those ideas that came

482
00:18:18,686 --> 00:18:21,420
out of there that are driving whatever good

483
00:18:21,420 --> 00:18:22,460
is still in the west.

484
00:18:22,940 --> 00:18:23,180
They...

485
00:18:23,980 --> 00:18:25,420
They're still doing it. We're still acting on

486
00:18:25,420 --> 00:18:27,660
it. Right? Still entrepreneurs. They're still science.

487
00:18:29,113 --> 00:18:30,229
To a large extent. Right?

488
00:18:31,185 --> 00:18:34,053
And we're still pursuing happiness somewhat, a little

489
00:18:34,053 --> 00:18:36,922
bit. People out. There seeking self help and

490
00:18:36,922 --> 00:18:37,480
all this stuff.

491
00:18:39,008 --> 00:18:41,316
But there's no intellectual understanding of any of

492
00:18:41,316 --> 00:18:41,475
that.

493
00:18:42,669 --> 00:18:45,216
So this the week... The the the the

494
00:18:45,216 --> 00:18:45,932
the the west,

495
00:18:46,584 --> 00:18:49,775
to extent there's Western civilization is weakening, and

496
00:18:49,775 --> 00:18:50,891
it's constantly weakening.

497
00:18:53,124 --> 00:18:55,517
But the forces that are anti enlightenment are

498
00:18:55,517 --> 00:18:55,996
still out there.

499
00:18:56,809 --> 00:18:57,688
They haven't gone away.

500
00:18:59,126 --> 00:19:00,006
The week could 2.

501
00:19:00,884 --> 00:19:01,624
There's no

502
00:19:02,083 --> 00:19:04,022
integrated idea like communism

503
00:19:04,401 --> 00:19:04,560
anymore.

504
00:19:05,534 --> 00:19:07,365
It's like this flaky walk stuff.

505
00:19:08,161 --> 00:19:10,230
Right? And and and nobody really likes and

506
00:19:10,230 --> 00:19:12,141
there's no no real understanding of how we

507
00:19:12,141 --> 00:19:13,096
need integrates into everything.

508
00:19:13,668 --> 00:19:15,178
But people do it out of a sense

509
00:19:15,178 --> 00:19:18,619
of guilt because it's associated with certain things

510
00:19:18,756 --> 00:19:20,584
that are bad in the past on racism

511
00:19:20,584 --> 00:19:22,910
and so on. But but they don't understand

512
00:19:22,910 --> 00:19:24,903
it. They don't have a passion around it

513
00:19:24,903 --> 00:19:26,977
except for small minority. And that's why every

514
00:19:26,977 --> 00:19:28,413
time it comes up for a vote. It's

515
00:19:28,413 --> 00:19:28,971
voted down.

516
00:19:29,769 --> 00:19:30,886
Majority of people don't like it.

517
00:19:32,339 --> 00:19:32,839
And

518
00:19:33,460 --> 00:19:35,059
you know, so you've got this this the

519
00:19:35,059 --> 00:19:37,079
left is is churning

520
00:19:37,539 --> 00:19:38,519
anti western

521
00:19:39,380 --> 00:19:41,708
stuff. But it's not geared towards any kind

522
00:19:41,708 --> 00:19:42,208
of

523
00:19:42,904 --> 00:19:45,853
grand ideology that integrates it all like communism

524
00:19:45,853 --> 00:19:46,092
was.

525
00:19:46,730 --> 00:19:48,028
And even on the right

526
00:19:48,579 --> 00:19:51,388
at best what they have, the best

527
00:19:52,163 --> 00:19:52,663
integrating

528
00:19:53,119 --> 00:19:55,190
source they have on the right is what.

529
00:19:56,384 --> 00:19:56,703
What's it?

530
00:19:57,833 --> 00:19:58,468
Is religion.

531
00:19:59,262 --> 00:20:01,270
So they have to go way back

532
00:20:01,803 --> 00:20:04,209
to before the enlightenment to bring forward

533
00:20:04,820 --> 00:20:05,320
their

534
00:20:05,773 --> 00:20:06,908
source for

535
00:20:07,219 --> 00:20:09,372
for the for the anti enlightenment ideas.

536
00:20:12,004 --> 00:20:14,876
But they are growing in strength because the

537
00:20:14,876 --> 00:20:15,913
people advocating,

538
00:20:17,204 --> 00:20:17,704
for

539
00:20:18,639 --> 00:20:20,712
enlightenment ideas don't know what they're advocating for.

540
00:20:21,669 --> 00:20:24,061
There's a weakness, a fundamental weakness. So even

541
00:20:24,061 --> 00:20:25,916
though our enemies, I think a week

542
00:20:26,309 --> 00:20:26,948
pathetic really.

543
00:20:27,907 --> 00:20:29,185
I mean, the left is pathetic.

544
00:20:29,905 --> 00:20:31,843
I mean, Long gone is the scientific

545
00:20:33,181 --> 00:20:35,610
views of marx that actually had a system

546
00:20:35,667 --> 00:20:38,612
and, you know, a whole philosophy and a

547
00:20:38,612 --> 00:20:39,328
view of man.

548
00:20:39,965 --> 00:20:43,092
Now it's just completely hap has a disintegrate

549
00:20:44,436 --> 00:20:45,547
it some makes extent nonsense.

550
00:20:46,738 --> 00:20:47,611
And on the right,

551
00:20:48,643 --> 00:20:51,262
Gun is any kind of again, system and

552
00:20:51,262 --> 00:20:53,924
and even even an idea of abs state,

553
00:20:54,143 --> 00:20:55,661
all they have is religion.

554
00:20:57,259 --> 00:20:58,377
So what do you have today?

555
00:21:00,787 --> 00:21:01,422
Yeah putin.

556
00:21:02,374 --> 00:21:02,930
A thug.

557
00:21:04,438 --> 00:21:04,994
A thug.

558
00:21:06,026 --> 00:21:08,089
Who doesn't stand for? What's the ideology of

559
00:21:08,089 --> 00:21:08,407
putin?

560
00:21:09,614 --> 00:21:12,086
I mean, this nationalism, but where does... Where

561
00:21:12,086 --> 00:21:14,319
does he get the nationalism from? Is it

562
00:21:14,319 --> 00:21:15,138
is this some

563
00:21:15,675 --> 00:21:17,669
core philosophical. I mean, if you ever listen

564
00:21:17,669 --> 00:21:19,319
to Doug, which is 1 of the philosophy

565
00:21:19,439 --> 00:21:21,753
fist... I mean, it's J gi groove. I

566
00:21:21,753 --> 00:21:22,471
mean, it's nonsense.

567
00:21:23,428 --> 00:21:25,284
It's hawking back to mystic.

568
00:21:26,954 --> 00:21:29,990
There's no set of ideas here. There's no

569
00:21:29,990 --> 00:21:30,490
philosophy.

570
00:21:31,028 --> 00:21:32,786
There's... I mean, there's a philosophy, but it's

571
00:21:32,786 --> 00:21:33,585
kind of an implicit.

572
00:21:34,315 --> 00:21:34,815
Mystical

573
00:21:35,346 --> 00:21:36,854
ancient philosophy. This is why when he sits

574
00:21:36,854 --> 00:21:37,488
down with Tucker.

575
00:21:38,837 --> 00:21:41,894
He doesn't articulate. Here's my view of how

576
00:21:42,033 --> 00:21:44,909
the wall should work. This, No. He starts

577
00:21:44,909 --> 00:21:46,826
telling him stories about what the Russians were

578
00:21:46,826 --> 00:21:47,726
at 800

579
00:21:48,119 --> 00:21:50,113
And and you know, what what what the

580
00:21:50,272 --> 00:21:51,787
Woo were and the ky of and this

581
00:21:51,787 --> 00:21:54,281
and that. Who care... I mean, it's interesting

582
00:21:54,738 --> 00:21:56,492
if if you did it objectively, which he

583
00:21:56,492 --> 00:21:56,732
doesn't.

584
00:21:57,624 --> 00:21:59,462
But he he has no... All he has

585
00:21:59,462 --> 00:22:00,022
his history.

586
00:22:01,061 --> 00:22:02,259
All he has is mystic.

587
00:22:03,538 --> 00:22:05,696
All he has is a vague notion of

588
00:22:05,856 --> 00:22:06,575
I hate the west.

589
00:22:07,468 --> 00:22:10,809
I'm anti reason, anti individual, anti political freedom.

590
00:22:11,526 --> 00:22:12,481
He can't say that,

591
00:22:13,833 --> 00:22:15,823
but that's all he's proposing.

592
00:22:16,874 --> 00:22:17,933
Or if you take

593
00:22:19,511 --> 00:22:22,068
Hamas. Right? I'm supposed to do israel. Right?

594
00:22:22,308 --> 00:22:23,187
I think it was on the list.

595
00:22:25,119 --> 00:22:26,315
I mean, what do they have? What do

596
00:22:26,315 --> 00:22:26,953
they proposing?

597
00:22:28,150 --> 00:22:28,650
Mystic,

598
00:22:29,506 --> 00:22:30,543
An ancient religion,

599
00:22:31,260 --> 00:22:33,733
a religion that never was reformed, never went

600
00:22:33,733 --> 00:22:34,531
through an enlightenment.

601
00:22:35,183 --> 00:22:38,785
Never was modified... Just Ji. This is about

602
00:22:39,081 --> 00:22:41,626
establishing a global ji. This is about establishing.

603
00:22:42,119 --> 00:22:44,352
S law the world. That's what motivates. That's

604
00:22:44,352 --> 00:22:46,346
what g come off. If you read their

605
00:22:46,346 --> 00:22:48,420
actual papers, they don't care about, a state.

606
00:22:48,659 --> 00:22:50,414
They don't believe in states. They believe in

607
00:22:50,414 --> 00:22:51,871
a 1 big

608
00:22:52,184 --> 00:22:53,065
ji hottest world.

609
00:22:54,424 --> 00:22:56,664
They're part of the Muslim Brotherhood, which is

610
00:22:56,664 --> 00:22:59,305
a international organization, the believes in taking over

611
00:22:59,305 --> 00:23:01,393
the world, They take this stuff seriously.

612
00:23:01,872 --> 00:23:03,227
But again, it's a primitive religion.

613
00:23:04,502 --> 00:23:06,574
There's nothing more there than primitive religion.

614
00:23:10,417 --> 00:23:12,012
Do I have to talk about Trump was

615
00:23:12,012 --> 00:23:14,325
on the list. But look, you know, look

616
00:23:14,325 --> 00:23:16,718
at our political candidates in America. Ronny right

617
00:23:16,718 --> 00:23:17,595
now Trump and Biden.

618
00:23:18,409 --> 00:23:19,288
What do they represent?

619
00:23:21,444 --> 00:23:21,764
Nothing.

620
00:23:22,722 --> 00:23:24,081
I think is pretty much right?

621
00:23:25,132 --> 00:23:28,250
Right. Again, Trump represents some hawk

622
00:23:28,702 --> 00:23:31,557
to to to some national vague nationalism.

623
00:23:32,605 --> 00:23:34,832
Which is really far into Americans. It's not

624
00:23:34,832 --> 00:23:37,240
exactly clear what it actually means. There's no

625
00:23:37,536 --> 00:23:39,444
thousand year history that he can go to

626
00:23:39,444 --> 00:23:41,512
and there's no... So so he just... It's

627
00:23:41,512 --> 00:23:41,884
it's

628
00:23:42,561 --> 00:23:45,190
it's just promising the popular, you know, it's

629
00:23:45,190 --> 00:23:47,659
pop in the sense of figuring out what

630
00:23:47,659 --> 00:23:49,650
gets people excited in they cup and seeing

631
00:23:49,650 --> 00:23:49,809
that.

632
00:23:51,018 --> 00:23:52,530
And he'll change his mind like that if

633
00:23:52,530 --> 00:23:54,520
the audience responds differently to what he says,

634
00:23:55,077 --> 00:23:56,293
because he stands for

635
00:23:56,668 --> 00:23:57,168
absolutely

636
00:23:57,544 --> 00:23:57,782
nothing.

637
00:23:58,751 --> 00:24:01,452
There's no ideas this. There's no ideology. And

638
00:24:01,452 --> 00:24:02,484
what is Biden stand for?

639
00:24:04,231 --> 00:24:04,549
Nothing.

640
00:24:05,105 --> 00:24:05,979
What's that? I didn't hear.

641
00:24:08,933 --> 00:24:10,045
Oh, dementia. Yeah.

642
00:24:13,875 --> 00:24:15,894
You know, the funny thing is Biden is

643
00:24:15,954 --> 00:24:18,515
that, if you if you go back and

644
00:24:18,515 --> 00:24:19,795
watch him when he was a senator,

645
00:24:20,355 --> 00:24:21,954
He was just as inc coherent.

646
00:24:23,009 --> 00:24:25,009
And just as ba as he is now.

647
00:24:25,169 --> 00:24:26,929
So I don't know that it's dementia as

648
00:24:26,929 --> 00:24:28,130
much as it's Biden.

649
00:24:28,609 --> 00:24:31,089
He was never that coherent to begin with.

650
00:24:31,744 --> 00:24:34,562
A but, again, he represents nothing. There's no

651
00:24:34,781 --> 00:24:37,018
ideology there. Again, there's an acceptance a kind

652
00:24:37,018 --> 00:24:39,256
of mixed economy of neither hear nor there

653
00:24:39,256 --> 00:24:40,455
or a little bit of everything.

654
00:24:40,788 --> 00:24:41,525
A vague

655
00:24:42,214 --> 00:24:44,457
notion of what pro democracy, but

656
00:24:44,908 --> 00:24:45,224
nothing.

657
00:24:45,938 --> 00:24:46,651
Nothing really.

658
00:24:47,934 --> 00:24:48,732
But what do they want?

659
00:24:49,848 --> 00:24:52,560
They clearly all these forces. What are they

660
00:24:52,560 --> 00:24:52,799
against?

661
00:24:54,794 --> 00:24:56,708
Against each other kind of and they... Yet

662
00:24:56,708 --> 00:24:59,030
they agree on so much? What they're really

663
00:24:59,030 --> 00:24:59,847
against is

664
00:25:00,459 --> 00:25:01,014
the enlightenment.

665
00:25:01,808 --> 00:25:03,554
What they're really against this reason,

666
00:25:05,459 --> 00:25:05,959
individual,

667
00:25:06,903 --> 00:25:09,289
and and true political liberty, individual rights.

668
00:25:11,118 --> 00:25:13,844
But notice that the the forces against

669
00:25:14,458 --> 00:25:15,809
a kind of bubbling idiots.

670
00:25:17,736 --> 00:25:20,924
But that's who dominates our political landscape? I

671
00:25:20,924 --> 00:25:22,838
mean, what does European Union stand for?

672
00:25:23,794 --> 00:25:24,193
Nothing.

673
00:25:25,642 --> 00:25:28,427
Kind of a a vague notion of we

674
00:25:28,427 --> 00:25:31,052
want to maintain political liberty, but we don't

675
00:25:31,052 --> 00:25:32,723
really know what that is. And suddenly there's

676
00:25:32,723 --> 00:25:34,970
no concept of individual rights. And we certainly

677
00:25:34,970 --> 00:25:36,830
don't want any individual and

678
00:25:40,730 --> 00:25:42,970
so what you have today is nothing gross

679
00:25:42,970 --> 00:25:43,210
nothing.

680
00:25:44,823 --> 00:25:47,061
And the more consistent party is the party

681
00:25:47,061 --> 00:25:49,459
that is willing to use more force because

682
00:25:49,459 --> 00:25:52,575
everybody is using Cog. That makes economy uses

683
00:25:52,655 --> 00:25:52,975
C.

684
00:25:53,707 --> 00:25:55,774
Cog is acceptable. So now it's just a

685
00:25:55,774 --> 00:25:57,523
question of who's willing to use more force?

686
00:25:58,080 --> 00:26:00,385
Who's willing to stand up and use more?

687
00:26:03,184 --> 00:26:04,882
I mean, 1 of the things that makes

688
00:26:05,898 --> 00:26:07,356
the crisis in Ukraine

689
00:26:07,734 --> 00:26:09,091
or the war in Ukraine, not a crisis.

690
00:26:09,331 --> 00:26:11,965
And the warren gaza are so important right

691
00:26:11,965 --> 00:26:12,045
now.

692
00:26:13,579 --> 00:26:15,339
Is it in both cases.

693
00:26:16,299 --> 00:26:17,119
The enemy

694
00:26:18,059 --> 00:26:18,559
is

695
00:26:18,940 --> 00:26:19,440
clearly

696
00:26:20,059 --> 00:26:20,380
evil.

697
00:26:21,993 --> 00:26:23,109
In both cases,

698
00:26:24,226 --> 00:26:26,800
Hamas and Russia have dedicated

699
00:26:27,177 --> 00:26:30,447
themselves to the destruction of Western civilization. They

700
00:26:30,447 --> 00:26:31,266
are clearly

701
00:26:31,897 --> 00:26:35,026
anti enlightenment. They clearly want to destroy whatever

702
00:26:35,083 --> 00:26:36,597
remnants of enlightenment is.

703
00:26:37,871 --> 00:26:39,624
And as flawed as Ukraine is.

704
00:26:41,074 --> 00:26:43,231
And as florida's as Israel is, israel less

705
00:26:43,231 --> 00:26:44,350
flawed, I think than Ukraine.

706
00:26:45,149 --> 00:26:47,067
As fraud as Europe is. As flawed as

707
00:26:47,307 --> 00:26:47,787
America is,

708
00:26:49,798 --> 00:26:52,344
All of this still have those remnants of

709
00:26:52,344 --> 00:26:54,731
the enlightenment. In all of those places, they

710
00:26:54,731 --> 00:26:57,697
still hope of who is e of re

711
00:26:57,754 --> 00:26:58,254
engaging

712
00:26:58,804 --> 00:27:00,714
those ideas of the enlightenment.

713
00:27:01,589 --> 00:27:03,579
The reason we should care about what happens

714
00:27:03,579 --> 00:27:05,966
in Israel is truly in israel, what's happening

715
00:27:05,966 --> 00:27:08,555
is you've got the remnants of Western

716
00:27:09,013 --> 00:27:11,806
civilization fighting against barbarian who wanna destroy it.

717
00:27:12,843 --> 00:27:14,933
And you've got the same thing. In Ukraine.

718
00:27:15,412 --> 00:27:16,710
Ukraine was just turning

719
00:27:17,088 --> 00:27:19,881
towards Europe, just turning towards an enlightenment. Just

720
00:27:19,881 --> 00:27:22,116
turning towards more reason, more individual ism.

721
00:27:23,009 --> 00:27:25,806
Again, as makes been as shallow as those

722
00:27:25,806 --> 00:27:28,763
concepts on the west today. As... And that's

723
00:27:28,763 --> 00:27:30,601
the reason why Russia invaded. This no in

724
00:27:30,601 --> 00:27:33,192
my view, there's no question. That Russia invaded

725
00:27:33,330 --> 00:27:35,483
because Ky was turning more western.

726
00:27:36,361 --> 00:27:38,275
Not because it was gonna light itself with

727
00:27:38,275 --> 00:27:40,429
nato, but because it was gonna lie itself

728
00:27:40,429 --> 00:27:41,067
with a west,

729
00:27:42,279 --> 00:27:44,436
in every aspect. And if you if you've

730
00:27:44,436 --> 00:27:45,795
been to care of if you weren't care

731
00:27:45,795 --> 00:27:47,393
before the war, you could see it. You

732
00:27:47,393 --> 00:27:48,532
could see the young people

733
00:27:49,071 --> 00:27:51,563
striving to become more European and in that

734
00:27:51,563 --> 00:27:52,921
sense more enlightenment.

735
00:27:53,880 --> 00:27:55,099
And that's what

736
00:27:56,037 --> 00:27:57,795
Moscow could not allow to happen.

737
00:27:59,634 --> 00:28:01,085
So what you see today

738
00:28:01,932 --> 00:28:04,230
in the world out there is very much

739
00:28:04,230 --> 00:28:06,070
the same battle that we saw in the

740
00:28:06,070 --> 00:28:08,217
twentieth century. Just a continuation. Just the forces

741
00:28:08,217 --> 00:28:10,125
now both on both sides the weaker,

742
00:28:11,317 --> 00:28:11,556
intellectually,

743
00:28:12,192 --> 00:28:12,669
philosophically.

744
00:28:13,797 --> 00:28:15,407
And less committed to the battle

745
00:28:15,859 --> 00:28:16,359
because,

746
00:28:16,732 --> 00:28:18,184
I mean, the reality is

747
00:28:18,716 --> 00:28:20,858
that Israel could end the war in Gaza

748
00:28:20,858 --> 00:28:21,596
in days

749
00:28:22,540 --> 00:28:23,915
The reality is

750
00:28:24,289 --> 00:28:26,777
that if Nato had supplied and the western

751
00:28:26,833 --> 00:28:29,138
supplied the weapons Ukraine needed, they could have

752
00:28:29,138 --> 00:28:30,013
ended the war there.

753
00:28:31,939 --> 00:28:34,416
The only reason these was ongoing is because

754
00:28:34,416 --> 00:28:35,875
our own lack of commitment

755
00:28:36,334 --> 00:28:37,234
to actually

756
00:28:37,853 --> 00:28:38,353
defend

757
00:28:38,812 --> 00:28:39,051
ourselves.

758
00:28:41,541 --> 00:28:45,298
The reason these wars ongoing is because

759
00:28:45,990 --> 00:28:47,443
of the weakness

760
00:28:48,388 --> 00:28:51,275
that the West has in its own ideas

761
00:28:51,332 --> 00:28:53,718
and its willingness to defend those ideas. I

762
00:28:53,718 --> 00:28:54,616
mean, imagine

763
00:28:55,404 --> 00:28:57,875
Israel fighting like the allies fought in World

764
00:28:57,875 --> 00:28:58,273
war 2.

765
00:28:59,309 --> 00:29:00,824
I mean, there's no... I mean, it wouldn't

766
00:29:00,824 --> 00:29:02,179
survive more than a few days in Gaza.

767
00:29:02,498 --> 00:29:02,578
Right?

768
00:29:03,948 --> 00:29:05,702
But nobody's willing to do that anymore.

769
00:29:07,218 --> 00:29:07,718
So

770
00:29:08,732 --> 00:29:10,429
we have 2 weakened enemies

771
00:29:10,965 --> 00:29:12,321
enlightenment versus anti enlightenment.

772
00:29:13,454 --> 00:29:15,372
And as much as we criticize own governments,

773
00:29:15,451 --> 00:29:17,789
and I'm assuming here. Everybody is from

774
00:29:18,168 --> 00:29:20,645
decent countries. Right? I think. Trying to think.

775
00:29:20,885 --> 00:29:21,858
Yep. Pretty much.

776
00:29:23,054 --> 00:29:25,287
Not no... That's right. We've got somebody from

777
00:29:25,367 --> 00:29:27,441
Hong Kong here. Because I haven't mentioned China

778
00:29:27,441 --> 00:29:27,521
yet.

779
00:29:28,717 --> 00:29:29,515
But but, yeah.

780
00:29:31,762 --> 00:29:34,093
There is this constant battle between

781
00:29:35,105 --> 00:29:36,299
enlightenment and anti enlightenment.

782
00:29:37,333 --> 00:29:39,801
And it's ongoing. It's been going on since

783
00:29:39,801 --> 00:29:40,676
the enlightenment happened.

784
00:29:41,169 --> 00:29:43,347
And the reaction every forces of religion

785
00:29:44,046 --> 00:29:45,165
rose up against it,

786
00:29:46,363 --> 00:29:49,160
and secular their anti enlightenment views,

787
00:29:50,054 --> 00:29:52,209
and have been coming at the enlightenment since

788
00:29:52,209 --> 00:29:52,369
then.

789
00:29:53,646 --> 00:29:56,382
And, you know, China is another example of

790
00:29:56,919 --> 00:29:58,835
this anti anti enlightenment force. Right?

791
00:29:59,649 --> 00:30:02,765
This anti western force? In the name of

792
00:30:02,765 --> 00:30:04,923
what? What is what is the Chinese regime

793
00:30:04,923 --> 00:30:05,083
today,

794
00:30:06,361 --> 00:30:07,400
consolidating power,

795
00:30:08,053 --> 00:30:08,529
and

796
00:30:08,926 --> 00:30:11,227
and rep pressing its people and taking over

797
00:30:11,307 --> 00:30:13,052
Hong Kong, What what is it doing in

798
00:30:13,052 --> 00:30:14,957
the name of? What ideology is it doing

799
00:30:14,957 --> 00:30:15,592
it in the name of?

800
00:30:17,275 --> 00:30:18,889
Kind of a vague nationalism.

801
00:30:20,934 --> 00:30:22,764
Well, it's not even imperialist. They don't really,

802
00:30:22,923 --> 00:30:24,928
you know, but It's like this vague. They

803
00:30:24,928 --> 00:30:26,998
they they they suggest a link to to

804
00:30:27,077 --> 00:30:29,306
Marx. They wanna pretend that there's some linked

805
00:30:29,306 --> 00:30:31,717
to marx. There's xi young jinping

806
00:30:32,029 --> 00:30:34,670
thought. The study now in schools, nobody knows

807
00:30:34,670 --> 00:30:37,309
what exactly any of that means. When mao

808
00:30:37,309 --> 00:30:38,990
thought was studied everybody knew what it was.

809
00:30:39,150 --> 00:30:40,837
It was a It was a it was

810
00:30:40,837 --> 00:30:42,190
clear cut communism

811
00:30:42,667 --> 00:30:45,531
This is kind of vague and unspecified weak.

812
00:30:47,848 --> 00:30:48,744
But China's

813
00:30:50,226 --> 00:30:51,756
everybody's a afraid of it because

814
00:30:52,365 --> 00:30:53,713
we don't know what we stand for.

815
00:30:54,682 --> 00:30:55,957
We don't know what we stand for.

816
00:30:58,188 --> 00:30:59,804
So the battle we're in

817
00:31:00,180 --> 00:31:01,477
is really

818
00:31:02,190 --> 00:31:05,150
a battle to save the good that we

819
00:31:05,150 --> 00:31:05,970
still have

820
00:31:06,430 --> 00:31:07,809
and to make it better

821
00:31:08,430 --> 00:31:10,830
because we know much better is possible.

822
00:31:12,038 --> 00:31:14,100
As good as things are in America's as

823
00:31:14,100 --> 00:31:15,608
good as things are in Europe as good

824
00:31:15,608 --> 00:31:17,829
as our individual lives are. They could be

825
00:31:17,829 --> 00:31:19,440
so much better both personally

826
00:31:19,828 --> 00:31:21,968
as we integrate these ideas into our lives,

827
00:31:22,444 --> 00:31:23,657
but also politically

828
00:31:24,109 --> 00:31:25,798
as these ideas spread

829
00:31:26,328 --> 00:31:26,804
throughout the world.

830
00:31:27,534 --> 00:31:30,324
But 1 way to conceptualize this is to

831
00:31:30,324 --> 00:31:31,998
think about any in terms of these ideas

832
00:31:31,998 --> 00:31:32,716
of the enlightenment.

833
00:31:36,318 --> 00:31:37,775
The enlightenment has to win

834
00:31:38,870 --> 00:31:39,588
for us to win.

835
00:31:40,864 --> 00:31:43,119
We are in that sense objective,

836
00:31:43,735 --> 00:31:45,625
those objective out there that are...

837
00:31:46,224 --> 00:31:48,620
That are fighting to bring these ideas into

838
00:31:48,620 --> 00:31:49,100
the culture,

839
00:31:50,378 --> 00:31:52,455
a fighting for the ideas of enlightenment.

840
00:31:53,345 --> 00:31:55,333
The ideas of reason, individual,

841
00:31:55,889 --> 00:31:56,525
political liberty,

842
00:31:57,240 --> 00:31:57,638
individual rights.

843
00:31:58,830 --> 00:32:00,182
That's what this is all about.

844
00:32:02,752 --> 00:32:03,631
Enemies are pretty weak.

845
00:32:04,910 --> 00:32:05,949
It's all like the strong.

846
00:32:07,387 --> 00:32:09,225
What is the concept that I ran uses

847
00:32:09,225 --> 00:32:09,725
to

848
00:32:10,200 --> 00:32:11,320
describe what's going on today.

849
00:32:12,200 --> 00:32:14,519
In terms of why the enemies of the

850
00:32:14,519 --> 00:32:15,400
good are winning.

851
00:32:16,839 --> 00:32:17,559
Sanction or the victim.

852
00:32:19,094 --> 00:32:21,007
They can't win without us sanction them.

853
00:32:22,283 --> 00:32:24,138
Putin can't win without the west's

854
00:32:24,515 --> 00:32:25,015
weakness

855
00:32:25,711 --> 00:32:26,907
and to some extent.

856
00:32:27,799 --> 00:32:28,759
I tucker a carlson,

857
00:32:29,480 --> 00:32:30,519
grove before him.

858
00:32:32,440 --> 00:32:33,579
Putin can't win

859
00:32:33,960 --> 00:32:35,960
on the basis of his own strength, he

860
00:32:35,960 --> 00:32:36,599
has no strength.

861
00:32:37,654 --> 00:32:40,955
Hamas cannot win on the basis of their

862
00:32:41,015 --> 00:32:43,174
strength. They have no strength. They can only

863
00:32:43,174 --> 00:32:45,743
win through Israel's weakness. They can only win

864
00:32:45,743 --> 00:32:48,366
through Biden constantly telling Israel to stop.

865
00:32:49,081 --> 00:32:51,625
The west constantly telling to Israel now, the

866
00:32:51,625 --> 00:32:53,951
risk is that if Israel actually execute on

867
00:32:53,951 --> 00:32:54,351
the wall,

868
00:32:55,229 --> 00:32:58,023
they will be declared what, war criminals and

869
00:32:58,023 --> 00:33:00,418
anytime they step in his... In in Europe,

870
00:33:00,578 --> 00:33:01,296
they'll be arrested.

871
00:33:02,509 --> 00:33:04,190
That is what gives power.

872
00:33:04,990 --> 00:33:07,390
It's out sanction that gives them power. It's

873
00:33:07,390 --> 00:33:07,890
out

874
00:33:09,881 --> 00:33:11,493
inability to support fully

875
00:33:13,693 --> 00:33:14,193
outside

876
00:33:14,964 --> 00:33:16,020
the side of

877
00:33:16,632 --> 00:33:16,790
civilization.

878
00:33:18,555 --> 00:33:21,283
So I think if we can conceptualize what,

879
00:33:22,772 --> 00:33:23,090
you know,

880
00:33:24,045 --> 00:33:26,591
On described today, you know, we're trying to

881
00:33:26,591 --> 00:33:29,490
train new intellectual. We're trying to get object

882
00:33:30,579 --> 00:33:31,611
and then intellectual.

883
00:33:32,803 --> 00:33:33,041
Well,

884
00:33:33,677 --> 00:33:35,821
the war, the battle that we're trying to

885
00:33:35,821 --> 00:33:37,449
train those intellectual 4

886
00:33:37,985 --> 00:33:40,317
is about to save Western

887
00:33:40,694 --> 00:33:43,323
civilization. It's about to save the enlightenment.

888
00:33:44,453 --> 00:33:45,271
Life is

889
00:33:45,965 --> 00:33:47,715
the best that it's ever been, and it

890
00:33:47,715 --> 00:33:49,068
might be the best that it's ever been

891
00:33:49,068 --> 00:33:50,022
for a while still.

892
00:33:50,818 --> 00:33:52,807
But at some point, it will not sustain

893
00:33:52,807 --> 00:33:52,966
itself.

894
00:33:54,097 --> 00:33:56,032
At some point, the momentum

895
00:33:56,410 --> 00:33:59,679
will stop. At some point, if somebody doesn't

896
00:33:59,679 --> 00:34:01,593
defend it, the enlightenment will disappear.

897
00:34:02,963 --> 00:34:05,050
And the forces defending the lay

898
00:34:05,582 --> 00:34:06,375
are very weak.

899
00:34:08,201 --> 00:34:09,470
And here I wanna come to me lee.

900
00:34:09,708 --> 00:34:09,946
Right?

901
00:34:11,628 --> 00:34:14,251
Mille who's now the president of Argentina surprisingly.

902
00:34:14,727 --> 00:34:15,227
Surprisingly.

903
00:34:16,476 --> 00:34:17,985
Has being kind of a beacon of hope

904
00:34:17,985 --> 00:34:19,575
and a and a beak of lightness in

905
00:34:19,575 --> 00:34:22,155
a sense. Right? Here's a guy who was

906
00:34:22,210 --> 00:34:23,662
advocating for shrinking government

907
00:34:24,273 --> 00:34:25,487
gave a speech or,

908
00:34:25,860 --> 00:34:27,447
you know, in many respects and an amazing

909
00:34:27,447 --> 00:34:29,688
speech. The world economic forum about the contrast

910
00:34:29,688 --> 00:34:32,234
between collect activism and individual ism, how it's

911
00:34:32,234 --> 00:34:34,382
all about individual and collect activism is evil,

912
00:34:34,620 --> 00:34:36,947
that the I, here's a guy who who

913
00:34:36,947 --> 00:34:37,447
is

914
00:34:39,180 --> 00:34:39,680
completely

915
00:34:40,455 --> 00:34:41,891
trying at least to,

916
00:34:42,528 --> 00:34:43,587
completely reform

917
00:34:44,699 --> 00:34:48,699
the Argentinian economy and argentinian political world and

918
00:34:48,699 --> 00:34:49,420
political culture.

919
00:34:52,231 --> 00:34:52,731
And

920
00:34:53,422 --> 00:34:55,489
I hope you succeeds. I mean, I really

921
00:34:55,489 --> 00:34:56,522
hope you succeeds. Right?

922
00:34:58,429 --> 00:34:59,883
But the reality is

923
00:35:01,146 --> 00:35:01,646
that

924
00:35:02,656 --> 00:35:03,451
he's too early.

925
00:35:05,279 --> 00:35:06,074
He's too early.

926
00:35:06,869 --> 00:35:07,902
The world's not ready.

927
00:35:08,393 --> 00:35:09,425
For that kind of change.

928
00:35:09,981 --> 00:35:11,490
And in a sense, he's not ready for

929
00:35:11,490 --> 00:35:11,648
it.

930
00:35:13,792 --> 00:35:15,324
He's still a mixture

931
00:35:15,697 --> 00:35:16,992
of a lot of good

932
00:35:17,859 --> 00:35:19,617
but a lot of confusion and a lot

933
00:35:19,617 --> 00:35:20,655
of bad ideas.

934
00:35:22,812 --> 00:35:25,062
His talk at World Economic firm was was

935
00:35:25,062 --> 00:35:26,729
pretty good, but when he comes to, his

936
00:35:26,729 --> 00:35:28,793
moral defensive capitalism which you try to provide.

937
00:35:29,586 --> 00:35:30,618
It was pretty collect,

938
00:35:32,285 --> 00:35:32,682
utilitarian.

939
00:35:34,369 --> 00:35:36,210
Right? It's good for society. Capitalism is good

940
00:35:36,210 --> 00:35:37,890
because the poor New bill. Well. I mean,

941
00:35:38,050 --> 00:35:40,289
that's true. That's not why capitalism is good.

942
00:35:41,422 --> 00:35:43,811
That's not what the morality of capitalism is,

943
00:35:44,130 --> 00:35:46,597
wilde of capitalism is the freedom of the

944
00:35:46,597 --> 00:35:48,110
individual to live his life based on his

945
00:35:48,110 --> 00:35:48,667
own judgment.

946
00:35:49,400 --> 00:35:50,699
In pursuit of his own values

947
00:35:51,239 --> 00:35:52,839
in pursuit ultimately leave his own happiness.

948
00:35:53,320 --> 00:35:54,679
Capitalism allows to that. Liberty.

949
00:35:55,800 --> 00:35:57,239
But me can't go there.

950
00:35:59,255 --> 00:36:01,515
He can go there because he's not yet

951
00:36:01,655 --> 00:36:04,695
completely committed to these ideas of individual and

952
00:36:04,695 --> 00:36:06,855
to these ideas of ego ism of selfish.

953
00:36:07,588 --> 00:36:09,023
Nes of self interest.

954
00:36:11,574 --> 00:36:14,125
So he can criticize collect activism, but what's

955
00:36:14,125 --> 00:36:14,864
the alternative

956
00:36:15,974 --> 00:36:17,335
The enlightenment is still weak.

957
00:36:19,255 --> 00:36:20,315
It's still not

958
00:36:20,934 --> 00:36:23,494
ready for, you know, the the full blown

959
00:36:23,494 --> 00:36:25,668
is not ready for me. You know, for

960
00:36:25,668 --> 00:36:26,388
for prime time?

961
00:36:28,465 --> 00:36:28,965
And

962
00:36:29,344 --> 00:36:31,582
if he did say it all, would have

963
00:36:31,582 --> 00:36:32,222
got elected?

964
00:36:34,314 --> 00:36:36,866
I don't know. Catholic Country Argentina. I I'm

965
00:36:36,946 --> 00:36:38,222
I'm I'm not... I don't think he would.

966
00:36:38,541 --> 00:36:39,977
Now and I and I don't saying he

967
00:36:39,977 --> 00:36:41,732
held back anything, because I think he says

968
00:36:41,732 --> 00:36:43,486
what he believes. I don't I think he's

969
00:36:43,486 --> 00:36:43,806
just mixed.

970
00:36:44,538 --> 00:36:45,814
If you listen to his

971
00:36:47,329 --> 00:36:50,200
seat pack talk, Cpa is a conservative political

972
00:36:50,200 --> 00:36:52,273
action committee, which is a big conference in

973
00:36:52,432 --> 00:36:55,637
Washington Dc. Trump spoke at and Mille cat.

974
00:36:56,833 --> 00:37:00,044
He spent, like 15 minutes on why abortion

975
00:37:00,102 --> 00:37:01,617
is a left wing conspiracy.

976
00:37:02,828 --> 00:37:05,300
To to to to reduce the number of

977
00:37:05,300 --> 00:37:06,495
human beings on the planet.

978
00:37:08,887 --> 00:37:10,902
Talk about missing the point

979
00:37:11,454 --> 00:37:14,485
and about individual missing individual and missing the

980
00:37:14,485 --> 00:37:16,638
concept of rights. I mean, it was a

981
00:37:16,638 --> 00:37:17,037
disaster.

982
00:37:17,675 --> 00:37:20,227
It literally was the left has this. They

983
00:37:20,227 --> 00:37:21,438
don't want a lot of people which is

984
00:37:21,438 --> 00:37:21,598
true,

985
00:37:22,714 --> 00:37:23,932
but that's not why

986
00:37:25,186 --> 00:37:26,382
abortion is prevalent.

987
00:37:26,861 --> 00:37:28,956
It's abortion is prevalent is because

988
00:37:31,184 --> 00:37:33,661
Women don't wanna have a kid when they

989
00:37:33,661 --> 00:37:34,460
happen to get pregnant.

990
00:37:35,099 --> 00:37:37,177
They wanna live their life. They have personal

991
00:37:37,177 --> 00:37:38,536
values. They're pursuing the happiness.

992
00:37:40,543 --> 00:37:43,429
But that is so radical. That is so

993
00:37:43,485 --> 00:37:45,417
individualistic. That is so

994
00:37:45,951 --> 00:37:47,621
requires a concept of individual rights.

995
00:37:48,274 --> 00:37:50,748
And so requires a real understanding of the

996
00:37:50,748 --> 00:37:51,487
pursuit of happiness

997
00:37:52,344 --> 00:37:53,222
that he's too early.

998
00:37:55,376 --> 00:37:55,855
Too early.

999
00:37:56,670 --> 00:37:57,549
So I wish him luck,

1000
00:37:58,269 --> 00:37:59,630
and I'm hoping to meet him,

1001
00:38:00,269 --> 00:38:01,869
but I, you know, I hope I hope

1002
00:38:01,869 --> 00:38:03,309
he succeeds in Argentina.

1003
00:38:04,202 --> 00:38:06,755
But I just... It's not gonna spread globally.

1004
00:38:06,994 --> 00:38:08,828
This is not the beginning of a of

1005
00:38:08,828 --> 00:38:10,743
some kind of free market revolution in the

1006
00:38:10,743 --> 00:38:12,418
world. It ain't happening.

1007
00:38:14,184 --> 00:38:16,565
And what's missing is that consistency.

1008
00:38:17,358 --> 00:38:19,365
What's missing is is that

1009
00:38:19,976 --> 00:38:20,476
understanding

1010
00:38:21,263 --> 00:38:23,254
And I don't think Melee has it and

1011
00:38:23,254 --> 00:38:24,529
certainly the culture doesn't have it.

1012
00:38:25,246 --> 00:38:26,782
And I don't think the culture is ready

1013
00:38:26,839 --> 00:38:27,078
for it.

1014
00:38:28,606 --> 00:38:30,438
And that's what we need new intellectual full.

1015
00:38:31,951 --> 00:38:33,941
What we need right now is to get

1016
00:38:33,941 --> 00:38:35,613
these ideas into the culture.

1017
00:38:36,664 --> 00:38:39,139
What we need right now is to convince

1018
00:38:39,139 --> 00:38:39,639
people

1019
00:38:40,256 --> 00:38:42,092
of the values of the enlightenment,

1020
00:38:43,849 --> 00:38:44,806
reinforced with Ina rand.

1021
00:38:46,739 --> 00:38:48,420
Solidified by Ai man's philosophy.

1022
00:38:49,300 --> 00:38:51,219
We need objectives to intellectual to go out

1023
00:38:51,219 --> 00:38:53,380
and into the culture and prepare the culture

1024
00:38:53,380 --> 00:38:54,420
for political leaders,

1025
00:38:55,233 --> 00:38:56,689
who will be far more consistent

1026
00:38:57,543 --> 00:39:00,651
and will have traction in the population because

1027
00:39:00,651 --> 00:39:01,607
of their consistency,

1028
00:39:02,483 --> 00:39:04,316
because of their advocacy for rights.

1029
00:39:05,528 --> 00:39:07,127
And we need leaders who can do that,

1030
00:39:07,846 --> 00:39:10,244
not when the economy has 200 percent inflation

1031
00:39:10,244 --> 00:39:12,402
and everything everybody's going bankrupt and it's the

1032
00:39:12,402 --> 00:39:14,160
end and what the hell let's flip a

1033
00:39:14,160 --> 00:39:15,713
coin. And go with

1034
00:39:16,570 --> 00:39:17,767
the crazy economist.

1035
00:39:18,246 --> 00:39:21,539
Right, who who is super radical. But because

1036
00:39:22,396 --> 00:39:23,216
what these

1037
00:39:23,529 --> 00:39:25,523
political leaders are advocating is true.

1038
00:39:27,039 --> 00:39:29,752
We need new founding fathers in that sense.

1039
00:39:31,599 --> 00:39:33,983
Who can change a culture and build a

1040
00:39:33,983 --> 00:39:34,960
new political

1041
00:39:35,493 --> 00:39:36,367
political reality,

1042
00:39:36,844 --> 00:39:37,957
a new political reality.

1043
00:39:38,528 --> 00:39:41,173
That is grounded in a proper philosophy

1044
00:39:41,706 --> 00:39:43,080
and brings back

1045
00:39:43,851 --> 00:39:45,043
the enlightenment ideas.

1046
00:39:45,854 --> 00:39:47,610
That brings back reason,

1047
00:39:49,366 --> 00:39:50,026
individual ism

1048
00:39:50,563 --> 00:39:52,420
and real political liberty grounded

1049
00:39:52,878 --> 00:39:53,916
individual individual rights.

1050
00:39:54,568 --> 00:39:54,887
Thank you.

1051
00:40:02,130 --> 00:40:03,563
Alright, we got time for questions.

1052
00:40:04,931 --> 00:40:05,965
20 minutes for questions.

1053
00:40:06,523 --> 00:40:07,318
That's how I like it.

1054
00:40:08,831 --> 00:40:10,582
So microphone is here. No. You have to

1055
00:40:10,582 --> 00:40:11,139
go up to Mike.

1056
00:40:12,492 --> 00:40:12,890
Right here.

1057
00:40:17,372 --> 00:40:17,851
Get in line.

1058
00:40:30,734 --> 00:40:32,574
The microphone for the questions is off.

1059
00:40:35,463 --> 00:40:36,181
Can you turn down?

1060
00:40:40,088 --> 00:40:41,205
Oh, There we go. Okay. Right.

1061
00:40:45,684 --> 00:40:46,184
So

1062
00:40:46,799 --> 00:40:48,951
I have observe a lot of people from

1063
00:40:48,951 --> 00:40:51,987
different countries with you know, my age and

1064
00:40:51,987 --> 00:40:53,178
my education background.

1065
00:40:53,734 --> 00:40:55,719
And 1 thing I really tend to notice

1066
00:40:55,719 --> 00:40:57,862
is that good times create weak men.

1067
00:40:58,910 --> 00:41:00,919
Yeah. Like, I Like, I I compare,

1068
00:41:01,452 --> 00:41:03,755
I I compare most of the... My Eastern

1069
00:41:03,914 --> 00:41:06,774
European acquaintances and the my American acquaintances is.

1070
00:41:07,409 --> 00:41:07,909
And

1071
00:41:08,219 --> 00:41:11,164
You know, like... And my eastern European acquaintances

1072
00:41:11,164 --> 00:41:14,290
is aren't into socialism. They aren't into pac,

1073
00:41:15,143 --> 00:41:15,643
whereas

1074
00:41:16,033 --> 00:41:18,489
Most of my American acquaintances are so well

1075
00:41:18,489 --> 00:41:21,130
defended that they don't know they are being

1076
00:41:21,184 --> 00:41:21,581
defended.

1077
00:41:22,373 --> 00:41:22,873
So

1078
00:41:23,579 --> 00:41:25,280
which makes me a little pessimistic

1079
00:41:25,579 --> 00:41:25,739
like,

1080
00:41:26,380 --> 00:41:28,800
do people have to learn the lesson

1081
00:41:29,179 --> 00:41:31,099
the hard way because if we're trying to

1082
00:41:31,099 --> 00:41:33,827
achieve a better society a better society. Like,

1083
00:41:33,985 --> 00:41:36,213
how do we educate people on this sort

1084
00:41:36,213 --> 00:41:38,282
of stuff without having people learn it in

1085
00:41:38,282 --> 00:41:38,679
hallway?

1086
00:41:39,889 --> 00:41:40,389
So,

1087
00:41:41,402 --> 00:41:44,132
you know, people don't tend to learn

1088
00:41:44,588 --> 00:41:47,058
from experience. If they did China would be

1089
00:41:47,058 --> 00:41:48,253
in a lot better shape than it is

1090
00:41:48,253 --> 00:41:51,209
right now. Right? The Chinese live through mao.

1091
00:41:51,368 --> 00:41:53,275
Why they wanna living that? Why did they

1092
00:41:53,275 --> 00:41:54,784
wanna relive that? Right?

1093
00:41:56,626 --> 00:41:57,998
The Eastern Europeans

1094
00:41:58,370 --> 00:42:00,353
live through communism. They know what they hate.

1095
00:42:01,225 --> 00:42:02,890
But they also have the benefit of being

1096
00:42:02,890 --> 00:42:03,842
next to Western Europe.

1097
00:42:04,891 --> 00:42:07,540
And seeing what's available and seeing what's possible

1098
00:42:07,597 --> 00:42:09,370
and having the impact

1099
00:42:09,826 --> 00:42:11,815
of enlightenment ideas on them.

1100
00:42:14,775 --> 00:42:17,718
Now it... America is weak, but it's not

1101
00:42:17,718 --> 00:42:20,025
weak because it hasn't been authoritarian.

1102
00:42:21,074 --> 00:42:23,387
It's weak because the ideas that made it

1103
00:42:23,387 --> 00:42:24,983
great have gone un unaffected.

1104
00:42:26,019 --> 00:42:28,811
Nobody is defending them. And it doesn't a...

1105
00:42:29,050 --> 00:42:32,172
It shouldn't surprise anybody that the common election

1106
00:42:32,172 --> 00:42:34,241
is between a nothing like Trump and a

1107
00:42:34,241 --> 00:42:35,116
nothing like Biden.

1108
00:42:36,070 --> 00:42:38,775
When over the last 50 years, we've had

1109
00:42:38,775 --> 00:42:39,784
nothing intellectual,

1110
00:42:40,221 --> 00:42:43,498
nothing ness. Right? So there there is no

1111
00:42:45,299 --> 00:42:45,799
intellectual

1112
00:42:46,410 --> 00:42:46,727
support.

1113
00:42:47,859 --> 00:42:51,054
Intellectual reinforcement for good ideas in America and

1114
00:42:51,054 --> 00:42:53,530
those good ideas. And given the the the

1115
00:42:53,530 --> 00:42:54,030
the

1116
00:42:54,424 --> 00:42:56,582
awful educational system in America, which is worse

1117
00:42:56,582 --> 00:42:58,201
in many of respects. And I think European

1118
00:42:58,420 --> 00:42:58,900
educational system.

1119
00:42:59,858 --> 00:43:01,237
You've just seen a

1120
00:43:01,697 --> 00:43:03,590
deterioration and values the deterioration in

1121
00:43:04,106 --> 00:43:06,090
determination. I don't think it's the the the

1122
00:43:06,090 --> 00:43:07,543
fact that they're not challenged,

1123
00:43:08,551 --> 00:43:11,274
you know, by nature right now because

1124
00:43:11,663 --> 00:43:14,207
The reality is that we most challenged by

1125
00:43:14,207 --> 00:43:14,445
nature,

1126
00:43:15,241 --> 00:43:16,218
life was tough

1127
00:43:17,467 --> 00:43:19,398
before the enlightenment. Right? And

1128
00:43:20,185 --> 00:43:21,775
didn't lead... I mean the dark ages were

1129
00:43:21,775 --> 00:43:23,286
dark for very, very long time. In it's

1130
00:43:23,286 --> 00:43:24,398
spite of the fact that you think they'd

1131
00:43:24,398 --> 00:43:26,465
be motivated not to be dark anymore. So

1132
00:43:26,465 --> 00:43:27,394
it's it's it's

1133
00:43:27,753 --> 00:43:30,139
That's not what motivates us. It's ideas that

1134
00:43:30,139 --> 00:43:30,775
drive history.

1135
00:43:31,411 --> 00:43:33,240
And ideas have being rotten for the last

1136
00:43:33,240 --> 00:43:34,911
50 years. So, yeah, you get Rotten people.

1137
00:43:35,150 --> 00:43:35,786
There's a consequence.

1138
00:43:36,199 --> 00:43:38,836
That advantage again the the Eastern Europeans is

1139
00:43:38,836 --> 00:43:39,736
they've seen

1140
00:43:40,515 --> 00:43:43,552
the better. They've seen wars, and they can

1141
00:43:43,552 --> 00:43:44,990
look and they can see the better.

1142
00:43:45,564 --> 00:43:46,998
So for a while, that'll hold them up.

1143
00:43:47,157 --> 00:43:49,786
And and, you know, Poland right now is

1144
00:43:50,185 --> 00:43:52,916
is doing fairly well, and they're investing hugely

1145
00:43:53,132 --> 00:43:55,616
in the military. And there's a clear reason

1146
00:43:55,616 --> 00:43:56,013
and why.

1147
00:43:56,728 --> 00:43:58,713
Right? Putin sanders is right there. And and

1148
00:43:58,713 --> 00:43:59,213
notice

1149
00:43:59,745 --> 00:44:02,127
that the country he blamed for all their

1150
00:44:02,127 --> 00:44:03,953
problems during his interview were Tucker,

1151
00:44:04,762 --> 00:44:07,382
was not Ukraine it was not Germany he

1152
00:44:07,382 --> 00:44:10,159
actually gave the Nazi to pass. Who was

1153
00:44:10,159 --> 00:44:10,318
it?

1154
00:44:11,271 --> 00:44:11,826
Was the polls.

1155
00:44:12,637 --> 00:44:14,548
I mean, if there's 1 people that came

1156
00:44:14,548 --> 00:44:16,938
across that he hates in that interview, it

1157
00:44:16,938 --> 00:44:18,770
was the polls. I would be investing heavily

1158
00:44:18,770 --> 00:44:20,523
in in in tanks right now if I

1159
00:44:20,523 --> 00:44:20,921
was poland.

1160
00:44:21,572 --> 00:44:21,810
So...

1161
00:44:22,684 --> 00:44:24,375
But that won't last

1162
00:44:25,224 --> 00:44:28,004
unless there's an intellectual foundation for it to

1163
00:44:28,004 --> 00:44:29,751
last. So, yes, for a while that keep

1164
00:44:29,751 --> 00:44:30,148
them going.

1165
00:44:30,957 --> 00:44:33,655
But they will surrender just like, you know,

1166
00:44:34,131 --> 00:44:36,115
other countries are willing to surrender, have been

1167
00:44:36,115 --> 00:44:37,861
willing to surrender in the past. If they

1168
00:44:37,861 --> 00:44:39,264
don't have the ideas to

1169
00:44:39,700 --> 00:44:40,438
to bolster

1170
00:44:40,968 --> 00:44:41,919
their self confidence.

1171
00:44:42,473 --> 00:44:42,949
Thank you.

1172
00:44:46,769 --> 00:44:46,929
Hi.

1173
00:44:47,730 --> 00:44:49,730
So I have a question that I I

1174
00:44:49,730 --> 00:44:52,150
have debated about with a lot of objective,

1175
00:44:53,010 --> 00:44:53,510
and

1176
00:44:54,064 --> 00:44:55,979
I still haven't gotten an answer that status

1177
00:44:55,979 --> 00:44:57,436
aside me. So

1178
00:44:57,814 --> 00:44:58,474
there was

1179
00:44:58,851 --> 00:44:59,351
Trump

1180
00:44:59,809 --> 00:45:00,309
says

1181
00:45:00,687 --> 00:45:01,166
repeatedly,

1182
00:45:01,738 --> 00:45:03,565
and it was part of his company think

1183
00:45:03,565 --> 00:45:05,018
in 2016

1184
00:45:05,074 --> 00:45:08,568
and and even now that if the countries

1185
00:45:08,568 --> 00:45:11,164
of Europe want to raise their defense budget

1186
00:45:11,284 --> 00:45:12,639
to a certain percentage,

1187
00:45:13,117 --> 00:45:15,348
which is agreed upon in the Nato agreement.

1188
00:45:15,826 --> 00:45:18,136
He will kick them out of Nato. And

1189
00:45:18,296 --> 00:45:19,672
I've I view this

1190
00:45:21,338 --> 00:45:21,838
and

1191
00:45:24,520 --> 00:45:25,020
demand

1192
00:45:25,554 --> 00:45:26,054
as

1193
00:45:27,304 --> 00:45:30,675
completely fine. Like, why should America be altruistic

1194
00:45:30,675 --> 00:45:33,394
country and help countries that don't even pay

1195
00:45:33,394 --> 00:45:34,835
for their for their own defense.

1196
00:45:35,489 --> 00:45:37,589
But a lot of objectives tell me

1197
00:45:37,889 --> 00:45:39,250
no we should defend...

1198
00:45:41,089 --> 00:45:41,589
It's

1199
00:45:41,889 --> 00:45:44,778
the in this context to say when Russia

1200
00:45:44,778 --> 00:45:45,576
invade Ukraine,

1201
00:45:46,213 --> 00:45:46,713
and

1202
00:45:47,330 --> 00:45:48,070
you can't

1203
00:45:49,005 --> 00:45:50,999
leave the countries of Europe alone. There's still

1204
00:45:50,999 --> 00:45:53,405
remnants of freedom over their and Trump is

1205
00:45:53,405 --> 00:45:55,973
crazy, but I think this is pretty legitimate

1206
00:45:56,587 --> 00:45:56,825
demand.

1207
00:45:57,939 --> 00:45:58,439
So

1208
00:45:58,973 --> 00:46:01,776
I don't think it's illegitimate demand. It's just

1209
00:46:01,776 --> 00:46:04,486
becomes illegitimate when Trump makes it because he's

1210
00:46:04,486 --> 00:46:06,001
not making it on the basis of any

1211
00:46:06,001 --> 00:46:07,617
kind of principle. I would even argue

1212
00:46:07,929 --> 00:46:09,925
you could make a legitimate argument to say

1213
00:46:09,925 --> 00:46:11,362
the United states should not even be in

1214
00:46:11,362 --> 00:46:13,299
nato. Nato should be an alliance of European

1215
00:46:13,438 --> 00:46:15,434
countries to defend Europe, and they don't really

1216
00:46:15,434 --> 00:46:18,184
need America rich enough to defend themselves. And

1217
00:46:18,243 --> 00:46:19,680
you guys are rich enough to defend yourselves.

1218
00:46:19,920 --> 00:46:21,856
You don't really need America if you're willing

1219
00:46:21,995 --> 00:46:23,193
to go out and defend yourselves.

1220
00:46:23,991 --> 00:46:25,428
But you need to make be able to

1221
00:46:25,428 --> 00:46:27,516
make a principal argument for why? Which is

1222
00:46:27,516 --> 00:46:29,263
the exact opposite of what Trump does. Right?

1223
00:46:29,819 --> 00:46:30,534
So now,

1224
00:46:31,248 --> 00:46:33,654
there's no question that Europe needs to

1225
00:46:34,107 --> 00:46:36,985
pony up and defend itself better, and needs

1226
00:46:36,985 --> 00:46:37,485
to

1227
00:46:38,184 --> 00:46:40,744
depend less on the United States. The United

1228
00:46:40,905 --> 00:46:42,184
States should soft stop,

1229
00:46:43,144 --> 00:46:45,953
presenting itself as the fend of europe no

1230
00:46:45,953 --> 00:46:48,260
matter what, particularly when Europeans are not willing

1231
00:46:48,260 --> 00:46:49,135
to defend themselves.

1232
00:46:49,851 --> 00:46:51,443
I I think all of that is absolutely

1233
00:46:51,443 --> 00:46:51,682
true.

1234
00:46:52,254 --> 00:46:54,246
It's just when Trump says it, and the

1235
00:46:54,246 --> 00:46:55,761
context in which he says it and how

1236
00:46:55,761 --> 00:46:58,231
he says it. There's no principle behind it.

1237
00:46:58,391 --> 00:47:00,399
There's no reason for it. He's just... You

1238
00:47:00,399 --> 00:47:02,175
know, he he he got a good

1239
00:47:02,552 --> 00:47:04,307
applause line when he went after nato.

1240
00:47:05,105 --> 00:47:06,221
So he he went with it.

1241
00:47:07,179 --> 00:47:09,013
He... There's no belief there. There's no system

1242
00:47:09,013 --> 00:47:09,832
of beliefs

1243
00:47:10,224 --> 00:47:13,258
There's no this strategic understanding of what is

1244
00:47:13,258 --> 00:47:15,813
required. There's no understanding of the difference between

1245
00:47:15,892 --> 00:47:17,569
Western Europe and Russia. There is a big

1246
00:47:17,569 --> 00:47:19,405
difference between Western and Europe and Russia.

1247
00:47:19,977 --> 00:47:22,197
And rest Europe up basically and there's no

1248
00:47:22,197 --> 00:47:23,703
understanding of the fact that we are right

1249
00:47:23,703 --> 00:47:26,795
now, whether we agree or not, we're a

1250
00:47:26,795 --> 00:47:27,112
nato.

1251
00:47:27,684 --> 00:47:29,605
Which means that if Estonia Tam tomorrow is

1252
00:47:29,605 --> 00:47:32,724
invaded by Russia, the Us by treaty has

1253
00:47:32,724 --> 00:47:35,684
to defend Estonia. Does anybody think Trump would

1254
00:47:35,684 --> 00:47:36,244
actually do that?

1255
00:47:37,298 --> 00:47:37,617
I don't.

1256
00:47:38,974 --> 00:47:40,751
So what he's really doing

1257
00:47:41,129 --> 00:47:43,763
is not standing up America. What he's really

1258
00:47:43,763 --> 00:47:45,120
doing is trying to undercut europe.

1259
00:47:45,850 --> 00:47:47,516
So his motivation is not...

1260
00:47:48,151 --> 00:47:50,054
This is what America self interest is.

1261
00:47:51,165 --> 00:47:51,665
It's

1262
00:47:53,009 --> 00:47:55,007
I don't care about europe a Putin? What

1263
00:47:55,007 --> 00:47:55,886
did he say the other day,

1264
00:47:56,605 --> 00:47:58,843
you know, if you wanna invade them fine.

1265
00:48:00,521 --> 00:48:01,021
That's

1266
00:48:01,480 --> 00:48:02,927
corrupt. And he is corrupt.

1267
00:48:03,800 --> 00:48:05,228
I I can agree that he's correct, and

1268
00:48:05,307 --> 00:48:07,212
I can see what you're saying, but still,

1269
00:48:07,450 --> 00:48:09,116
I think when it talks about it in

1270
00:48:09,116 --> 00:48:10,489
does pro, it it says

1271
00:48:10,959 --> 00:48:13,196
We don't need to pay for countries that

1272
00:48:13,196 --> 00:48:14,794
don't pay for them themselves. Absolutely because it's

1273
00:48:14,794 --> 00:48:16,233
a great applause line. I'm mean, and I'm

1274
00:48:16,233 --> 00:48:18,230
sorry. I've I've watched Trump enough to know.

1275
00:48:18,723 --> 00:48:19,755
Like he used to say,

1276
00:48:20,708 --> 00:48:24,042
I saved us from Covid because I funded

1277
00:48:24,042 --> 00:48:26,677
the vaccines and the vaccines are amazing. And

1278
00:48:26,677 --> 00:48:28,744
we saved millions of lives and what happened?

1279
00:48:29,300 --> 00:48:30,253
The audience booted him.

1280
00:48:31,366 --> 00:48:32,478
Trump does not like to be boo.

1281
00:48:33,193 --> 00:48:34,147
Now he's backs.

1282
00:48:35,672 --> 00:48:38,059
He's becoming and and he has lines or

1283
00:48:38,059 --> 00:48:40,605
or your avoids va completely because he knows.

1284
00:48:40,843 --> 00:48:42,832
Right? So he placed his audience and the

1285
00:48:42,832 --> 00:48:46,274
and the line saying, nato, those bad Europeans

1286
00:48:46,274 --> 00:48:47,311
they need to pay for their own defense.

1287
00:48:47,471 --> 00:48:49,386
That got great applause line as you would

1288
00:48:49,386 --> 00:48:51,701
expect. So he's gone he's gone all in

1289
00:48:51,701 --> 00:48:54,359
with it. Okay. And there's no

1290
00:48:55,286 --> 00:48:58,061
there's no actual strategy. I mean, it would

1291
00:48:58,061 --> 00:48:59,251
be 1 thing if it there was a

1292
00:48:59,251 --> 00:48:59,727
strategy.

1293
00:49:00,218 --> 00:49:02,762
That says here's what American self defense requires.

1294
00:49:03,557 --> 00:49:05,307
And part of American self defense means we

1295
00:49:05,307 --> 00:49:07,215
need to bring troops home. We need to

1296
00:49:07,215 --> 00:49:09,044
stop if defending Europe they're enough to defend

1297
00:49:09,044 --> 00:49:09,362
themselves,

1298
00:49:09,933 --> 00:49:11,838
Let's... Here's the steps that we should take.

1299
00:49:12,156 --> 00:49:14,696
It's not what is going on. And and

1300
00:49:14,696 --> 00:49:16,205
look, his attitude to a Ukraine.

1301
00:49:17,889 --> 00:49:18,128
I mean,

1302
00:49:19,246 --> 00:49:21,641
here's a real... I think a real existential

1303
00:49:21,641 --> 00:49:24,755
battle here. This does represent Western of civilization

1304
00:49:24,755 --> 00:49:26,751
versus the barb wisdom that I think Russia

1305
00:49:26,751 --> 00:49:28,994
represents today. And what is... What what is

1306
00:49:28,994 --> 00:49:31,934
he suggesting? It's not just, you know, we

1307
00:49:31,934 --> 00:49:33,524
shouldn't use a make and taxpayer pay money

1308
00:49:33,524 --> 00:49:36,242
to whatever, which is you know, you... It's...

1309
00:49:37,038 --> 00:49:39,186
He doesn't care. If puts in wants care,

1310
00:49:39,345 --> 00:49:39,822
let him happen,

1311
00:49:40,538 --> 00:49:41,333
that's the attitude.

1312
00:49:42,224 --> 00:49:42,864
And that means,

1313
00:49:43,904 --> 00:49:45,924
I I... I'm not standing with Western

1314
00:49:46,224 --> 00:49:47,264
civilization. I'm I don't care.

1315
00:49:49,424 --> 00:49:50,545
I'm stand indeed he likes.

1316
00:49:51,279 --> 00:49:53,351
I mean, he he admire putin. He admire

1317
00:49:53,351 --> 00:49:55,583
she. He admire the dictators of the world.

1318
00:49:56,460 --> 00:49:57,735
So he has no...

1319
00:49:59,663 --> 00:50:02,694
Positive view of Western Europe and even of

1320
00:50:02,853 --> 00:50:04,130
America in my view. He doesn't know what

1321
00:50:04,209 --> 00:50:06,363
America is. Has no conception of America. That's

1322
00:50:06,363 --> 00:50:08,277
why the whole America first is or make

1323
00:50:08,277 --> 00:50:09,807
a america a great to get is such

1324
00:50:09,807 --> 00:50:12,595
a... It's such a really ridiculous because what

1325
00:50:12,595 --> 00:50:13,551
is America Mean?

1326
00:50:14,348 --> 00:50:15,224
What is America?

1327
00:50:15,782 --> 00:50:17,614
I mean, according to technical carlson, it's beautiful

1328
00:50:17,614 --> 00:50:18,331
scenery in God.

1329
00:50:20,180 --> 00:50:22,015
But not according to reality,

1330
00:50:22,493 --> 00:50:24,966
America is the land of the enlightenment. America

1331
00:50:24,966 --> 00:50:26,561
is the land of the declaration of Independence.

1332
00:50:26,880 --> 00:50:28,417
America is the land of

1333
00:50:29,205 --> 00:50:30,735
the constitution, it

1334
00:50:31,503 --> 00:50:33,246
these people have no clue about any of

1335
00:50:33,246 --> 00:50:33,325
that.

1336
00:50:34,197 --> 00:50:36,834
So just and Is that a lot of

1337
00:50:36,834 --> 00:50:37,553
questions you.

1338
00:50:38,432 --> 00:50:40,909
So it just... If you say the right

1339
00:50:40,909 --> 00:50:43,706
things, but for the wrong reasons, there are

1340
00:50:43,706 --> 00:50:45,398
not the right things. They're worse than the

1341
00:50:45,398 --> 00:50:46,994
right thing. They're worse than the wrong things.

1342
00:50:47,393 --> 00:50:48,431
They're the they're worse.

1343
00:50:49,308 --> 00:50:49,968
Because then

1344
00:50:50,745 --> 00:50:52,661
because then the right things associated with somebody

1345
00:50:52,661 --> 00:50:54,992
who's really, really bad with really, really bad

1346
00:50:54,992 --> 00:50:55,791
fundamental ideas.

1347
00:50:56,750 --> 00:50:56,910
Bye.

1348
00:50:59,147 --> 00:50:59,307
Okay.

1349
00:51:00,186 --> 00:51:00,985
My question is.

1350
00:51:01,958 --> 00:51:04,134
About... If you think it is important

1351
00:51:04,751 --> 00:51:07,384
to know where to fight and how to

1352
00:51:07,384 --> 00:51:08,821
fight. I mean, it is worth,

1353
00:51:10,514 --> 00:51:11,255
to fight,

1354
00:51:11,875 --> 00:51:14,934
I would object of, the the objective in

1355
00:51:15,074 --> 00:51:16,135
word on the.

1356
00:51:16,994 --> 00:51:17,494
That

1357
00:51:18,048 --> 00:51:19,794
do you think that there are places and

1358
00:51:19,794 --> 00:51:21,223
on on earth that it is not working,

1359
00:51:21,382 --> 00:51:22,969
and you think yeah,

1360
00:51:23,525 --> 00:51:24,978
just... We sold go gal

1361
00:51:25,588 --> 00:51:26,406
instead of

1362
00:51:28,546 --> 00:51:30,639
give any force on those cultures

1363
00:51:31,174 --> 00:51:32,209
and leave them.

1364
00:51:32,847 --> 00:51:34,757
Look, there's no... It it depends what we

1365
00:51:34,757 --> 00:51:37,080
mean by by fight for. If you're trying

1366
00:51:37,080 --> 00:51:38,114
to change a culture...

1367
00:51:39,228 --> 00:51:41,057
Yeah, there's some cultures that are more difficult

1368
00:51:41,057 --> 00:51:41,456
than others.

1369
00:51:42,251 --> 00:51:43,921
I I think cultures that are that are

1370
00:51:43,921 --> 00:51:45,707
basic oriented we it towards

1371
00:51:46,080 --> 00:51:48,881
western ideas towards the enlightenment are gonna be

1372
00:51:48,936 --> 00:51:49,674
should be

1373
00:51:50,047 --> 00:51:51,158
easier to influence.

1374
00:51:52,205 --> 00:51:54,906
Because there's already sudden orientation towards them.

1375
00:51:57,607 --> 00:51:58,107
But

1376
00:51:59,037 --> 00:52:01,284
but that doesn't mean that any particular case

1377
00:52:02,231 --> 00:52:03,666
And if you can't get to that part

1378
00:52:03,666 --> 00:52:05,657
of the world. You should just give up

1379
00:52:05,657 --> 00:52:08,286
on whatever culture you're in. Latin America, that

1380
00:52:08,286 --> 00:52:09,960
take like in America, for example, Latin America

1381
00:52:09,960 --> 00:52:12,608
is very influenced by by continental philosophy, they

1382
00:52:12,608 --> 00:52:14,685
had very little exposure to kind of the

1383
00:52:14,685 --> 00:52:15,564
enlightenment ideas.

1384
00:52:16,203 --> 00:52:18,621
There's a brief period with Bo. But

1385
00:52:19,414 --> 00:52:21,572
so much tougher because in in a sense,

1386
00:52:22,291 --> 00:52:23,670
everybody there is

1387
00:52:24,288 --> 00:52:25,327
some form of status.

1388
00:52:26,126 --> 00:52:28,535
And in America, there's still a certain level

1389
00:52:28,535 --> 00:52:30,047
of what I meant called the sense of

1390
00:52:30,047 --> 00:52:33,309
life that is oriented towards individual ism, and

1391
00:52:33,309 --> 00:52:35,394
you can capitalize on it. So I mean,

1392
00:52:35,554 --> 00:52:37,631
I could still, I believe the best hope

1393
00:52:37,631 --> 00:52:38,291
we have

1394
00:52:38,750 --> 00:52:40,667
to change a culture. It's also a very

1395
00:52:40,667 --> 00:52:42,425
big country, and that makes it really tough.

1396
00:52:42,998 --> 00:52:44,912
To have an influence in such a big

1397
00:52:44,912 --> 00:52:46,587
country. There's so many intellectual or there's so

1398
00:52:46,587 --> 00:52:47,145
many forces.

1399
00:52:48,341 --> 00:52:50,813
So, you know, I'd say fight where you

1400
00:52:50,813 --> 00:52:50,973
can.

1401
00:52:52,343 --> 00:52:54,169
Or you want to? Or you wanna live?

1402
00:52:54,487 --> 00:52:57,503
Don't don't go... Don't move so you can

1403
00:52:57,503 --> 00:53:00,123
fight. Right? If you wanna become an intellectual

1404
00:53:00,123 --> 00:53:02,920
and, you know, your native language is Spanish,

1405
00:53:03,000 --> 00:53:04,670
and that's where you write best, and that's

1406
00:53:04,670 --> 00:53:06,977
where you speak best, then find a Spanish

1407
00:53:06,977 --> 00:53:08,090
country and do it there. Right?

1408
00:53:08,741 --> 00:53:11,442
Doesn't necessarily mean you have to you have

1409
00:53:11,442 --> 00:53:13,268
to move to the United States. Right? Or

1410
00:53:13,268 --> 00:53:15,198
or or or to move to particularly European

1411
00:53:15,254 --> 00:53:17,739
country. Find where your values are most

1412
00:53:18,288 --> 00:53:18,788
att

1413
00:53:19,485 --> 00:53:20,920
and do the work that you do there.

1414
00:53:21,638 --> 00:53:24,031
You know, the... It's not... You're not supposed

1415
00:53:24,031 --> 00:53:24,531
to

1416
00:53:24,909 --> 00:53:26,743
sacrifice your personal values for the cause.

1417
00:53:27,461 --> 00:53:27,620
Right?

1418
00:53:29,071 --> 00:53:30,427
But, of course, moving to America is not

1419
00:53:30,427 --> 00:53:31,405
a bad idea

1420
00:53:32,022 --> 00:53:33,080
even beyond

1421
00:53:33,458 --> 00:53:33,958
objective.

1422
00:53:34,893 --> 00:53:36,648
Most for most people, not all people, but

1423
00:53:36,648 --> 00:53:37,126
for most people.

1424
00:53:39,606 --> 00:53:42,227
Hi. So I like 2 points that you've

1425
00:53:42,227 --> 00:53:46,119
made that putting primary motivated by hatred of

1426
00:53:46,119 --> 00:53:47,414
the west of the

1427
00:53:47,961 --> 00:53:50,344
enlightenment, reason, individuals and capitalism,

1428
00:53:50,901 --> 00:53:52,092
and the point that you're made in a

1429
00:53:52,092 --> 00:53:52,966
question period that,

1430
00:53:54,237 --> 00:53:55,929
the cuts he he blames

1431
00:53:56,239 --> 00:53:58,465
the most and hates the most in Europe

1432
00:53:58,465 --> 00:53:58,943
is Poland.

1433
00:54:01,489 --> 00:54:02,443
Especially for me As a poll,

1434
00:54:03,492 --> 00:54:05,240
my question rates, the presidential elections,

1435
00:54:05,876 --> 00:54:07,943
whom are going to vote for and why?

1436
00:54:12,647 --> 00:54:15,030
I I live 1 of the great benefits

1437
00:54:15,030 --> 00:54:16,222
of living in Puerto Rico.

1438
00:54:17,572 --> 00:54:19,638
Is you're still in American? It's still in

1439
00:54:19,797 --> 00:54:20,694
American territory

1440
00:54:21,163 --> 00:54:23,476
but you're literally not allowed to vote for

1441
00:54:23,476 --> 00:54:23,954
president.

1442
00:54:24,831 --> 00:54:26,187
So I don't need to make a choice.

1443
00:54:27,782 --> 00:54:29,456
Who would I vote for if I could?

1444
00:54:31,063 --> 00:54:31,699
Not for Trump.

1445
00:54:33,130 --> 00:54:35,775
So I view Trump as the number 1

1446
00:54:35,991 --> 00:54:37,183
existential threat to America.

1447
00:54:38,072 --> 00:54:39,902
Another 4 years of Biden would be awful,

1448
00:54:40,300 --> 00:54:41,595
h, disastrous,

1449
00:54:42,686 --> 00:54:44,197
but not an existential fit.

1450
00:54:45,008 --> 00:54:45,246
So,

1451
00:54:46,121 --> 00:54:47,552
I don't know if I could actually bring

1452
00:54:47,552 --> 00:54:48,426
myself to vote for Biden.

1453
00:54:49,460 --> 00:54:51,367
So I would either not vote or vote

1454
00:54:51,367 --> 00:54:53,434
for Biden, but Trump, I would never vote.

1455
00:54:53,832 --> 00:54:53,991
Why?

1456
00:54:55,123 --> 00:54:57,041
Okay. Thank you. Who asked why?

1457
00:54:58,479 --> 00:55:00,257
Because I said, I think Trump is an

1458
00:55:00,476 --> 00:55:03,047
existential threat to the very nature of the

1459
00:55:03,128 --> 00:55:05,924
American system of government to the very nature

1460
00:55:05,924 --> 00:55:07,921
of the country. And and to the very

1461
00:55:07,921 --> 00:55:08,800
nature of the ideas,

1462
00:55:09,374 --> 00:55:11,445
in the country. He is he is a

1463
00:55:12,639 --> 00:55:14,015
you know, he by

1464
00:55:14,710 --> 00:55:17,816
adopting the America first, by adopting this notion

1465
00:55:17,816 --> 00:55:21,432
of Make America great again. He is promoting

1466
00:55:21,887 --> 00:55:24,510
the very nature of what America is and

1467
00:55:24,510 --> 00:55:26,283
the very conception of America

1468
00:55:26,672 --> 00:55:28,581
by associate himself with a flag,

1469
00:55:29,218 --> 00:55:31,525
and and and and with this great country,

1470
00:55:31,764 --> 00:55:34,230
I think he undermine all the greatness that

1471
00:55:34,230 --> 00:55:34,707
is there,

1472
00:55:35,278 --> 00:55:38,218
He is the ultimate p, the ultimate And

1473
00:55:38,297 --> 00:55:40,204
I think an eye in the ads. Because

1474
00:55:40,204 --> 00:55:42,110
what he really wants is to see what

1475
00:55:42,110 --> 00:55:44,516
he perceives as his enemies pretty much everybody

1476
00:55:44,572 --> 00:55:44,731
but.

1477
00:55:45,624 --> 00:55:46,663
He's not a builder.

1478
00:55:47,142 --> 00:55:48,820
Even though he's a builder. Right? Said, we'll

1479
00:55:48,820 --> 00:55:50,179
say developer. He's not a builder.

1480
00:55:51,298 --> 00:55:53,216
He's a he's a destroyer. And and

1481
00:55:54,175 --> 00:55:54,675
so

1482
00:55:55,309 --> 00:55:57,626
Yeah. III think... And and you saw, you

1483
00:55:57,626 --> 00:55:59,704
know, anybody who acted the way he acted

1484
00:55:59,704 --> 00:56:02,740
after they last election should never be present.

1485
00:56:03,713 --> 00:56:04,931
Just that childish,

1486
00:56:06,264 --> 00:56:07,561
you know, emotional,

1487
00:56:08,496 --> 00:56:08,815
you know,

1488
00:56:10,091 --> 00:56:11,845
disrespect for the entire political system.

1489
00:56:12,338 --> 00:56:15,065
The rigging of it. They've appeal to pence

1490
00:56:15,280 --> 00:56:18,065
to manipulate the system in order to somehow

1491
00:56:18,065 --> 00:56:20,543
get him elected. These call to Georgia. And

1492
00:56:20,702 --> 00:56:23,004
Said, oh, give me another 17000 votes, just

1493
00:56:23,004 --> 00:56:25,068
give me find them somewhere. Right? I mean,

1494
00:56:25,703 --> 00:56:27,609
somebody like that should never be allowed.

1495
00:56:28,259 --> 00:56:30,569
To be president again. I mean, it is

1496
00:56:30,569 --> 00:56:31,547
so contempt

1497
00:56:32,003 --> 00:56:33,596
that he's even on the ballot. It is

1498
00:56:33,596 --> 00:56:35,269
a it is a it is a an

1499
00:56:35,269 --> 00:56:37,914
embarrassment should be an embarrassment in America. That

1500
00:56:37,914 --> 00:56:39,052
he's even under

1501
00:56:39,429 --> 00:56:41,126
consideration. And it says a lot

1502
00:56:41,584 --> 00:56:43,738
about the nature of American politics and the

1503
00:56:43,738 --> 00:56:45,666
nature of the hoping a party today. That

1504
00:56:45,666 --> 00:56:47,891
they voted for. Right? Everybody will tell you.

1505
00:56:48,208 --> 00:56:49,639
It's the party system. They're just 2 of

1506
00:56:49,639 --> 00:56:51,227
them. Yeah. But they they they were, like,

1507
00:56:51,465 --> 00:56:52,919
5789

1508
00:56:54,024 --> 00:56:54,504
candidates.

1509
00:56:55,382 --> 00:56:56,022
They chose him.

1510
00:56:56,741 --> 00:56:58,499
Alright. We have to go. Yeah. Yeah.

1511
00:56:59,537 --> 00:57:00,736
I wanted to ask,

1512
00:57:02,027 --> 00:57:03,480
Well all the

1513
00:57:04,171 --> 00:57:06,157
rational people in the world, of I... I

1514
00:57:06,157 --> 00:57:09,333
mean, when the war in israel started, you

1515
00:57:09,333 --> 00:57:12,320
know, when everyone sold all the atrocities.

1516
00:57:13,416 --> 00:57:16,151
I I thought to myself, now they'll

1517
00:57:16,529 --> 00:57:18,147
pro peep probably

1518
00:57:18,859 --> 00:57:23,103
people who are rational or semi rational kinda

1519
00:57:23,240 --> 00:57:24,297
who see that

1520
00:57:24,753 --> 00:57:27,701
and say in and and say, well, I

1521
00:57:27,701 --> 00:57:29,466
can't deaf defend it or it I can

1522
00:57:29,466 --> 00:57:31,851
defend it anymore, and it was, like,

1523
00:57:32,964 --> 00:57:35,349
when at started it was kinda like that

1524
00:57:35,349 --> 00:57:37,440
sse didn't continue. So

1525
00:57:38,465 --> 00:57:40,236
well well all the

1526
00:57:41,166 --> 00:57:44,186
people where all people who have 1 foot

1527
00:57:44,186 --> 00:57:44,980
in reality.

1528
00:57:46,983 --> 00:57:48,181
They are riddled with guilt.

1529
00:57:49,298 --> 00:57:50,975
So they might have put in reality, but

1530
00:57:50,975 --> 00:57:52,832
they won't stand up and declare it

1531
00:57:53,370 --> 00:57:55,786
because they afraid. They're afraid of the mall

1532
00:57:56,099 --> 00:57:56,656
question. Look,

1533
00:57:58,090 --> 00:58:00,003
the Palestinians must be the good guys.

1534
00:58:01,436 --> 00:58:01,914
The weak,

1535
00:58:03,109 --> 00:58:05,340
and, you know, the the they're oppressed,

1536
00:58:06,234 --> 00:58:07,135
and their poor

1537
00:58:07,835 --> 00:58:10,155
and alt demands that you side with them.

1538
00:58:11,114 --> 00:58:12,875
And I don't think many people do side

1539
00:58:12,875 --> 00:58:13,275
with them.

1540
00:58:14,007 --> 00:58:15,360
But they don't sit with them, but they

1541
00:58:15,360 --> 00:58:17,429
were afraid to stand up against them because

1542
00:58:17,429 --> 00:58:18,566
that would make them

1543
00:58:19,260 --> 00:58:20,294
the opposite of alt.

1544
00:58:21,344 --> 00:58:24,056
That would make them self interested and it

1545
00:58:24,056 --> 00:58:24,795
they're riddled

1546
00:58:25,331 --> 00:58:25,730
and fear.

1547
00:58:26,767 --> 00:58:28,362
Fear of that you might wanna step away

1548
00:58:28,362 --> 00:58:29,398
from the mic because I I don't know

1549
00:58:29,398 --> 00:58:30,650
how it's resonating, but

1550
00:58:32,354 --> 00:58:36,026
yeah. It's it's shocking and outrageous and stunning

1551
00:58:36,319 --> 00:58:38,064
that so few people stood.

1552
00:58:39,034 --> 00:58:41,931
By Israel after October seventh, and it's stunning

1553
00:58:42,309 --> 00:58:43,848
that so many people

1554
00:58:44,387 --> 00:58:45,766
went out immediately

1555
00:58:46,559 --> 00:58:48,556
to side with the Palestinians. And that the

1556
00:58:48,556 --> 00:58:50,633
voices against them will ultimately muted.

1557
00:58:52,071 --> 00:58:52,471
And

1558
00:58:53,683 --> 00:58:55,041
you know, if I can if I can

1559
00:58:55,041 --> 00:58:56,238
just, you know, just this...

1560
00:58:58,234 --> 00:58:59,830
And I know this will offend some of

1561
00:58:59,830 --> 00:59:00,948
you, but so be it,

1562
00:59:04,076 --> 00:59:05,213
you know, a

1563
00:59:05,591 --> 00:59:07,687
1 of the best reasons in the world

1564
00:59:07,745 --> 00:59:09,421
never to call yourself a libertarian.

1565
00:59:11,590 --> 00:59:13,287
Never to call yourself a libertarian

1566
00:59:13,905 --> 00:59:14,405
is

1567
00:59:15,341 --> 00:59:17,756
the response of the American libertarian

1568
00:59:18,068 --> 00:59:20,076
party and it's into... In its leaders

1569
00:59:20,607 --> 00:59:21,321
to what happened.

1570
00:59:22,035 --> 00:59:25,050
Because they didn't just not comment. They clearly

1571
00:59:25,050 --> 00:59:25,922
cited with hamas.

1572
00:59:26,734 --> 00:59:29,295
And that is such a betrayal of liberty,

1573
00:59:30,574 --> 00:59:31,394
of freedom

1574
00:59:32,255 --> 00:59:34,594
of the values of the enlightenment that supposedly

1575
00:59:34,734 --> 00:59:36,847
at some point And 1 of the reasons

1576
00:59:37,065 --> 00:59:38,900
I am much more sympathetic than me that

1577
00:59:38,900 --> 00:59:41,133
it would be generally is the mille didn't

1578
00:59:41,133 --> 00:59:43,446
fall for them. Mila actually stood with Israel

1579
00:59:43,446 --> 00:59:44,642
and this stands with Ukraine.

1580
00:59:45,694 --> 00:59:47,524
In a opposition to the leaders of the

1581
00:59:47,524 --> 00:59:49,672
libertarian party in the United States who will

1582
00:59:49,672 --> 00:59:53,252
betrayed everything they supposedly claim to stand for.

1583
00:59:53,332 --> 00:59:54,286
And this has shown them.

1584
00:59:55,096 --> 00:59:55,596
Naked

1585
00:59:56,682 --> 00:59:58,744
as anti liberty, anti freedom,

1586
00:59:59,378 --> 01:00:01,440
anti everything the west stands for.

1587
01:00:03,441 --> 01:00:05,352
And therefore of the enemy, part of the

1588
01:00:05,352 --> 01:00:05,671
enemy.

1589
01:00:06,387 --> 01:00:08,481
So I'm all getting involved

1590
01:00:09,255 --> 01:00:11,166
politically and doing what you can politically,

1591
01:00:11,739 --> 01:00:14,291
but the label libertarian was already tainted.

1592
01:00:15,408 --> 01:00:15,908
Now

1593
01:00:16,285 --> 01:00:17,801
I don't know how you ever recover from

1594
01:00:17,801 --> 01:00:19,795
that taint and Niko are saying, I have

1595
01:00:19,795 --> 01:00:21,071
to stop. So thank you.

1596
01:00:26,924 --> 01:00:28,525
Thank you for listening to the Ina Rand

1597
01:00:28,525 --> 01:00:30,055
in youtube live podcast podcasts.

1598
01:00:30,852 --> 01:00:33,324
Remember to subscribe wherever you listen. You can

1599
01:00:33,324 --> 01:00:35,476
also find this on Youtube. If you like

1600
01:00:35,476 --> 01:00:37,882
this content, please share or leave us review.

1601
01:00:38,519 --> 01:00:41,385
For more information, go to rand dot.